City Council approval of vacancy decontrol for mobile home park spaces
struck fear for the future in many seniors, veterans and working poor,
who make up a large percentage of mobile home residents. The OK was
given in a 3-2 vote on May 4 in which Mayor Jim Wood and Councilwoman
Esther Sanchez voted no.
“I think it’s our job to protect the ordinances,” Wood said. “At some times government does have to step in and protect people.”
There
were 160 requests to speak on the item and an estimated 100 residents
were turned away from the meeting due to lack of space even after two
overflow areas were opened.
At the start of the meeting it was
understood that Councilmen Jerry Kern and Gary Felien did not support
rent control and would likely vote yes.
Residents shared stories
of tight budgets and concerns that higher rent would mean lower mobile
home resale value in an attempt to sway Councilman Jack Feller to cast
the third no vote.
Feller was not convinced that ordinance 16B
was needed. “I think the council was sold a bill of goods on rent
control,” Feller said.
The city code has been in place since 1982
in order to control rates for mobile home owners who must rent park
spaces. More than 2,000 space renters will be affected by the amendment.
“It’s
a vote to confiscate the property of seniors, veterans and widows,”
George McNeal read in a letter written by former Councilwoman Melba
Bishop. “I beg you to put yourself in the shoes of these seniors and
protect those who need our protection.”
Some called the motion a
“backdoor way of stealing” seniors’ property and life savings. “No one
is going to buy a mobile home when they can buy an apartment at the same
price,” Bob Ogle, Oceanside resident, said.
“You’ll be
relegating us to our kids’ back bedrooms, rest homes or worse,” Barbara
McCluskey, Mira Mar Mobile Home Community resident, said. “We all
deserve better.”
The thought of many who spoke is that when the
space rents increase the resale value of mobile homes will go down.
Seniors said they will not have the needed economic return they
anticipated to live on when they sell their mobile homes.
“We
want our independence,” Judy Choitz, Rancho Calavera Mobile Home Park
resident, said. “The aging baby boomers will have no options without
rent control. This agenda item is about greed.”
“I resent having
to stand here and beg for what we thought we had when we purchased it,”
Tom Stanley, Rancho Calavera Mobile Home resident, said.
Mobile
home park owners also took to the podium and said rent increases are
needed to make a reasonable profit and have funds for park upgrades.
“It’s
horrible to own a mobile home park,” John Grant, former owner of
Catalina Mobile Estates, said. “Rent is $162, $195 two blocks from
beach.”
“The owners have no incentive to stay in the mobile home
park business,” Felien said. “Keeping things the way they are is
unrealistic. Some kind of decontrol does the most good for the most
people.”
Council will introduce the amendment on May 18. Residents may seek a referendum.
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.