Can Chiu, Ting Win Ellis Act Reform?

Friday, March 20, 2015
Randy Shaw
Beyond Chron

As San Francisco gears up for enacting Ellis Act reform legislation in Sacramento,  passage likely depends on the city’s two Assembly members, David Chiu and Phil Ting. An Assembly committee killed Ellis reform in 2014 after Senate passage, and winning  an Assembly floor vote remains the biggest challenge in 2015.

Earlier this month, State Senator Mark Leno introduced SB 364 to stop speculator evictions under the Ellis Act. Leno’s success last year in winning Senate approval, and his monumental effort to successfully exempt SROs from the Ellis Act in 2003, demonstrates that he will get SB 364 through the Senate.

How Leno accomplishes these feats is never clear. But you can take it to the bank that Leno will deliver Senate passage of Ellis Act reform this year.

Mayor Lee was in Sacramento on Monday. He made it clear to Senate and Assembly leaders that Ellis reform is San Francisco’s top priority. He told the leaders that he will do whatever he can to help Ellis reform this year, and that he would not stop pushing Ellis reform until it was enacted.

That puts the focus on San Francisco’s Assembly members to win passage in that body.

Chiu’s Commitment

David Chiu has consistently supported Ellis reform. He also backed the anti-speculation tax, Prop G, on last November’s ballot. Chiu pledged during his Assembly campaign to fight for Ellis reform, and is now in a top Assembly leadership position where he can make a huge difference.

Chiu has been centrally involved in Speaker Toni Atkin’s bold plan to greatly increase affordable housing funding in California. That measure is desperately needed and Chiu is to be applauded for jumping into the issue barely after taking office.

But as I read Chiu’s tweets about the housing bill and his efforts on its behalf, I wonder whether he also has the bandwith to lead Ellis reform in the Assembly. Chiu may be too consumed with winning passage of the housing bill to spend the time necessary corralling swing Democrats on behalf of the Ellis measure.

Ting’s Potential Role

Phil Ting was not much involved in last year’s Ellis struggle because proponents  were unprepared for the quick Assembly committee fight after winning Senate passage. But with Leno taking care of the Senate and Chiu deeply involved in the Atkins housing package, Ting could play a decisive role in securing Assembly  passage.

The Assembly has always been more challenging for tenant legislation because so many of its members aspire to higher office, particularly the State Senate. This means that some Assembly members are looking for campaign contributions almost from the moment they take office; coffers that real estate interests are eager to fill.

This problem was worsened by the original term limits law that pushed people out of the Assembly after only six years. But now that they can stay in office for twelve, there is less pressure to fundraise for future races. The longer tenure also facilitates relationship building, a skill Ting has demonstrated since joining the Assembly.

Predicting Assembly votes this early is difficult because of the many newly elected members and the Assembly’s lack of past Ellis Act votes (the two Democrats who killed the 2014 Ellis bill were both defeated in November). We do know that the committee chairs involved with the legislation are more sympathetic. California labor is also 100% on board and intends to work hard to pass the bill.

This means that Ting will have the support he needs to make the strongest possible push for Assembly passage.

Rising Ellis Cases

After a combination of factors (See “SF Slashes Ellis Act Evictions,” January 6, 2015) caused a sharp reduction in new Ellis Act filings, the trend has reversed. This follows the courts striking down the Campos relocation measure, the defeat of Prop G, and the failure of Ellis reform last year.

With the prices of small buildings going through the roof on a per unit basis, speculators are paying as much as $700,000 a unit for buildings housing longtime tenants. Even when they figure in steep attorneys’ fees, relocation expenses and one-year notice periods speculators assume that they can sell vacant units in the right neighborhood for $1.2 million apiece or more.

A revival of Ellis evictions makes passage of a reform bill imperative in 2015. With Mayor Lee, Senator Leno, and Assemblymembers Ting and Chiu making passage a top priority, this could be the year that speculator displacement of tenants under the Ellis Act is finally restricted.

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: