The second meeting of the Thousand Oaks Rent Adjustment Commission ended just like the first: no decision.
After hearing six hours of testimony Monday at city hall, the five-member panel decided to wait until Tues., Jan. 18 to render a decision on a proposal to increase rates at Thunderbird Oaks Mobile Home Park, a low-income park for seniors where monthly rents range from $373 to $525 for a space.
Commission chair Lloyd Wertheimer concluded the meeting just after midnight after hours of back-and-forth debate between tenants and representatives for the property owner, who is asking to raise rents $261 per space per month.
Thunderbird is one of two mobile home parks in the city—both owned by the same property owner—where rent hikes have been proposed. Under the city’s rent-control law, owners of mobile home parks must file a detailed application justifying rent increases on the basis of improvements made to the property or to recoup a “just and reasonable return.”
On Monday, attorney Robert Coldren was adamant that what his client, property owner Andrew Hohn, was requesting was the “absolute floor” of a “just and reasonable return.”
He blamed the city’s rent control ordinance, which has been in place since 1982, for forcing Hohn to make such a request. Hohn is also asking to increase rents at Ranch Mobile Home Park.
Coldren said that because the law doesn’t allow for property owners to raise rents on new tenants, he’s been forced to charge below-market rents for years.
“If (the ordinance) did provide for vacancy decontrol, we wouldn’t be here, or we certainly wouldn’t be here asking for anywhere close to this kind of increase because we would have been able to raise rents on turnover over the years to incoming purchasers,” Coldren said.
“But because mobile home park residents have forced the city since 1982 to retain no vacancy decontrol . . . you have this horrible problem coming to roost.”
Mobile home parks at Thunderbird regularly valued at $30,000 have sold for $150,000 because of the low rent, Coldren said.
But the elderly tenants who stayed up late to speak Monday weren’t dissuaded.
Most, like 70-year-old Sharon Marshall, simply argued that there is no way they could afford a $261 a month increase.
“How much do they think they need for, quote, a fair and just return?” said Marshall, whose husband suffers from Alzheimer’s. “They’re gouging old people and it’s obscene.”
City staff agreed that Hohn was justified in raising rents at Thunderbird but disagreed over how much.
The city’s recommendation was an increase of $65 per space per month phased in over two years.
Mark Sellers, attorney for Thunderbird tenants, said his clients feel “captured” because they can’t afford the expense to move their mobile home into another park. In addition, most parks won’t allow used mobile homes to move in.
Hohn submitted a statement to the commission saying that as long as he’s “treated fairly” and can implement his rent increase without further delay he would not force a “long-term” tenant in “good standing” out of the park because they can’t pay the rent increase.
Coldren said Hohn made the offer because he cares about people. He’s not, the attorney said, a “greedy” park owner looking to throw people out of their homes.
The commission asked Coldren what constitutes “good standing” and a “long-term” tenant.
Coldren said an example of a tenant in good standing is a resident who pays his or her rent on time. Long-term tenants are those who lived in the park before Hohn’s June application to the city for the rent increase, he said.
“My client’s commitment is designed to allay the fears of these poor folks who are out here facing this uncertain process that’s going on,” Coldren said.
Coldren said Hohn would put that statement in the lease agreement of tenants in good standing.
Tuesday’s meeting will begin at 6 p.m. inside Scherr Forum.
Either party has 14 days after receiving the commission’s decision in writing to file an appeal to the City Council.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.