Those representing the interests of mobile home park owners in Chula Vista paid people to attend two recent meetings where the City Council voted to allow those owners to increase rent whenever a mobile home is sold.
In a packed City Hall on July 12, council members made changes to the city’s mobile home rent review ordinance known as “vacancy decontrol,” in which a form of rent control continues for current space renters but not future ones.
About 100 of the nearly 300 people in the audience were paid $20 each to attend and support the revised ordinance. Around 50 who came to the second reading of the ordinance July 19 were paid $40 each to sit in the council chambers as “seat savers.”
In the crowd July 12, a large group of young people wore green “Yes on Vacancy Decontrol” stickers in support of the changes.
Some of those attendees told other audience members they were with “the Young Republicans of El Cajon” and that they were each paid $20 to attend.
At a second reading the following week, Chula Vista resident Ray McMurty, 62, said he received $40 for attending the meeting from a representative of the Republican Party. McMurty is a resident of the Rancho Bonita mobile home park and says he’s not affected by the new ordinance because he doesn’t plan on selling his mobile home. Most mobile home owners were opposed to the changes.
McMurty is on social security disability and money is tight. He said $40 goes a long way in helping with groceries through the week in his household.
“All I did was wear a sticker that I support the proposition, so I don’t really see any problem with doing that,” McMurty said.
Matthew Donnellan, president of the San Diego County Young Republicans, said he was not directly aware of anybody being paid to attend Chula Vista’s meetings. But he said, in general, sometimes people are compensated for participating at public meetings.
“From time to time, if we’re going out to support a cause, sometimes people give money, like a gas reimbursement, to make it easier for people to come out,” he said. Donnellan declined to say who writes the checks or hands out the cash.
Peter Scheer, executive director of the First Amendment Coalition, a nonpartisan, nonprofit group promoting government transparency, said compensating people to attend public meetings is “sleazy in the extreme.”
“If it’s such a trivial amount, then don’t pay it and see how many people show up,” he added.
The council voted 4-0 to adopt the proposed changes to the mobile home ordinance that the paid supporters were rallying behind. Councilman Rudy Ramirez abstained from the vote.
Prior to the second reading of the ordinance, a South Bay campaign consultant who runs the politically-involved San Diego Group sent out an email obtained by The San Diego Union-Tribune. It informed mobile home park owners that there were “50 confirmed seat savers” and staffing available for the meeting.
The principal of the firm, John Wainio, said he’s been in Martha’s Vineyard since July 4 and was not involved in compensating anyone.
“I never paid anyone and I disagreed with the approach and strategy of paying people to attend,” Wainio said. “The people responsible need to respond to this and defend themselves.”
A law firm representing the Chula Vista Mobile Home Park Owners Association also issued a statement saying it had no direct knowledge of attendees being paid.
“There seems to be a double standard practiced here. While it is customary for labor organizations or groups seeking funding to try to pack the council chamber, an effort to increase participation by property rights organizations attracts criticism,” the statement read.
Penny Vaughn, president of the Chula Vista Mobile Home Residents Association, said she is outraged.
“Almost all of our residents had to sit out in the City Hall lobby on folding chairs and they did not ask anyone to relinquish their seats to the people these items impact the most,” she said. Vaughn also objected to the attendees’ behavior during the meeting.
“That City Hall looked like a Harry Potter movie had just let out. I mean water bottles and trash left everywhere,” she said.
During the long debate, the chambers were so crowded that additional rooms were set-up in the lobby and in a side room. Some people left City Hall saying there were too many people.
Scheer, who advocates for open and transparent government, said paying people to come to meetings could affect elected officials’ view of the public sentiment and change the outcome of a vote.
“If the same person was paying people to go to the polls and vote in a particular way, you might call that a crime. This is only one step removed from that,” Scheer said.
Donnellan said he sees nothing wrong with what is an accepted practice for both Republicans and Democrats.
“I don’t see any particular problem with it, if someone is willing to step up on any side and advocate for a position or item − it’s just giving a voice to someone and it is appreciated,” he said.
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.