Candidates Challenged on 'Rent Stabilization'

Monday, October 20, 2014
Daniel DeBolt
Mountain View Voice

All nine candidates for Mountain View City Council were put on the spot last week during a candidate forum held by church leaders who want the City Council to pass a "rent stabilization" ordinance to put an end to the dramatic rent increases that are forcing many out of Mountain View.

Candidates came to the event Friday evening at Trinity United Methodist Church, not knowing its format, and were asked to sit in front of the stage for a presentation. The event was sponsored by Peninsula Interfaith Action.

"Fear is not dignity," said Saint Anthanasius church member Phil Cosby during the event he helped host with Day Worker Center director Maria Marroquin and others. "When you are afraid of rent increases, that is not dignity. Stability is dignity. Homeowners can plan about their future housing costs" but renters can't unless there's a law that limits rent increases.

A list of cities with ordinances that limit rent hikes was presented, including San Jose, Los Gatos, San Francisco, Oakland, Hayward, East Palo Alto and Berkeley. "All of these cities have given dignity to their renters, why not also in Mountain View?" he said.

Cosby dissected the candidates' arguments against rent control, as reported by the Voice last month. Most of the candidates favor a long-term solution: more residential zoning and slowing down office growth to relieve pressure on the housing market. But "renters have a short-term problem many will soon be gone," Cosby said.

"I don't think the candidates should be the only people up here," said candidate Ken Rosenberg. "Landlords should be up here answering why they are choosing to increase rent too much."

Most candidates explained why they aren't pushing for rent control, to the dismay of many in the audience, most of whom raised their hands when asked if they wanted "rent stabilization" to be studied by city staff.

Candidate Greg Unangst, a retired Army colonel and retired aerospace engineer who owns a town home, was the only candidate open to studying rent stabilization.

"I'm the only candidate who has been advocating rent stabilization," Unangst said. As he's knocked on doors for his campaign, he has noticed that "you can tell the difference in people that own and people that rent. People that own are concerned about congestion, and where Mountain View is going, but renters are scared. They don't know when another rent increase is coming or how much the rent increase is going to be."

"I am living with fear every day that I will not be able to pay the rent for next month," said a single mother of two girls, who spoke to the crowd. "I am living with a fear of needing to leave this place because my daughters were born here. They grew up here and they go to school here. Whenever they go to school I have peace of mind of knowing they are in a secure community."

Lupita Garcia said she pays $500 to share a living room and may have to move to "Los Banos or Merced to be able to live and not have to work three jobs just to live in the area. I never thought Mountain View would get to this point."

"I have protection under Prop. 13 as a homeowner," Unangst said. "There's no protection for the renters, and I don't think that's fair."

Rosenberg had a different view. "We're focusing on the wrong issue when we focus on rent control," he said.

Rosenberg, who has called himself a housing advocate and supports building a new neighborhood in North Bayshore to help meet local demand for housing, said the city could use up to $10 million in affordable housing funds to help renters "today" instead of building costly affordable housing projects. He didn't say exactly how it could be used.

Some big landlords have said that "as a policy they aren't willing to raise rents more than 10 percent a year," Rosenberg said. "Organizations like the California Apartment Association (which represents landlords) should be encouraging everyone to adopt that type of policy."

Candidate Pat Showalter had a similar comment: "We need to get the California Apartment Association to actually police its members and also police people that aren't its members. In their literature they claim they do this. But I don't see much evidence to that effect."

Cosby later questioned the comment about relying on the CAA to police its member landlords. The group also lobbies state and local government on behalf of landlords.

"Why would you want to give the CAA a group that nobody elects power over non-member landlords and not do that democratically through the city?" Cosby said.

As one of the leaders of the efforts to bring rent control to Mountain View in the late 1970s and early 1980s and who lost three bids for a council seat in those days candidate Lenny Siegel said he didn't intend to make rent control a campaign issue this time around.

"I learned the difficulties to pass such measures," Siegel said. "Big landlords spent a hundred to one against us to defeat our measure. The renters who signed petition had to move because of rent increases before we had the election."

He noted that despite rent control in some cities, landlords can still evict tenants to raise rents, though it's harder in some cities than others.

"I would probably agree to study it if people as a community came forward and asked for it," Siegel said. But now, he said his priority, as leader of the Campaign for Balanced Mountain View, is to "bring people together to make sure we deal with supply and demand, which is causing the problem in the first place."

Cosby addressed concerns from candidates that a rent control ballot measure would be an impossible political battle. "The Mountain View City Council could pass rent stabilization and avoid that fight," Cosby said.

According to a questionnaire the candidates filled out before the event, nearly all of the candidates said they had been "undecided" about whether they want city staff to "research rent stabilization for Mountain View." Unangst said he "strongly agreed," while Lisa Matichak and Pat Showalter said they "strongly disagree."

In interviews with the Voice, candidates Rosenberg and Margaret Capriles spoke clearly against rent control.

"I didn't want to support rent control because I thought it wasn't politically possible," Showalter said. "People suffering need to be helped with things we can do quickly. Things that take many, many years aren't really going to help them. I think we can do quite a bit with increasing (housing) supply."

The three renters in the race Jim Neal, Mercedes Salem and Ellen Kamei didn't push for rent control.

"I believe in property rights, but if we are going to have a conversation about rent control, let's have it," Salem said. "As council it's our duty to be the voice of people we represent."

She advocated for the creation of a "rent support group or organization," which sounded similar to some landlord-tenant mediation services already provided by Project Sentinel and the financial aid provided by the Community Services Agency. She called it " a place you can go in neediest of needy times to get support for rent" and financial support for utility bills. It would have "an advocacy component, someone who can fight for you" when it is "between yourself and your landlord."

She encouraged tenants to try to negotiate their rents downward, something she said she has done for herself.

Neal told the crowd that there is "no quick fix" to the problem.

"I know what that kind of hardship is like," he said, adding that he once survived on bread and peanut butter for three weeks. "I know it's very difficult. There is no quick fix. What we need is a long-term fix and one long-term fix is to ensure jobs and housing are in balance. Another fix is education."

If you learn to do something nobody else can do, "you can write your own ticket. Get the skills you need, that will be the thing nobody can take away from you," he said.

Kamei and Matichak avoided commenting on rent control, but expressed their sympathy.

"I spend over 50 percent of my income on rent," Kamei said.

"It was tough to hear women speak about their situations," Matichak said, adding that she had talked to some smaller landlords who don't want to raise rents dramatically.

As to fears that rent control would lead to "slummy" neighborhoods, as candidate Capriles has said, Cosby noted that landlords could still be allowed to recover maintenance costs under a rent stabilization ordinance, and landlords are required to maintain their properties under state law anyway. Even without rent controls, some landlords "are raising rents and do no upgrades on the property," Unangst said. 

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.  

Help build power for renters' rights: