Chronicle's Coverage of Parkmerced is Embarrassing

Tuesday, February 8, 2011
Dean Preston
BeyondChron

The 30-year Parkmerced development project would have a huge impact on
San Francisco, particularly the residents of Parkmerced and neighbors.
At issue is the future of San Francisco's largest rent-controlled
housing complex. One would hope the City's leading local newspaper
would address the merits of the project in some depth. Instead, the Chronicle’s coverage last week
simply regurgitated the developers' talking points. With this type of
one-sided reporting on the front page, it is no wonder the Chronicle's readership is in decline.

The title of the piece is telling: “Park Merced: Lofty Plan Would Revamp
Neighborhood.” This is not an article analyzing the project. It is an
article promoting the project.

The article does not include a single word about the
financial viability of the project. In January, the City’s consultant
concluded that “based on current and reasonably foreseeable short-term
market conditions, the Project may not be economically feasible.”
Apparently, the likelihood that the promised plan will never come to
fruition, at least as envisioned in the “lofty plan,” is a detail
unworthy of discussion in the Chronicle.

The Chronicle also mischaracterizes the extent of the opposition.
The article references “a handful of Park Merced residents” with
concerns about the project. In fact, this project is strongly opposed
by most residents of Parkmerced. All three resident organizations at
Parkmerced oppose the project. Hundreds of Parkmerced residents have
shown up to testify against this project at Planning Commission
hearings. All the author had to do was show up at a meeting, watch the
footage online, or read BeyondChron to know that Parkmerced residents
have been turning out in force against this project.

The article uncritically accepts the developer’s argument about the rent
control units: “Units that currently have their rents controlled will
stay that way, but new ones will be rented or sold at market rate.”
Actually, units that currently have rent control are being demolished
under the plan, and some of the new units, according to the developer,
will have rent control. However, there are significant legal questions
regarding the enforceability of these promises, something not even
discussed in the article.

The only “authority” referenced on the rent control issue is the
developer's public relations person who confidently states that the rent
controlled units will stay rent-controlled. Housing experts with no
personal stake in the project are not quoted, while the developer's paid
P.R. consultant is quoted as if his perspective is fact. That is poor
reporting, at best.

The Chronicle's decision to quote Daniel Phillips as if he
represents residents' sentiment is astonishing. Phillips is the former
head of the Parkmerced Residents Organization (PRO). The Chronicle
mentions his title, but fails to mention why he became the “former”
head in recent months. He was removed by the PRO board following
controversy over his public support for the developer, despite the
organization’s official opposition to the project. Phillips himself
admitted being “shame faced” over the board’s “no confidence” vote
regarding his leadership.

To balance the biased front-page article, the Chronicle should do a front-page story about the growing opposition to the project. Or the Chronicle
can continue to ignore criticism of the Parkmerced proposal and print
articles praising the project without letting the facts get in the way.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: