Assembly bill targets 'predatory equity' schemes

Monday, April 26, 2010
Gennady Sheyner
Palo Alto Online

Spurred by the recent implosion of Page Mill Properties' East Palo Alto portfolio, California's elected officials are
considering barring state pension funds from investing in companies
that rely on displacing tenants to turn a profit.

The proposed bill by Assemblyman Tom Ammiano would prohibit public
pension funds such as the California Public Employees' Retirement
System (CalPERS) and the California State Teachers' Retirement System
(CalSTRS) from investing in companies that engage in "predatory equity"
schemes, which involve forcing tenants out of rent-regulated housing.

CalPERS, the nation's largest pension fund, had committed about $100
million to Page Mill Properties and contributed about $95 million
before the Palo Alto-based firm defaulted on a Wells Fargo loan and
lost control of all of its properties last fall.

Ammiano's bill, AB 2337, cleared the state Assembly's Committee on
Public Employees, Retirement and Social Security last week and is
scheduled to be taken up by the entire Assembly in the coming weeks.
East Palo Alto tenants and community activists joined Ammiano on April
21 in calling for the committee to approve moving the bill forward,
which it eventually did by a 4-2 vote.

"There's no excuse for public funds being used for predatory-equity
schemes," Ammiano said. "They are not only unethical but are unsound
investments that pose serious financial risks."

"Over $100 million of public funds have been invested in companies in
California like Page Mill that have resulted in the harassment and the
displacement of tenants and rent control units," he added.

The bill was taken up just two days after the CalPERS board of
directors voted to adopt a new policy that prohibits investments in
real estate properties that depend on displacements of tenants. The
board released a statement touting the new policy as one that will
ensure that CalPERS capital won't lead to mass displacements of tenants.

"We took some very tough medicine in real estate but are on the mend
and applying extremely useful lessons to greatly improve our systems
and controls," CalPERS Chief Investment Officer John Dear said in the
statement. "Much of the bad news is behind us, and we're
well-positioned for solid performance."

Ammiano's legislation would essentially codify this new policy in state
law. Christopher Lund, Page Mill's tenant and member of the East Palo
Alto Fair Rent Coalition, told the committee that CalPERS' new policy
is a "good first step" but argued that the legislation is needed to
make sure predatory-schemes like Page Mill's don't happen in the future.

"Institutional memory is short, and nothing in the proposed policies
prevents the boards from rescinding the changes when money once again
begins to flow more freely in the real estate market," Lund told the
committee. "Legislation remains necessary to ensure that these policies
stay in effect under the current and future boards."

Lund said Page Mill's scheme resulted in about 1,500 tenants being
displaced through increased rents from their apartments in the city's
Woodland Park neighborhood since the company bought the properties in
2007. The company had also filed a flurry of lawsuits against East Palo
Alto, challenging its rent-control ordinance and at one point seeking
to remove Woodland Park from the city's control.

City officials, tenants and even Page Mill's investors (who have since
sued the company) have accused the company of seeking to turn the
rent-control apartments into more profitable developments. The company
outlined in a private memorandum to its investors its plans to develop
condominiums, community-oriented retail and service businesses in East
Palo Alto. The memorandum became public once the investors turned
against Page Mill.

Dean Preston, president of the tenant-advocacy group Tenants Together,
testified at the committee hearing that predatory-equity schemes are
"premised on abusing tenants." The situation is particularly unsettling
when tenants themselves fund these schemes through their retirement
contributions, he said.

"We believe that it is unacceptable for retirement funds of working
people to be used to displace working people from their homes," Preston
said.

Robert Allen Fisk, an East Palo Alto planning commissioner who formerly
chaired the city's Rent Stabilization Board, testified that the city's
rent-stabilization program has "become ineffective due to all the
lawsuits and the vacancy rates." Fisk, a Page Mill tenant, said the
company tried to raise his rent from $900 to $1,700. He also said that
his building now has a 50 percent vacancy rate.

But others were more cautious about the proposed legislation. Alex
Alanis of the California Bankers Association, said he was concerned
about the "broad application" in the proposed bill. Alanis said banks
aren't always aware of the practices employed by their clients.

Two committee members, Diane Harkey and Brian Nastande, voted against
the bill, A third member, Warren Furutani, voted to support it, but
said he was concerned about micromanaging CalPERS.

Danny Brown, chief of government affairs at CalPERS, told the committee
that the pension fund has not yet taken a position on the proposed
legislation. He said CalPERS agrees with the intent of the legislation
but is worried that some of the language in the bill could result in
reduced investment in affordable housing.

"We want to make sure this does not create a competitive disadvantage for pension systems," Brown said.

Ammiano agreed to work with CalPERS, the bankers group and CalSTRS to
refine the language further before presenting the bill to the full
Assembly.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner 


Help build power for renters' rights: