City says rent control costs are necessary

Friday, April 30, 2010
PHILIP RILEY
ARGUS-COURIER

Litigation related to the Sandalwood mobile home park has cost the
city almost $80,000 in legal fees in the past 13 months, but not much
could have been done to avoid those expenses without exposing renters to
harm, say city officials.

Petaluma’s rent control
ordinance, which the lawsuits focus on, protects mobile home residents
from unreasonable rent increases, said Bonne Gaebler, the city’s housing
director.

“We have a very
good rent stabilization ordinance,” said Mayor Pam Torliatt. “The
concern, if reopened, is that there might be additional changes that
might be imposed by the anti-mobile home resident representatives that
would make (the ordinance) more ineffective.”

But the owner of Sandalwood mobile home park
says that the city could change parts of the ordinance to allow for
“reasonable” rent increases that fund needed improvements to a park —
which would allow the city to save on attorney fees.

“I believe that ordinance makes
it almost impossible for park owners to get a reasonable rent increase,”
said Sandalwood owner Bill Feeney in an e-mail interview. “This very
costly system assumes current rents — no matter how low — are fair and
puts the burden on the park owner to justify the increase.”

While the city says that Feeney
has been aggressive in bringing suits before the city, Feeney says that
lawsuits have been his only option because there has been no mediation
process with the city.

Since
2001, Feeney has brought four cases against the city, claiming that the
ordinance is unfair and biased against mobile home park owners. In only
the past 13 months, those four cases have cost the city $79,819 in
attorney’s fees. Recent court decisions have been in favor of the city,
with a ruling in March saying that the city did not use biased
arbitration officers, as Feeney claimed.

In that lawsuit, Feeney states that he made $885,433 in
capital improvements to the park since 2002, including a new pool and
clubhouse. In 2008, he sought to raise rents for eight residents to $825
per space from between $407 and $579 to help pay for improvements,
which he said benefited renters. Some renters said that they did not
want the costly improvements.

“He’s simply using the backs of the homeowners to
achieve his goals in rent control,” said Sandalwood resident Bill
Donahue. “It’s not fair to people living here,” who are mostly seniors
or retirees, he said.

The
ordinance states that any rate increase more than 300 percent of the
annual Consumer Price Index adjustment for the Bay Area is automatically
required to go to an arbitrator. The ordinance applies to renters on
leases less than 12 months, and households on this short-term lease can
opt in to the program by paying part of the administration fee for the
program. Park owners pay a fee of $65 for each property under the
ordinance to fund its administration costs, and can pass on up to half
of the cost to renters.

In
a 2007 letter to the city, Feeney suggested that disputes can be
resolved “by having a city representative (not an attorney who is
financially motivated to litigate) informally mediate (non-binding)
these rental disputes prior to arbitration.”

Councilmember Mike Healy said that Feeney has
“had the opportunity to be heard” in arbitration hearings.

“We have a bunch of modest
income seniors who are in jeopardy,” he said.

Healy said that modifying the ordinance would
possibly open it up to powerful park owner interests to shape the
legislation.

However, “I’d
be willing to have that conversation if what comes to the table doesn't
harm mobile home residents,” he said.

City Attorney Eric Danly could not be reached for
comment.

Contact Philip
Riley at philip.riley@arguscourier.com

FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the
use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright
owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website
in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in
California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such
copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S.
Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from
the copyright owner.  

Help build power for renters' rights: