The past two years have been trying, to say the least, for the California Public Employees' Retirement System.
The $200 billion pension fund, the largest in the nation, experienced
humongous stock market losses in 2008, while the value of its real
estate investments was cut in half in 2009. Critics pounded on
management, some demanding a thorough housecleaning. Some, including
its real estate adviser, San Francisco's Victor MacFarlane, were let go.
This year, so far, isn't shaping up much better. As The Chronicle
noted Thursday, state lawmakers raked CalPERS over the coals for
investing in companies doing business in Iran, despite a state ban on
those activities.
Now it's being accused of being in bed with "predatory investment schemes."
This week, Assemblyman Tom Ammiano, D-San Francisco, introduced legislation demanding CalPERS and the California State Teachers' Retirement System,
"disclose and divest from any investments in companies engaged in
predatory business practices that rely, or result in, the displacement
of residents in affordable housing in order to generate profits for
investors."
Ammiano specifically targeted a $100 million investment CalPERS had in a Palo Alto real estate investment company, Page Mill Properties,
that was making life very uncomfortable in dozens of East Palo Alto
rent-stabilized apartment buildings it owned - raising rents, evicting
tenants, failing to make repairs, that sort of thing.
CalPERS reportedly pressed Page Mill to make some fixes, which it
did, but for both entities the issue has become somewhat moot. Page
Mill's properties are scheduled to go on the auction block Tuesday on
the steps of the San Mateo County courthouse, and CalPERS has written
off its $100 million investment. "These predatory equity schemes are
not only unethical but unsound," said Ammiano.
Page Mill would not comment, but I'm told it's engaged in
discussions with its chief lender, Wells Fargo & Co. Meanwhile,
said Brad Pacheco, CalPERS chief spokesman, "We'll
analyze (Ammiano's) bill with our investment office, see what the
requirements are and take it to our board."
We've been here before: The Page Mill affair is
similar, on a smaller scale, to CalPERS' $500 million investment that
went down the tubes when the owners of Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper
Village apartment complexes in Manhattan defaulted on a $4.4 billion
debt last month. The owners, Tishman Speyer Properties and BlackRock Realty Inc.,
had come under fire for similarly alleged mistreatment of tenants. A
New York court upheld tenant charges that they improperly moved to
raise rents.
As the Wall Street Journal reported in October,
assurances by the owners that they "would be able to convert thousands
of protected apartments to higher market rents ... convinced CalPERS
and pension funds of several other states to make large equity
investments in the deal."
Those other pension funds included California State Teachers' Retirement System, which lost $100 million, and Florida's state pension fund, whose $250 million also evaporated.
"These investments have raised many dimensions at a policy level,
and our investment staff has been studying these investments and plan
to bring a policy to our board in the coming months," said Pacheco.
'Ongoing reviews': Then there's the ongoing "pay to play" fracas involving former CalPERS board member turned "placement agent," Alfred Villalobos, who has earned $59 million in fees on investments CalPERS made in private equity firms represented by his company, Arvco Capital of Stateline, Nev. One of those investments - a 9 percent equity stake in New York's Apollo Capital Management - has lost $475 million as of June 30, according to figures released by CalPERS on Wednesday.
Pacheco noted that Villalobos's $13.2 million fee from the Apollo
deal has sparked an "ongoing review" of its involvement with placement
agents being conducted by a Washington, D.C., law firm, Steptoe & Johnson LLP, and one of its attorneys, Philip Khinda, a former SEC investigator. Pacheco said the review should be complete in the next two months.
Trust, and verify: CalPERS is well aware of the
hits it's been taking, especially financially. However, noted Pacheco,
the fund has earned more than 7.8 percent on its investments over the
past 20 years (up until June 30), more than enough to cover its
members' benefits. "For the long term, we're still well managed."
At the same time, he added, "Our chief investment officer has said
he's looking at every asset class to restructure the portfolio looking
forward."
Blogging at sfgate.com.columns/bottomline. Tweeting at @andrewsross. E-mail bottomline@sfchronicle.com.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the
use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright
owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website
in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in
California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such
copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S.
Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for
purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain
permission from the copyright owner.