This year's sea change surrounding rent control continues to make waves in the city's mobile home parks.
In the latest development, the City Council will hold a public hearing Thursday to consider repealing the mobile home park rent stabilization ordinance in its entirety.
In March, the city amended its ordinance with the purpose of reaching a settlement agreement with Surf and Sand Mobile Home Park owner Ron Reed, who had two active lawsuits against the city.
Under the settlement, lower income residents were offered 34-year leases with a monthly rent of $475 after an income-verification process. Higher income full-time residents were offered leases that increased rents to market rate for eight years. Rents for part-time residents, and residents who own other residential property, could immediately increase to market rate.
The Surf and Sand residents protested the changes, saying there were insufficient protections for the most vulnerable in the park, low-income families and the elderly.
Many Surf and Sand residents have balked at signing the lease offered by Reed under the amended ordinance. Some, including 23-year park resident Bill Newman, signed the lease but only on the condition that some provisions be removed. Newman objected to lease terms that allowed Reed to redraw plot lines, and, in the case when the home no longer fit within the plot, move a home to a different spot in the park.
Newman, who applied for low-income status, said that because he did not sign the lease unconditionally, he received a letter from Reed saying his rent would increase from $285 to $2,500 per month.
"It's been pretty tough, and some people here are feeling physical impacts from this," Newman, 86, said. "Some people's nerves are so bad, they just can't get over the constant tension. There are a lot of fragile old people here who are at the point in life when you want to kick back and live the rest of your life in peace."
Some resident have filed a lawsuit saying the new provision that prevents mobile home owners from participating in rent control if they have any other residential property violates state law. A second lawsuit, which Newman is a part of, has been filed against Reed challenging the new "market rents."
City attorney John Barisone said in a report to the council that he believes the ordinance will stand up to a legal test, but the ordinance could be repealed to avoid litigation costs, which are why the city aggressively sought a settlement this year.
The city has spent close to $1.5 million during the past decade defending its rent control ordinance from legal challenges, with about a third of that money coming from a legal-defense fee park residents contribute.
In response to the anticipated rent increases from the ordinance amendments, the city entered into a 10-year agreement with the Santa Cruz County Housing Authority to provide $150,000 a year to subsidize rents for low-income park residents.
The city recently closed a deal in which the nonprofit Millennium Housing used a $2 million loan from the city's Redevelopment Agency to buy Castle Mobile Estates.
At Cabrillo Estates Mobile Home Park the residents have entered into a separate agreement with the park owner, Albert Vieira, that has provided some long-term stability and restricted rent increases.
With Capitola's other mobile home parks either city- or resident-owned, Surf and Sand residents are feeling the most vulnerable. The city believes leases under the amended ordinance will stand if signed before a repeal. Yet, like Newman, many residents have not signed a completed lease, and depending on the timing of the repeal may not have agreements in place before rent control expires.
"I'm certainly very concerned about repealing the ordinance," Councilman Sam Storey said. "All of the leases proposed under [the amended ordinance] haven't been finalized, and a repeal could pull the rug out from under the residents who haven't signed those leases."
Yet, Storey added that Capitola is currently in a poor position to handle any unforeseen expenses.
Two flash floods in March caused an estimated $1.3 million in damage to city property. The city has nearly depleted its reserves to pay for repairs, and has not received any money from its insurance company or state or federal disaster relief programs.
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.