City to Explore Eviction Limits

Saturday, September 5, 2015
Samantha Weigel
San Mateo Daily Journal

As an influx of high-paying jobs have made the Bay Area’s housing market more competitive, San Mateo city officials are considering emergency regulations barring landlords from evicting tenants without a just cause.

Councilman David Lim said he’s disturbed by the number of renters who’ve come forward pleading for help, as they’re about to lose their homes. Although the council plans to collaborate with all stakeholders to identify solutions to the lack of affordable housing, Lim said he’d like to see a temporary 90-day ordinance provide more immediate protection.

“It really started to hit home when you see young families or middle-class professionals, teachers, nurses, county workers, people we rely on,” Lim said. “People want to paint this as a low-income problem or about people who are on welfare. This is not. These are the people who are the fabric of our community.”

On Tuesday, Lim will ask the council to consider taking up the proposal at its Sept. 21 meeting, during which it is scheduled to discuss the issue and brainstorm solutions concerning the status of affordable housing in the city. If at least four councilmembers approve the ordinance later this month, it would immediately go into effect.

“It would be an unmitigated disaster for the city, rental housing owners, operators and residents. Every renter would be rolling the dice anytime they moved into a new apartment because they might have to endure a bad neighbor because the owner can’t prove cause in court or establish enough political favor with a political body to remove a problem resident,” according to a statement from the California Apartment Association.

Who’s prevented from what?

Lim noted this does not deal with rent control and is a temporary measure at this time.

Based on his draft ordinance, a landlord can still evict a tenant based on several reasons: failure to pay rent, substantially violating a material term of the lease, refusal to sign a new lease, causing damage to the premise beyond normal wear and tear, disturbing the peace of other tenants or denying landlord access to the property as required by state law.

Landlords could also evict tenants if either the owner or an immediate family member plans to move in.

The draft ordinance also makes provisions for landlords who after obtaining necessary permits, must repair the property to bring it up to city codes or for health and safety purposes. In that case, the owner must then give the tenant the option of moving back in and either not increasing the rent or not charging more than the capital cost of improvements, according to the draft.

The ordinance would not apply to certain property owners, such as those who live on site and share use of a kitchen or bathroom — as in the case of a single-family home — or apartments with less than three units with the landlord residing on site as well.

Ultimately, the city will not be responsible for enforcing such an ordinance. Instead, the landlord or tenant would take the matter to civil court.

Seeking landlord input

Lim noted the ordinance can easily be overturned by the council and is intended to provide everyone with time to collaborate while working on more comprehensive solutions.

“It’s not a perfect solution. I don’t pretend it’s a perfect solution and it’s not meant to cause a hardship to our landlords. But we really have tried to work with the apartment association about why they’re raising rents,” Lim said noting in many cases landlords have made sudden increases between 28 percent and 58 percent. “I’m really hoping it will spur apartment owners to come to the table with solutions that work for them and work for us. We don’t want to tell apartment owners how to run their businesses. But at the same time, we can’t just unilaterally allow them to increase rents to the point where we lose our middle class.”

Representatives with the San Mateo County Association of Realtors, or SAMCAR, have spoken with Lim and noted their willingness to collaborate. But it opposes a just cause ordinance as a reaction the lack of housing opportunities.

“‘Just cause’ eviction ordinances are an infringement on private property rights. They prohibit property owners from evicting bad tenants, unless the reason for eviction is listed on a short, council pre-approved list of ‘acceptable’ reasons,” SAMCAR CEO Steve Blanton wrote in an email. “There is a need for affordable housing in the county, any decision that is reached by cities or the county should help to alleviate our housing shortage and encourage the creation of additional units of affordable housing. Attempting to use government to ‘regulate our way out’ of a housing shortage is not a feasible solution to the problem.”

Limitations and impacts

Lim and other councilmembers agree the issue is afflicting the entire region and ultimately, more housing units are needed — particularly as nearly 40,000 jobs have been added in San Mateo County over the last three years while just 3,000 new homes have been built. With rents having increased more than 50 percent in the last four years, an average one-bedroom is going for more than $2,500.

With the dissolution of redevelopment agencies in 2012, many municipalities have struggled to squirrel away enough money to fund the costly construction of new units.

Slow moving, next steps

While the county’s Board of Supervisors is also conducting its own brainstorming workshops, San Mateo city officials are making efforts as well. Last month, the council committed to studying the issue to determine why some are being squeezed out of the market and city limits.

One probing question the council seeks answers to: Are certain landlords raising rents to support needed building improvements, or simply because they can?

Deputy Mayor Jack Matthews said he wants to learn more about the actual impact of a just cause eviction ordinance before considering it. He also questioned whether it would truly make a difference as the issue heavily relates to a disparity in income with many unable to afford the area’s high cost of living.

“Would it really make a difference in this huge problem we have? Because I think the real problem is rents are being increased to the point of it being unaffordable. … It’s not a matter of them being evicted, it’s a matter of them not being able to afford the rents,” Matthews said. “It’s a supply and demand thing. The high salaries that some people are making because of the kinds of jobs that are being created, so it’s a combination of many things.”

Still, Lim argues immediate action is needed to help those who are being forced out of their homes — particularly as entire buildings housing families, teachers, nurses and middle-class citizens are being evicted with little recourse or time to find new homes.

While some may dismiss the issue as a low-income or poverty issue, Lim said the middle class is being squeezed out of the community. Having heard from teachers who fear they may no longer be able to work at local districts, Lim emphasized the issue impacts everyone.

In the end, Lim said he wants property owners, landlords, tenants, nonprofits and all stakeholders to work together to address the affordable housing crisis. Providing a 90-day respite for those fearing evictions will alleviate pressure and encourage property owners who’ve previously remained silent, to come to the table, Lim added.

“This is a chance to catch our breath, show that we are taking the issue seriously and that we want to having meaningful dialogue with all the parties. Because we’re not going to just stand by and say ‘it’s a horrible problem, but there’s nothing we can do.’ We need to work together to find a solution,” Lim said. “This [ordinance] is not a perfect solution, but it’s an incremental response to show that we’re serious about the plight of renters.”

The council meets 7 p.m. Tuesday, Sept. 8, at City Hall, 330 W. 20th Ave., San Mateo. Visit cityofsanmateo.org to review the draft ordinance. 

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: