Black Gold, Red Checkbooks

Sunday, July 14, 2013
Nathaniel Miller
Odessa American

With the increase of money and business coming into the Permian Basin, several Odessa residents are still struggling to find a way to pay the rising rent prices.

In fact, the average rent price in Odessa for 2013 is greater than most surrounding West Texas cities and one major Texas metropolitan area, and almost on par with the state’s capital.

Data from the Odessa Chamber of Commerce’s annual apartment survey showed an overall increase in monthly rent and deposit fees for 79 of the 90 apartment complexes in the city.

The average rent in Odessa for July 2013 was $961, Kathi Vaughn, the economic development research assistant for the Chamber of Commerce, said. The rent for a one-bedroom unfurnished apartment was listed at $779; a two-bedroom unfurnished apartment at $988; and a three-bedroom at $1,404.

Last year, the average rent for an unfurnished one-bedroom apartment in Odessa was reported at $664 and $568 in June 2011.

ALN Apartment Data, a database firm that surveys monthly apartment communities, reported the average price for rent in Lubbock in June 2013 was $689; average rent in Abilene was $661; rent for the Dallas/Fort Worth area was $863; and Austin was reported at $985.

“It (rent) is what I expected,” Vaughn said in terms of the higher prices. “The deposits have gone up, the rent rates have gone up … and you still have apartments charging pet rent to have an animal.”

The largest difference between complexes in terms of rent was between the Andalucia Villas, 5075 E. 52nd St., and Park Bend, 1200 Santa Rosa Ave. According to the survey, Andalucia rent for an unfurnished one-bedroom apartment ranged from $1,394 to $1,729. Park Bend’s rate for a one-bedroom was listed as $400.

Vaughn also said she was unsure of the occupancy rate for 2013, but estimated it was around 98 percent. Occupancy rates for 2012 were reported at 98 percent and 97 percent in 2011.

“It looks like it’s full, but last year, there were not many vacancies,” Vaughn said. “We’re seeing a few starting to open up.”

The State of Texas was listed at a 92 percent occupancy rate in May, according to ALN.

Still, city leaders think things will start getting better in terms of rent rates of citizens.

During Tuesday’s Odessa City Council meeting, Director of Economic Development Guy Andrews said the current estimated population for the city is 140,200. Of the 79 complexes that participated for the survey, only 9,450 total apartment rooms were available.

“I think we’re eventually getting there,” Andrews said, adding there were several apartment complexes currently being built. “We have five big ones (apartments) under construction now and a few more planned.”

SUPPLY AND DEMAND

The way Kerri Hamilton explains it, setting rent prices is out of her control.

“We are on a program that’s similar to airlines and rental cars,” Hamilton, Regional Manager for DEI Communities said. “It’s all based on supply and demand.”

DEI Communities owns four apartment complexes, Hamilton said, two in Odessa and two in Midland. The two in Odessa — The Woodlands, 5050 Tanglewood Lane, and Windchase Apartments, 4100 E. 50th St. — both had similar rent rates at $910 and $965, respectively. The average rent for the apartments in Midland, Windtree Apartments and Polo Park Apartments, was unknown.

Hamilton, who has been the regional manager for two years and worked at Windtree for about 19 years, said she’s seen people come and go out of apartments during the booms and busts. However, the occupancy for The Woodlands was at 100 percent, and Hamilton said the turnover rate for tenants has slowed down.

“I think it’s because they don’t have a choice,” Hamilton said. “When that paper comes and says how much rent is increasing, they’ll go out and look, but things aren’t much better anywhere else.”

Hamilton also credited the staff of DEI Communities for giving both current and potential residents’ good service, even when they know that there’s nothing they can do about rent prices.

“I think it’s the consistency (of the staff) and the friendly environment,” Hamilton said. “They make it feel like home.”

A rent renewal for Sunchase Apartments, owned by Orion Residential, stated a recent tenant’s rent was being raised to $1,375 for a 12-month lease. In the same letter, a nine-month lease would cost the tenant $1,397 a month, and a six-month lease would cost $1,439 a month. For a month-to-month agreement, the complex would charge $2,130. Sunchase is reported as having 300 apartment units.

Several phone calls made to David Pope, Orion Residential Regional Manager, were not returned.

Bernadine Spears with Odessa Housing Authority, which helps low income residents find affordable housing, said she has a waiting list of at least 300 people and hasn’t had any landlords willing to open additional units for families in more than two years. She said most landlords are opting to rent out apartments to residents who will pay higher rent.

“Finding landlords who will sign an annual lease … it’s next to impossible,” Spears said. “It’s the world we live in now and I don’t know if it’s going to get better.”

The increase in rent, however, hasn’t gone unnoticed — or appreciated — by local residents.

In 2012, a local resident started up the social media page “Speak Up Odessa,” a webpage dedicated to highlighting the high rent in the area and urging people to contact their city council members to instate rent control.

An online petition set up by “Nicole,” a pseudonym for Sabrina Woodruff, had 983 as of Thursday. The last update on the “Speak Up Odessa” page was listed on Sept. 19, 2012.

Odessa Mayor David Turner was unavailable for comment for this story, but said during the campaign trail in November he was opposed rent control, arguing it would deter apartment builders from Odessa.

Numerous calls made to councilwoman for District 3 Barbara Graff and councilman for District 4 Dean Combs — the longest serving city council members — were not returned.

Assistant City Manager Michael Marrero said the City of Odessa could not set up rent control, and couldn’t do so unless given permission from the Texas Legislature. However, Marrero said the city has seen “several” inquires from companies about buy land for apartments, and said city officials hopes more units will moderate prices.

“At the end of the day, it’s a market-driven deal,” Marrero said. “I think we’re fortunate to have a great economy … but there’s always a downside, and that’s a lack of housing.”

NICKEL AND DIMED

For many in Odessa, having to balance their paychecks between paying rent and paying for other utilities is becoming more difficult.

A single-mother of three, Christy Smith said she was paying $725 a month for a three bedroom, two bathroom apartment two years ago. When the rent increased, Smith and her children, now ages 17, 14, and 8, moved to a two bedroom, two bath apartment.

Currently, Smith said she’s getting ready to pack up her current apartment and move in with her mother.

“I have to budget between am I going to have enough gas or enough food,” Smith, who said her rent would be raised to about $1,300, said. “I don’t receive any assistance … It comes down to nickel and diming.”

Smith said she works for an oil company, though declined to say for which one. Saying she makes “good money,” Smith said she’s constantly balancing car payments, grocery store bills, electricity, water and school supplies during the fall.

“It’s actually to that point where I’ll go to my mom’s and say, ‘We don’t have any food,’ and I’ll raid my mom’s pantry,” she said.

With her oldest son moving to Wyoming to live with family, Smith said she’s hoping to either get a transfer to Wyoming, or save up enough money to eventually buy a house. In the meantime, Smith said she plans on putting her belongings in storage and begin saving up money and working on improving her credit score.

“It’s people who own the apartments being greedy,” she said. “People who are working 120 hours and can afford rent; they have the money, but they’re not home.”

Samantha Everett, another single-mother, knew her apartment lease with Sunchase Apartments ended at the end of June. What she didn’t know was her rent was going to increase $250.

“I figured it would increase, but not that much,” Everett said. “Last time it changed by $125.”

Moving to Odessa from Snyder for work, Everett said she has since moved her children — 9, 8, and 6 year olds — into a house they are renting, adding the rent is about the same for what the apartment was going to be.

But money is still tight. Everett said she’s planning on cutting off her cell phone to cut back on that bill, bargain shops at the grocery stores, avoids eating at restaurants and goes to drive-in movies instead of movie theaters.

While she isn’t a big fan of the high prices, Everett said she wants to stay in Odessa because she likes the schools her children are in, and wants them to have stability in their lives in terms of friends and after-school activities.

“There’s not going to be any jobs compared to what Odessa has,” Everett responded when asked if she has thought about moving. “The best advice I can give is … don’t give up. Keep doing what you’re doing and just take it one day at a time. There’s only so much you can do.”

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: