Hoping to overturn a court ruling they say would hurt
affordable housing in Santa Monica and throughout the state, City Hall
lawyers plan to ask the California Supreme Court to review the Embassy
Hotel Apartments case, which an appellate court decided against the
city last month.
The move is the last available option for
City Hall to fight the appellate ruling, which said the Embassy's owner
could remove 19 units from the housing market despite having previously
agreed to continue operating the units as rent-controlled apartments.
At
issue is how the Ellis Act, the state law that bars jurisdictions from
requiring landlords to stay in the rental business, applies to certain
contracts.
In the Embassy case, the building's owner had
agreed to offer half of its total units as affordable apartments to
resolve a prior land use dispute with City Hall. The appellate court,
though, said that provision of the settlement was "unenforceable"
because it violated the landlord's rights under the Ellis Act.
Besides
reducing Santa Monica's affordable housing stock, lawyers at City Hall
said the appellate decision, handed down by a three-judge panel from
the Second District, Division Five Court of Appeals, could "lead to
unintended consequences to private agreements between tenants and
landlords" statewide.
The decision, they said, could invalidate contracts
in which landlords waived their Ellis rights in exchange for regulatory
concessions, such as the right to build larger projects.
Stephen
Lewis, public information manager for Santa Monica's Rent Control
Agency, said it's rare but not unheard of for City Hall to ask the
state's highest court for review.
"It's something that you would only do if you thought the legal issue was fairly momentous," he said.
The
Rent Control Agency's general counsel, Michaelyn Jones, and lawyers in
the City Attorney's Office, plan to file the petition for review on
Friday, he said.
Getting the state Supreme Court to accept a case, though, can be a tall order.
Lynn
Holton, public information officer for the court, said in the past 10
years the justices have agreed to hear between 2 and 7 percent of the
civil cases submitted each year for their review.
The court has received an average of about 3,500 petitions for review each of the past four years, she said.
The
Supreme Court will have 90 days, including an optional 30-day extension
period, to make a decision about whether to review the Embassy case.
The Embassy Hotel Apartments is a 38-unit residential building located at 1001 Third St. in the Wilmont neighborhood.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.