Following the introduction of AB 2337, the Socially Responsible
Investment Act, by Assemblymember Tom Ammiano, CalPERS and CalSTRS
recently proposed changes in their real estate investment policies with
the goal of avoiding future investments in deals that rely, or result
in, the displacement of residents in affordable housing, a practice
commonly referred to as "predatory equity".
Predatory
equity is an inherently risky form of real estate speculation in which
investors pay more for rent-regulated housing than can be justified by
the actual rental income at the time of purchase. The business model is
predicated on the eviction and harassment of tenants so that rents can
be significantly raised through vacancy decontrol or so that properties
can be converted to other uses such as condominiums.
Unfortunately,
this practice has become a problem of both statewide and national
importance in recent years, and has in many instances used public
pension fund money as the primary source of equity. Beyond the ethical
concerns raised by such practices, the investments have also proven to
be financially unsound, with CalPERS and CalSTRS recently losing more
than $700 million in deals in New York City and East Palo Alto.
While
CalPERS’ and CalSTRS’ proposed real estate investment policy changes
are an important first step, they do not sufficiently guarantee that
these types of predatory investments will come to a halt.
In
addition to holes in the language of the proposed policies, including a
failure to provide a right of return to displaced renters when
rent-regulated housing is demolished, the fact remains that such
policies can be modified at will by the board. Institutional memory is
short, and nothing in the proposed policies prevents the boards from
rescinding the changes when money once again begins to flow more freely
in the real estate market. Legislation remains necessary to ensure that
these policies stay in effect under the current and future boards.
In
weighing the efficacy of self-oversight versus statutory reform, it is
worth remembering that both CalPERS and CalSTRS were signatories to the
UN Principles for Responsible Investment at the time many of these
investments were made, and yet this particular internal policy
commitment was insufficient to prevent these investments. CalPERS’
controversial investment in Page Mill Properties’ East Palo Alto
portfolio, which has received significant coverage in local and
national news outlets over the past year, resulted in the displacement
of over 1,500 predominantly Latino and African American low-income
residents in less than 18 months.
Most would agree that it is
unacceptable for the retirement funds of California public employees to
be used to displace working people from their homes. AB 2337 would
provide stronger more permanent protections for renters, safeguard
workers’ retirement funds, and introduce greater transparency and
accountability into the investment decision making process, something
all Californians would no doubt like to see.
FAIR USE NOTICE.
This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not
have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort
to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We
believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted
material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If
you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that
go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright
owner