One man told the council most park residents were "old enough to be your father," many were war veterans, and a majority were senior citizens who want to live out the rest of their lives in security and dignity.
"Politicians need to stand up for the poor and disadvantaged," speaker J.R. Rose said. "Mobile home park owners are greedy."
Speaker Doug Johnson disagreed, noting that Mendocino County and neighboring Lake County recently rejected rent control, and urging the council particularly against considering the city of Santa Rosa's rent control ordinance, if it considered any to model its own after.
"Rent control is not the answer," he said.
Asked by Councilwoman Mari Rodin how the city could protect senior citizens from unfair rent increases and let the free market work at the same time, Johnson said, "Keep our feet to the fire ... but let's sit down and talk and figure out a solution that works for everyone and doesn't cost the city or taxpayers money."
Rodin wanted to know where alternatives to rent control had worked, and Johnson said he could find out.
City Manager Jane Chambers said the city doesn't have the money to implement a rent control ordinance. Rapport is planning to have his research ready in time for a June 2 budget workshop, where Chambers said the council would weigh the cost.
"The council will have to choose how to fund this, or how to pass the cost on to park residents," Chambers said.
Councilman Phil Baldwin urged his fellow council members to act quickly to avoid a flood of rent increases, but the consensus was to wait and calculate the cost first - particularly if it meant sacrificing other city services.
Rapport noted if there was no pass-through cost, "it would be at the expense of something else."
Rapport said he's looking particularly at the city of Santa Rosa's ordinance, which passes through to park residents the cost of implementing the ordinance. He noted Santa Rosa has "hundreds" of mobile home parks and more park dwellers over which to spread the cost.
Chambers noted the city has already done its homework about how much rent is charged in the city's mobile home parks, about the ages and financial situations of the people who live in them.
There are five mobile home parks listed in the report, including Modern MHP, Shady Grove, Harold's Square, Rancho Del Ray and Manor Oaks.
In August 2008, the city mailed 357 surveys to mobile home residents; 135 were returned. Of those, the majority were female, lived alone, were 62 years old or older, had annual incomes ranging from $11,750 to $19,950, paid about $8,000 annually in rent and utilities.
The majority were also concerned about lack of park maintenance and increasing costs, but were "basically satisfied" with the park in which they lived, according to the city's November report.
Tiffany Revelle can be reached at udjtr@pacific.net, or at 468-3523.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.