It was another packed house at the Calimesa City Council meeting on Oct. 17 as the council heard a second reading and adoption of the Calimesa mobile home rent stabilization ordinance.
The three-part item on the agenda included adopting Ordinance 316, which amends certain provisions, adopting resolution 2011-38 approving the amended administrative rules resolution 2011-40, which adopts an annual registration fee for regulated mobile home parks and spaces with updated language.
“We wanted to point out there were a couple of things that (were changed) as a result of the city councils action,” said Assistant City Attorney Amy Greyson. “We took direction from city council that you did not want park owners charging a late fee to the residents. But the details of that late fee were not specified, so in the text of the rules, we indicated that the park owners could not charge more than $1.79 late fee. So, they can not collect more than $1.79 as a late fee per space (per month). The maximum late fee per year per space would be $21.41.”
The staff report also addressed possible alternatives in the annual increase methodology rent and vacancy provisions.
Several park owners spoke against the amended resolutions and were in favor of full vacancy de-control. Many said the ordinance as written was unfair.
“The only park in Calimesa with vacancy de-control is Plantation on the Lakes,” said Big Oaks Garden Mobile Home Park owner Dennis Sullivan. “It should be corrected since you are reviewing rent control. This city council should want to treat all the parks equal. The facts show that vacancy de-control works.”
Rancho Calimesa owner James Overturf spoke in support of rent control and against the many “proposed changes” that were listed in the agenda as alternatives for council to consider.
“Park owners are pressuring the council to change the rules of this ordinance even though it has worked well for 21 years,” said Overturf. “The sneakiest and meanest proposal is to end vacancy rent control. Sounds nice, but without rent control the sales prices would plummet. No prospective buyer would make a substantial purchase investment with no assurance of a fixed and fair space rent.”
He received loud applause from the audience, which was mostly mobile home park residents.
“We are not talking about doing away with the ordinance,” said Councilman Jim Hyatt. “We’ve had again repeated requests to go 100 percent of CPI and do away with vacancy control. So, in essence we are not trying to change anything — we are trying to fine-tune it. I think your concern is that we are going to do away with it, thats not on the agenda tonight. The park owners are arguing their point.”
Overturf said he read the lengthy agenda packet and misunderstood that those “options” of ending vacancy de-control were on the table.
“What the city attorney does is to try to give us options, but they are only options,” said Calimesa Mayor Ella Zanowic.
The city staff reiterated the fact that the only three items that would be voted on at the meeting would be the three mentioned at the beginning of the meeting.
The second reading and adoption of the ordinance, adoption of the revised registration fee and adoption of administrative rules all were adopted.
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.