CITY HALL — Santa Monica officials are challenging
an appellate court decision issued last month that could mean the loss
of 19 rent-controlled apartment units at the Embassy Hotel Apartments,
a residential building in the Wilmont neighborhood near Downtown.
A
state appellate court on June 14 said the property owner, Embassy LLC,
is allowed to take the units off the rental market, despite having
signed a settlement agreement in 2000 that required 19 of the
building's 38 units to be operated as rent-controlled dwellings. The
other 19 units were permitted to be rented out as hotel rooms under the
settlement, which resolved a prior land use and tax dispute with City
Hall.
City Hall lawyers on June 28 filed a motion asking the
court to reconsider the case, arguing the decision by a three-judge
panel from the Second District, Division Five Court of Appeals was
"erroneous" because it was based on the "omission of issues and facts
and mistakes of law and fact."
The court is expected to rule
on the motion within two weeks. If it rejects the motion, the last
remaining option for City Hall would be to ask the California Supreme
Court to rule on the case.
At issue in the case is whether the
2000 settlement is enforceable under the state law known as the Ellis
Act, which forbids cities from compelling land owners to stay in the
rental housing business. Embassy sued City Hall in 2008 after its
application to remove the 19 units from the rental market was rejected.
In determining the settlement violated the Ellis
Act, the appellate court reversed a trial court's earlier finding in
City Hall's favor.
In its motion for rehearing, lawyers for
City Hall argue Embassy is trying to wriggle out of a binding
settlement it had willingly entered into to resolve the prior
litigation. The appellate court, City Hall attorneys argue, failed to
recognize that the settlement should be exempt from Ellis Act
requirements under state law.
Also in its motion for rehearing,
City Hall lawyers asked that the appellate decision be "depublished" in
order to limit its influence on future cases. City Hall argued that the
published decision would set a precedent that would "lead to unintended
consequences to private agreements between tenants and landlords."
Tony Oliva, who represented Embassy in the case, said most motions for rehearing are rejected.
"We certainly believe the original decision was proper and that there's no basis for a rehearing," he said.
Stephen
Lewis, a spokesman for Santa Monica's rent control agency, didn't rule
out the possibility of asking the state Supreme Court to review the
case if the motion for rehearing is unsuccessful.
"The board gave its approval to challenge this decision, and this is the first means by which it's being challenged," he said.
The Embassy Hotel and Apartments is located at 1001 Third St.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.