Calpers
took a hit last year when its investment in Manhattan's Peter Cooper
Village and Stuyvesant Town apartment complex collapsed. But Stuyvesant
Town wasn't the huge pension fund's only foray into real-estate
investments that involved ousting low-rent tenants.
The California Public Employees' Retirement System has partnered
with firms that have bought and converted rent-regulated buildings in
East Palo Alto, Calif., and in other New York City neighborhoods,
including Harlem and Manhattan's Upper East Side.
Some deals have led to losses; at least one has paid off. But
whatever the investment result, the conversion of low-rent properties
to market-rent apartments—and ejection of some tenants in the
process—is raising concerns within and beyond Calpers about its role in
these deals.
"These historical investments were made under previous investment
leaders" and outside managers who handle Calpers real-estate
investments, says Calpers spokesman Brad Pacheco. "Nevertheless, our
current investment staff has this issue under study, and hopes to bring
forward a policy discussion in the months ahead."
Calpers has been a passive investor in the deals; representatives of
the fund have said that in some cases, Calpers was unaware of tenants'
complaints.
Calpers, which manages about $200 billion in retirees' money and
other benefits for public employees, prides itself on taking a
leadership role in promoting socially responsible investing.
Some detractors say deals that involve ousting tenants conflicts with that mission.
"This investment strategy undermines exactly the type of affordable
housing that [public pension fund] employees need," says Benjamin
Dulchin, executive director of the Association for Neighborhood and
Housing Development, which represents housing-advocacy groups.
Former New York City Comptroller William Thompson in 2007 signed a
public commitment on behalf of New York City pension funds not to put
future money toward this strategy. He sent a letter in 2008 to Calpers
and other major U.S. public pension funds, urging them to "decline
investments in individual properties that might adversely affect
tenants and affordability."
In these types of real-estate deals, which detractors call
"predatory equity," investors borrow funds to buy the buildings and
then try to make money by getting the buildings to operate more
profitably, primarily by raising rents.
Rent-regulated units generally can be raised to the market rate
after a tenant moves out, as long as the landlord makes sufficient
improvements to the apartment. But waiting for apartments to become
vacant may not be profitable for investors who do these types of deals,
given interest due on the money borrowed to buy the building.
So owners often try to move out a number of tenants quickly, for
example by trying to identify tenants occupying the apartments
illegally. Real-estate investment firms that have done these types of
deals generally say evicted tenants often weren't the lease holders or
weren't using the apartment as their primary residence—both potential
rent-law violations.
Tenants often maintain they resided legally and were harassed or
intimidated by new owners in hopes of getting them to leave
voluntarily. Other times, owners have looked for possible ambiguities
in rent-control laws that might justify a rent increase, tenants say.
Sometimes, lower-income and non-English-speaking tenants are reluctant
to challenge these abrupt increases in court, say affordable-housing
advocates.
In 2006, Calpers invested $100 million in an apartment-complex purchase in East Palo Alto, Calif.
Tenants accused the real-estate investor and Calpers's partner, Page
Mill Properties, of using aggressive tactics, like failing to fix leaks
or threatening litigation, to make rent-stabilized residents feel
unwelcome, says Christopher Lund, a tenant who has led the opposition
to Page Mill's management.
Eric Oberle, a history teacher, moved out of the East Palo Alto
complex in August 2008, a few months after the new owners raised his
monthly rent to $1,450 from $1,095. Page Mill officials told him that
they had incorporated each property separately, which they maintained
exempted them from rent-control laws.
Before he left, Mr. Oberle recalls the quality of life at his
building deteriorated. "There was a Kafkaesque feeling to it," he says.
"People would park their trucks in the driveway, so we couldn't get our
cars out for hours. The owners removed all trees in front of the
building. They would repeatedly measure the inside of the units, or
would keep checking the gas, constantly invading our privacy. They
wouldn't repair laundry machines, which all stopped working about the
same time."
Calpers's Mr. Pacheco said that after some East Palo Alto tenants
complained to the Calpers board at a December meeting, the pension
staff instructed Page Mill to fix broken furnaces and other damaged
property at buildings.
Sam Singer, a spokesman for Page Mill, said: "The owners are proud
that thousands of residents have benefited since 2006 as a result of
more than $27 million paid for life safety, security and habitability
improvements ... . This is in addition to fulfilling more than 15,000
service requests submitted by residents."
Different tenants had other issues. In late 2008, after two
successive months of rent increases on his East Palo Alto apartment,
from $1,100 to $1,150 and then to $1,200, Sione Mahoni said Page Mill
wouldn't accept more payments from him.
"I gave them a money order" for the rent due, he says, "but they
wouldn't take it. They told me to talk to the Page Mill lawyer. They
told me they wanted me to move out."
He did. Mr. Mahoni, a 40-year-old truck driver born in the South
Pacific archipelago of Tonga, and his wife spent the next week sleeping
in his car. Then they moved into his parents' home, where he is still
looking for work and a new apartment.
Page Mill declined to discuss individual tenants' circumstances. The
firm last summer missed a $50 million payment on the investment.
Calpers values its $100 million stake at zero.
In Harlem, Calpers and its real-estate partner Rockpoint Group were
more fortunate. Rockpoint and Stellar Management bought the Riverton
Houses rent-stabilized apartment complex for $131 million in 2005.
Rockpoint and Stellar refinanced the complex in 2006 with $250
million in debt. Their plan projected an increase in operating income
over five years going from $5.2 million to $23.6 million, according to
an analysis by the Association for Neighborhood and Housing
Development.
"Our models call for a certain degree of bringing units to market
rate with deregulation, but it was only part of our strategy, not the
fundamental thesis," a Rockpoint spokesman said.
The building went into foreclosure a year ago, leaving creditors and
tenants with an uncertain future but Rockpoint and Calpers with a
profit by refinancing years earlier.
Calpers isn't alone among public pensions in this type of investing.
The California State Teachers' Retirement System and Florida's state
pension fund, for instance, have also written off large investments in
the Stuyvesant Town deal. Calpers lost $500 million in that deal.
California Assemblyman Tom Ammiano introduced a bill last week that
would prohibit Calpers and the California Teachers' fund from investing
"in a company with business operations engaged in predatory investment
practices that rely on, or result in, the displacement of persons in
rent-regulated housing." The bill would also require both pension funds
to sell any existing investments that fall into that category.
Write to Craig Karmin at craig.karmin@wsj.com
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.