Carson apartment residents are the victims in land ownership dispute

Friday, August 5, 2011
Sandy Mazza
dailybreeze.com

Cecillia Maiava and her husband loaded the last of their belongings into a truck and threw out their well-used couch set on Friday.

The Carson apartment where she grew up with her grandparents and aunts, where she celebrated many birthdays, and where her grandfather passed away, has sheltered its last families.

But now the family is leaving their longtime home, victims of a long and bitter tug-of-war for the property between the the owner of the apartment building and the owner of the land it sits on, Watson Land Co.

Just two months ago, residents pleaded with the City Council to intervene in the longtime dispute between the two entities. They wanted to stop the Watson Co. from tearing town the building, which is owned by San Miguel Apartments Inc.

But feelings against San Miguel have soured.

"We had the feeling that we were fighting the city and Watson because they were the bad guys," said Maiava, 33. "But the (apartment) owners betrayed all of us. They're lousy. I think they're cowards."

Residents in the 64 units at Don Dominguez apartments at 19702-19822 S. Main St. believe the San Miguel owners lied to them, then took their security deposits and left them with little time to move before the buildings will be demolished.

Just a few months ago, most of the residents were furious at Watson and the city, who they believed were heartlessly ripping them from their homes. The landlord had convinced residents that they were "evil people who wanted to throw everybody in the street," said apartment manager Samia Ibrahim.

"I never got the full truth, I always got little pieces," Ibrahim said. "I was promised that I would be here at least two more years. They always told me I was family. Now I don't know who to trust."

Watson took San Miguel Apartments to court this summer because the landlord was not complying with his earlier agreement to remove the tenants and tear down the building.

In June, a Los Angeles Superior Court judge sided with Watson and appointed an independent receiver to enforce the terms of the contract, since the landlord refused to comply.

Watson subsequently agreed to pay for the demolition of the buildings, which the apartment owner was responsible for, said Edythe Bronston, the court-appointed receiver. The company also offered free last month's rent or a security deposit return to residents, as well as relocation payments of $1,500 to $2,500.

"The security deposits, which the landlord was supposed to keep under California law - they didn't," Bronston said. "Watson has stepped up and is refunding all security deposits. It's a very sad situation and we're doing everything we can to ameliorate the pain. The tenants are losing their homes and they just did not understand. They were sold misinformation."

Attorney Stephen L. Joseph, who represents San Miguel Apartments and its president, Ebbi Azzizzi,would not respond to questions about the security deposit and other issues this week.

"Unfortunately, we are prohibited from discussing it with you as there is a clause in the settlement agreement which prohibits San Miguel from having any discussions about any aspect of the property with anyone," Joseph wrote in an email. "San Miguel Apartments, Inc. reserves all rights to sue the Daily Breeze and any other person or entity for uttering or printing any untrue or defamatory statements."

San Miguel Apartments waged an emotional public campaign in March in an attempt to get out of its long-standing contract with Watson to vacate and destroy the buildings by November. The apartments are adjacent Victoria Golf Course, close to two freeways, and near a major planned commercial development called Boulevards at South Bay.

In 1982, the area was rezoned for commercial use and owners of residential buildings were given a period of time to recover their investments before leaving. San Miguel Apartments Inc. took over the Don Dominguez buildings in 1988 and agreed to vacate them in 2003. Since then, they have received several extensions and settled on a final date of Nov. 23, 2011.

This year, instead of leaving, the landlord hired Joseph and hung large banners on the apartments that read: "Don't Demolish Our Homes." They also took out ads and started a website pleading their case. They asked city leaders to give them another extension but were denied. City planners had already penned an agreement with a commercial developer for use of the land.

In March, Joseph told the Daily Breeze that Watson Land Co.'s refusal to extend the landlord's contract was "absurd, it's cruel, it's wrong."

Residents asked the City Council to intervene on their behalf a few months later. Several residents lashed out at the city and Watson, who they believed were actively working against them.

"My parents have been living (at Don Dominguez) for four years now," Leonard Collier told the council. "Now they've got to get up and move and they're disabled. My father has two malignant tumors in his head right now and he can barely walk. My mother just suffered a stroke and heart attack. I wonder why they didn't notify us when they signed the lease to move in. I wanna know which of you five council members are receiving funds from Watson because I know it's a money thing."

Since the landlord washed his hands of the buildings and residents after the court receiver was appointed, families living at the property expressed shock, anger and disappointment. They had believed they would not have to leave.

"I got so many false promises," said Ibrahim, the apartment manager.

Ibrahim, whose husband died in 2005, has three children. She has managed the Don Dominguez apartments for 14 years and has had no luck finding a new job or apartment - and she is expected to move out by Sept. 30.

"I feel like I've been pushed around, so many lies," Ibrahim said. "I told my kids: `Don't worry, I'll take care of you guys even if I have to sweep streets."' 

FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together.  This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: