The fate of thousands of tenants at Parkmerced is now in the hands of
the San Francisco Board of Supervisors. Today, the Board will hear
appeals of the Environmental Impact Report (EIR) narrowly approved by
the Planning Commission on a 4-3 vote. If the EIR is approved, the
board will next consider, at future hearings, whether to approve the
re-zoning of Parkmerced and the proposed Development Agreement.
The project is fundamentally flawed. Under the banner of “smart
growth,” the developer and the Mayor’s Office of Economic &
Workforce Development (the two are indistinguishable when it comes to
this project) are applying infill development principals designed for
vacant and abandoned land to the demolition and reconstruction of an
occupied community of working class San Franciscans. If they have their
way, they will bulldoze over 1500 homes. The Board must stop this
madness.
The only reason this plan is even being considered is
because it is destroying the homes of working class renters, not
homeowners.
Imagine a proposal to take 152 acres of San Francisco’s Sunset District
(or any other neighborhood) and increase density and transit by
bulldozing 1500 single-family homes or duplexes to make way for new
larger buildings as part of a 20 or 30-year construction project. The
developer would be chased out of San Francisco, and any politician that
aligned himself/herself with the project would be recalled.
Project backers will argue that the city will derive tax revenue and
MUNI investments from the project. This is reminiscent of the
justification used by the U.S. Supreme court in the wildly unpopular Kelo v. City of New London
case. In that case, the Court upheld a city’s use of eminent domain
power to acquire homes for private development on the theory that the
increased tax base provided a sufficient public benefit to justify the
use of eminent domain.
The Parkmerced proposal is similar, except that it is tenants whose
homes are to be seized. Tenants would be forced to endure 20 or 30
years of construction, displacement from their current homes, and
serious risk that the promised “replacement housing” will never
materialize, all so that the City can, in theory, increase its tax base
with fantasy $800,000 high-rise condos at Parkmerced.
Today, the issue before the board is the sufficiency of the EIR. Here’s
a quick guide to some of the major housing-related flaws of the EIR:
1. The EIR fails to analyze a no-demolition project alternative. Given
that the demolitions have project impacts, the failure to analyze a ‘no
demolition’ alternative is fatal to this EIR.
2. The EIR fails to identify how long the project will take. At times
in the EIR, the estimate is 20 years, and then at other times, the
estimate is 30 years. In assessing a broad range of environmental
impacts, a ten-year difference in the project description is
significant.
3. The EIR contains no timeline for the various stages of construction.
As noted by the Planning Department in a memo to the Planning
Commission, “unlike other recently approved development agreements,
under the terms of this Development Agreement, the Developer is not
required to maintain any development schedules or pre‐determined
physical development phases.” Without any guidelines as to when
demolition and rebuilding will occur, the project impacts cannot be
sufficiently analyzed.
4. The EIR fails to adequately address the displacement of thousands of
residents. Instead, the EIR apparently adopts the position that tenants
will be re-housed and therefore are not “displaced,” a position that is
wrong legally (being relocated to a different unit is displacement
under state and local law) and practically (there are serious risks that
replacement rent control promises will never materialize). Other
errors flow from this, including the failure to include state mandated
relocation payments as part of the mitigation measures for tenants being
displaced.
5. The EIR counts construction of new units as a “benefit” but does not
count the demolition of over 1500 rent controlled units as a significant
impact. This massive demolition has impacts that must be analyzed in
the EIR, and any benefits analysis must be offset by the loss of
existing units.
6. The EIR fails to analyze the Development Agreement (DA) in the
project description. As argued by attorney Mary Miles in a recent
comment letter, the “City proposes to enter into a development agreement
that improperly delegates responsibility for mitigating the Project’s
impacts to the developer with no public oversight.”
There are many other issues relating to seismic safety, gas lines,
traffic, parking, historical significance, etc. that have been raised in
the various appeals of this EIR and the comments submitted by the
public.
For those who are interested in these issues, be sure to attend or watch
the EIR hearing today at 4:00 p.m. at San Francisco City Hall.
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.