City Sues Landlord for Allegedly Forcing Out Rent-Controlled Tenants

Friday, June 5, 2015
J.K. Dineen
San Francisco Chronicle

A local property owner has "waged a war of harassment, intimidation and retaliation” to illegally chase out longtime tenants in San Francisco apartment buildings, City Attorney Dennis Herrera alleged in a lawsuit filed Thursday in San Francisco Superior Court.

In the court documents, Herrera charges that Anna Kihagi, who manages and partially owns nine properties in the city, has employed “strong arm and unlawful tactics” to displace tenants in rent-controlled apartments in order to re-rent the units at much higher market rates. In the past two years, Kihagi’s group has invested $24 million in San Francisco real estate, assembling a residential portfolio with 50 units.

“Defendants accomplish this displacement through harassment, retaliation, fear, intimidation, fraud, abuse, false accusations, reduction of services, refusal to timely and properly perform repairs, theft, invasion of privacy, and willful destruction of the tenants’ guarantee of quiet enjoyment,” states the lawsuit.

Herrera said the lawsuit is aimed at halting the “pattern of intimidation and harassment that is terrorizing folks throughout the city.” The city lawsuit seeks an injunction ordering the property owners to cease unlawful harassment and eviction of tenants, to remove illegally performed construction, correct health and safety violations and pay fines for numerous “unfair or unlawful business acts.”

“The conduct we have seen in this case is on par with the most egregious I have seen in my 13 years as city attorney,” said Herrera.

Kihagi, a native of Kenya who also goes by Anne Kihagi and Anna Kihagi Swain, burst onto the San Francisco real estate scene in June 2013 when she started buying up properties in Noe Valley, the Castro, the Mission and North Beach. She had previously invested in multifamily properties in West Hollywood in Los Angeles County, where she was also sued by the city for violating rent-control regulations.

From the beginning, her business model has been clear. According to Herrera, Kihagi focuses on buildings with long-time rent-controlled tenants paying below-market rents and then seeks to get rid of them.Typically she offers to buy out tenants and, if that doesn’t work, the city’s lawsuit said, she threatens an “owner move-in” or a “relative move-in” eviction, both of which are allowed under the state rent control laws.

Meanwhile, according to Herrera and the tenants, she makes life miserable. Surveillance cameras are installed in the common areas. Tenants are handed an elaborate set of “house rules” governing such things as pets, use of storage room, backyard, parking rights, laundry and storage of large items, like bicycles. Tenants who violate the rules — including such things as leaving shoes or plants in the hallway — are informed that they do so “at their peril.” Gas, electric, and cable services are suddenly cut. Rent checks are not cashed and the landlord then claims payment was not received.

“She is an eviction specialist and she has a whole bag of tricks,” said Dale Duncan, whose family was served a 60-day relative move-in notice on April 17.

Karen Uchiyama, an attorney representing Kihagi, says her client, who was educated in London and the United States, has done nothing illegal and is the victim of discrimination. Everyone who has been evicted from Kihagi’s properties was breaking rules and many of them were subletting rooms to others, in clear violation of their leases, the attorney said.

“Anna is going to enforce the rules,” Uchiyama said. “She is fearless and the law is on her side.”

Uchiyama conceded that Kihagi buys buildings with “loose management and bad tenants” because they are cheaper than those with “tight management and perfect tenants.”

“Anna buys buildings with bad tenants in them and they deserve what they get,” said Uchiyama. “Some investors buy a fixer uppers. Some investors want move-in ready beautiful buildings with perfect tenants. Other landlords have no problem buying cheaper buildings with bad tenants because they are going to enforce the rules and be able to kick them out.”

For more than two decades Duncan, a cabinet maker, lived in a five-unit Edwardian building at 69-75 Hill Street in Liberty Hill, a fashionable neighborhood that borders Noe Valley and the Mission. He never had any issues with his old landlord; on the contrary, when something went awry, like the water heater breaking, Duncan would take care of it with the property owners’ blessing.

But shortly after Kihagi bought the Hill Street building in August 2014, things started going wrong, Duncan said. The water heater began leaking and the property owner didn’t address the situation for two weeks, despite repeated requests. Then the power in the building was shut off. Again, Duncan reached out to Kihagi but the matter was not quickly fixed, he said.

After numerous complaints, a team of city inspectors, escorted by a San Francisco police officer, showed up on March 4 to inspect the Hill Street property. At first, a trio of security guards Kihagi had hired refused to let the city inspectors in, the lawsuit states. But three of the tenants were home and invited the city workers to inspect the units. As the inspectors walked in, Kihagi pointed to the unit of one of the cooperating tenants and said “I’m going to move my sister in there,” according to the complaint.

As soon as the city inspectors left, a truck full of workers showed up with construction materials and, under Kihagi’s direction, “boarded up access to the laundry room and garage ... and changed the locks on the main garage door there,” according to the complaint. “The laundry is done,” she said.

“It was retaliatory. It was obvious. We let the city in and an hour later she is taking our laundry away,” said Duncan.

Kihagi has gone on the offensive against the city. In March she filed a complaint, claiming that city inspections of her properties amounted to “illegal searches and trespassing.” She accused city of enforcing building codes in an “arbitrary, capricious and discriminatory manner.” She said she has been “singled out and targeted due to a personal animus toward her, motivated in part by the city’s opposition to a female, African American immigrant owning property.”

Tenants who have been either evicted or allegedly forced from their units include a teacher, a professional skydiver, a retired school crossing guard, a 65-year-old retired army veteran with cancer, a bedridden 91-year-old and a 68-year-old employee of Saints Peter and Paul Church.

Some of Kihagi’s tenants are dealing with the fallout of having to move while others are fighting back. Mery Rose, a 61-year-old Brazilian immigrant, was evicted from an apartment on Filbert Street in North Beach and could only afford a new place near Highway 580 in Richmond.

“It’s noisy and dirty. There is a lot of drugs and car alarms all night long,” she said. “Anna broke my life. I miss my neighborhood. I miss my apartment. I miss Saints Peter and Paul Church. I am crying every night.”

Nick Reggars, who works in advertising, also moved out of the Hill Street building because he felt threatened and harassed. His parking spot was taken away. The laundry machines disappeared. Kihagi said she was going to move her sister into his unit, he said. He had just married and wanted to have a kid. He ended up exchanging his $2,900-a-month two-bedroom on Hill Street for a Bernal Heights one-bedroom that costs him $3,600.

“The stress and anxiety level was getting crazy,” he said. “It was a sword hanging over us.”

On April 17, Duncan was told that his family — which includes his 6-year-old daughter — had 60 days to clear out to make way for one of Kihagi’s sisters. Duncan, who pays $1,300-a-month, was offered a different unit for $4,200, but it wouldn’t be available until four or five months after the eviction. Duncan, who works out of a busy wood shop on Alabama Street, said he has been tempted to pack up and move. But he decided the right thing to do was stay and fight the eviction in court.

“We realized all the people who got mowed down before us couldn’t see it coming. Some of them were elderly, some didn’t speak very good English. It’s our social obligation to fight this,” said Duncan. “I am a solidly middle class guy with an 800 credit score who knows what he is doing. I’ve lived in the neighborhood for a long time and have a 6-year-old in the San Francisco schools. We are going to fight this.”

Meanwhile the city of West Hollywood has multiple criminal and civil cases pending against Kihagi, said Jonathan Holub, an attorney for the city. The cases involve tenant harassment, illegal evictions and unpaid fees and penalties. Kihagi used to have four buildings in West Hollywood, but sold two of them. “It’s been constant problems with her,” he said. “She is very much on our radar.”

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: