The final arbiter on the city's 32-year-old rent control ordinance may be the voters.
On Tuesday, about 20 Surf and Sand Mobile Home Park residents and others protested the City Council's recent decision to repeal its rent stabilization ordinance and vowed to collect signatures for a referendum.
Picketers marched along the sidewalk in front of Capitola Realty, where Councilman Kirby Nicol is a broker, and received constant honks of support from passing motorists.
In March, the city amended its ordinance while reaching a settlement with Ron Reed, the owner of Surf and Sand, who had two lawsuits against the city.
Surf and Sand residents filed a petition to hold a referendum on the amendment, but it was thrown out due to a procedural error.
"We will do another petition and it will be done right," Surf and Sand resident Sandy Williams said. "Everybody in town has been very supportive. It's only the council that hasn't supported us."
A lawsuit filed against the city's amended ordinance challenges several provisions that attorney Maurice Priest say violate state law. The court expedited the trial and set a hearing for Aug. 26, before new rents would take effect on Sept. 1.
After the council's vote to repeal, the city asked to delay the hearing. The court is expected to rule on the city's motion Aug. 22.
The city must conduct a second reading, scheduled for Aug. 25, and then wait 30 days before the repeal would take effect.
Priest said if the court throws out the amendment on Aug. 26, the law would revert to the original ordinance at least until Sept. 24, when the repeal would be enacted.
The city attorneys, from law firm Atchison, Barisone, Condotti & Kovacevich, said repealing the ordinance would moot the legal challenge, but Priest said the case should go forward either way because residents have already been adversely affected.
A second lawsuit, handled by attorney Philip Crawford, has been filed against Reed, challenging provisions in the leases offered under the amended ordinance.
Under the settlement, lower income residents were offered 34-year leases with a monthly rent of $475 after an income-verification process. Rent for higher income full-time residents will gradually increase to market rate after eight years. Rents for part-time residents, and those with other residential property, could immediately rise to market rate.
As of last week, five residents in the 74-unit park on 47th Avenue had been offered the low-income lease. Many residents, the majority of whom are elderly or disabled, signed conditionally, objecting to certain provisions including one that stipulated disputes must be handled through arbitration instead of the courts and another that allows the park owner to redraw plot lines and move homes.
For those without low-income status rents will escalate from as little as $285 per month to as high as $2,800 per month.
Neither Reed nor his attorney, Mark Alpert, returned calls seeking comment.
Nicol, targeted for the protest because residents say he is one of the council's biggest opponents of rent control, also did not return a call Tuesday.
Councilman Mike Termini said he wants more information on the residents' lease status before he decides how to vote at the second reading.
"There is a basic foundation of mistrust between Reed and the residents, and it's hard to get information. We are working in the dark basically," Termini said. "It's true the lease is onerous ... but I think the lesser of two evils is signing the lease, securing rent control and then mounting any disputes."
The city has spent close to $1.5 million during the past decade defending the ordinance from legal challenges, with approximately a third of that money coming from a legal-defense fee to which park residents contribute.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.