Alameda: Council Bolsters Committee That Reviews Rent Disputes

Wednesday, July 29, 2015
Peter Hegarty
Contra Costa Times

The City Council has strengthened the city committee that reviews disputes between landlords and tenants, a move that comes amid reports that rising rents are forcing people from their homes throughout the Bay Area.

The new rules deny a landlord the right to carry out a disputed rent hike if the landlord fails to appear before the committee without giving notice or good cause if a tenant asks for a review. The increase also will be void and will not take effect for at least one year if the landlord does not show.

"It does not solve everything," Councilman Tony Daysog said. "But from what I can see, it's a pretty well-measured, calibrated approach to the rental housing crisis."

The Rent Review Advisory Committee was created in November 1979 to mediate disputes and is made up of tenants and landlords, as well as a homeowner.

Participation is voluntary, and until now a landlord did not face consequences for not showing up if a tenant filed a complaint, which critics said undermined the committee's effectiveness.

Councilwoman Marilyn Ezzy Ashcraft said she did not want to vilify landlords.

"We will only find good, workable solutions if we work collaboratively and avoid accusatory language and actions," Ashcraft said.

The council's unanimous decision July 21 supported a first reading of an ordinance that formalizes the rent committee in the city's municipal code and better defines its duties.

Crafting the new rules follows the council forming a community group of realtors, tenants and others to examine the city's rental market.

The ordinance also comes as a consultant retained by the city is carrying out a study on the impact of rising rents. A report is expected at the end of the year, said Debbie Potter, the city's community development director.

Local tenant Anette Zielinski said her landlord raised her rent 20 percent and she now fears her rent will jump still higher when her one-year lease ends.

"I am at the max of what I can afford," said Zielinski, who is considering moving to Oregon.

Jon Spangler said the committee's powers should be boosted even more, such as by requiring landlords who have given a 30-day notice to help tenants with moving expenses and to fully return their security deposit.

"There's still no way to stop egregious increases and robber baron behavior by people who happen to own property and it just stinks," Spangler said.

Kari Thompson, the former president of the Alameda Chamber of Commerce, told the council that landlords were being unfairly criticized.

"Yes, there are nasty landlords," she said. "There always have been and there always will be."

But Thompson also said the advisory committee was a good way to resolve disputes.

The city will rely on the courts to enforce the ordinance, and a tenant can only use a landlord's violation as evidence in their defense if taken to court over failing to pay a rent increase.

There is no minimum rent increase before a tenant can seek help from the committee.

A tenant who fails to appear after requesting a review without giving notice or sending a representative will lose the chance to dispute the increase. The committee also will take no action if both parties do not turn up.

Under the ordinance, property owners also must inform tenants that their rent can be reviewed through the committee when they make an increase.

Similar ordinances are in place in Fremont and San Leandro.

Councilman Jim Oddie said he hoped to establish a more public process for appointing people to the committee since the rental market effects so many residents.

According to city officials, on average 71 percent of cases that have been reviewed by the committee over the past 14 years have been successfully resolved.

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: