City leaders get a look at senior housing builder's work

Tuesday, June 7, 2011
Mary Weston
OrovilleMR.com

Petaluma Ecumenical Properties builds affordable senior housing for the lowest income seniors in Northern California, and has proposed a senior housing project in Oroville.

The proposal would put five three-story buildings with 50 units of affordable housing for seniors and a manager's apartment on Robinson Street on the old Vega Center Property.

However some neighbors opposed the project at a recent public meeting hosted by PEP.

Neighbors' concerns included the number of units proposed on the 1.57-acre site, the height of the buildings, and fears that the project will attract crime in the downtown neighborhood.

On May 26, three city representatives and this reporter traveled to Petaluma to see what the organization's senior housing projects are really like.

The first stop was at a 23-unit complex on Edith Street in a historic residential area near the downtown. This complex combines one-, two- and three-story apartments.

Renter Dianne Pamentel, 78, had sold the house where she lived in the country in Petaluma after her husband died, and had to move into the senior complex shortly after it was built in 2001.

"I didn't want to come here, but I loved it after I got here," Pamentel said.

She said the senior residents all get along and enjoy visiting, but they also like going back to the privacy of their own apartments.

Pamentel has some disabilities, so the Americans with Disabilities Act-accessable complex ensures she can remain independent. She has a car that she seldom drives but keeps to ensure her independence.

Only a few seniors in the apartments have cars.

Pamentel broke her ankle after she moved in, and was confined to a wheelchair, which she could maneuver around the apartment.

"These apartments are very good for wheelchairs," Pamentel said.

The complex has a nicely furnished community room with a kitchen and laundry rooms.

The apartments span 620 square-feet with a living room, kitchen, bedroom and a bathroom with a shower that seniors can roll into with a wheelchair. The apartments in Oroville are planned the same way, except the units will be 634 square feet.

Outside the bedroom through sliding glass doors, Pamentel has a patio where she can sit outside and grow flowers in pots.

Pamentel, who lived in the country most of her life, also has flowers, including a bright red geranium in the flower bed in front of her apartment.

In back of the apartments, seniors have planted a community vegetable garden in raised beds. Residents can go through a gate behind the apartments and walk two blocks to a market.

Like many seniors in the complex, Pamentel has a small companion dog.

PEP Executive Director Mary Stompe said most of the senior renters had worked all their lives and had life-changing events that reduced their income in later years.

She said they have retired war veterans, police officers and people from all walks of life.

Most of the seniors stay in the apartments until they die, and PEP has a waiting list of 15 months to two years.

PEP has 300 seniors 62 and over in 287 apartments in Sonoma County. People with disabilities who rent must also be 62 and over.

All renters have to pass a background check. Caregivers have to be licensed and undergo a background check.

The Edith Street complex, like the one proposed for Oroville, is a Housing and Urban Development 202-funded project.

Seniors who qualify pay 30 percent of their adjusted income, which could be as little as $200 a month or less.

A group of clergy and civic leaders conceived the housing organization to provide quality affordable housing for the community's lowest income seniors.

The organization formed as a nonprofit in 1978 and now has a full staff. PEP has won several awards for managing senior housing, building environmentally-friendly projects and for staff's contributions to the community.

A few apartments away, one of Pamentel's friends, Lillian Barthollo, 74, also loves her apartment. Before she moved in seven months ago, she didn't think she could afford to rent her own place again.

"It gave me a second chance in life," Barthollo said.

Barthollo retired as a neuro-diagnostic technician at Marin General Hospital, and she moved to Brazil to care for her mother who was ill.

"I promised her I would take care of her," Barthollo said.

She cared for her mother to the end when she was bedridden and died at 100 years of age.

During those years, Barthollo depleted her nest egg, and came back to the United States to live with her son and his family.

With a very limited income, she didn't think she could find housing until she learned about PEP, applied and finally got an apartment.

"My son is wonderful, but he has two small kids, and they have their own lifestyle," Barthollo said.

Barthollo has a small dog that she got from Poodle Rescue that keeps her company and plays with Pamentel's small dog when they visit.

"Tinker Bell and Dianne's dog hang out together," Barthollo said.

She feels safe in the apartments surrounded by friends and with an on-site manager.

"People look out for each other here, but at the same time we live independently and respect each other's privacy," Barthollo said.

Stompe said PEP has built about 13 projects in Petaluma, many in areas with historical homes, but they have never had opposition before.

She said they like to combine some of the history of the area into their projects. For example, they are trying to get cuttings from the original mother orange tree to plant in the Oroville complex, along with a plaque that gives the history of the old hospital where many residents were born.

Operations and Housing Development Director Jim Langford also gave a tour of a three-story senior complex on Douglas Street in an older residential area of Petaluma, across from a continuation school.

Community botanical and raised beds gardens were behind the apartments, along with a patio and walkways.

A group of seniors were attending a disaster preparedness meeting inside the large community room, which had a kitchen and a computer room. There's a laundry room next door.

Next stop was another project with six three-story buildings on Vallejo Street.

Here again, seniors were having a renters association meeting in the community room. The 85 units in this complex were built as two projects.

A few seniors were on the walkways with walkers.

Langford said they differ from other nonprofit developers in that they only build senior housing. Senior housing is easier to manage, he said, because there are very few problems like there is with affordable housing in general.

The senior complexes are very quiet, he said.

"The most activity is at 3 o'clock in the afternoon when they get out of their meeting in their walkers," Langford said.

The three-story buildings in Oroville would still be under the city's 45-foot limit in the downtown area.

On June 22, the proposed project will get a full Oroville Planning Commission review at a Development Review Board meeting. 

FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together.  This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: