Capitola repeals rent control

Friday, August 12, 2011
Tovin Lapan
Santa Cruz Sentinel

Facing legal challenges to the city's recently amended rent control ordinance, the City Council voted 3-1 Thursday to repeal the law in its entirety.

The move, which still must go through a second reading and vote before taking effect, will end 32 years of rent control in Capitola and has residents of Surf and Sand mobile home park in particular worried about their futures.

"The inconvenient truth here is that as long as we have rent control we will have litigation," said Councilman Kirby Nicol, who voted with Mayor Dennis Norton and Councilman Mike Termini to repeal the ordinance. "If not the park owners it will be the residents. It's not going away. The city caused this problem and the city has a moral obligation to fix it."

Stephanie Harlan was the lone dissenting vote, while Councilman Sam Storey was not in attendance.

In March, the city amended its ordinance with the purpose of reaching a settlement agreement with Ron Reed, the owner of Surf and Sand Mobile Home Park, who had two active lawsuits against the city.

Under the settlement, lower income residents were offered 34-year leases with a monthly rent of $475 after an income-verification process. Higher income full-time residents were offered leases that increased rents to market rate for eight years. Rents for part-time residents, and residents who own other residential property, could immediately rise to market rate.

As of Thursday, only five residents in the 74-unit park on 47th Avenue have been offered the low-income lease. Many residents, the majority of whom are elderly or disabled, refused to sign the lease or signed it conditionally because they objected to certain provisions including ones that allowed the park owner to redraw plot lines and move coaches that no longer fit within the new plots. Additionally, residents who signed the lease waive their right to go to court, and must settle disputes through arbitration.

Some residents have filed a lawsuit saying the new provision that prevents mobile home owners from participating in rent control if they have any other residential property violates state law. A second lawsuit has been filed against Reed challenging several aspects of the lease.

Attorney Philip Crawford, who is representing the residents suing Reed, said the city's attorneys, from law firm Atchison, Barisone, Condotti and Kovacevich, did a poor job of protecting residents in the settlement deal.

"Your lawyers are not protecting them, they are throwing them under the bus on this," Crawford said. "Maybe not intentionally, maybe it's just out of negligence."

Over 20 people spoke to the council on the issue, all opposed repealing the ordinance.

Some of those who have not qualified for low-income status have seen rents escalate from as little as $285 per month to as high as $2,800 per month, a figure residents argue is well above market rate.

The city has spent close to $1.5 million during the past decade defending its rent control ordinance from legal challenges, with approximately a third of that money coming from a legal-defense fee park residents contribute.

In response to the anticipated rent increases from the ordinance amendments, the city entered into a 10-year agreement with the County Housing Authority to provide $150,000 a year to subsidize rents for low-income park residents.

The city recently closed a deal in which the nonprofit Millennium Housing used a $2 million loan from the city's Redevelopment Agency to purchase Castle Mobile Estates.

At Cabrillo Estates Mobile Home Park the residents have entered into a separate agreement with the park owner, Albert Vieira, which has provided some long-term stability and restricted rent increases.

With Capitola's other mobile home parks either city or resident-owned, Surf and Sand residents are feeling the most vulnerable.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: