West Hollywood made the argument for incentivizing the conversion into condos of the city’s largest and most “prominent” historic apartment buildings at Thursday’s Planning Commission.
The commission reacted with a 7-0 vote to reject the proposal as written, recommending to the WeHo City council that they convene a task force to rethink it.
Along the way, skeptical commissioners and an angry public poked the proposed “pilot program” full of holes.
Citing El Mirador, the Jerome Nash-owned apartmentvbuilding at 1302 North Sweetzer Ave. (at Fountain) with 32 units as one of the buildings that would qualify, the proposal provides landlords owning Historic Buildings with 21 or more units who wish to leave the rental business a leg up on the process.
Mr. Nash evicted the few remaining tenants from the building in September 2010 because of what he claimed to be the city's foot-dragging on his attempts to replace the building's windows.
Tenants say the window episode is a red herring; they charge Mr. Nash with evicting a building full of people enjoying sub-market rents in order to make more money.
Because that process was not going quickly enough, they say, Mr. Nash created a controversy over the windows to finish the job of clearing out the building.
Charged Jim Kingslan, a tenant who left the building in January, "This man is trying to eliminate rent stabilizaion. He went in knowing it was 85 percent rent control," and harrassed tenants to drive them out.
He recalled Mr. Nash telling him in the midst of one of his apoplectic rages several years ago, "At the end of the day you're just one more leech that is going to be evicted from my building."
Mr. Kingslan also alleged that Mr. Nash "elder abused Emil Berger, sued him and almost bankrupted him to force him to sell his interest in the building," in 2009.
Mr. Nash denies ill-treating his tenants, although WeHo News witnessed his volatile temper in his dealings with contractors on a tour of El Mirador and suffered his wrath upon asking the "wrong" questions in an interview in his office.
The Berger family declined to reply to inquiries for comment.
The last tenants leave the iconic 1920's structure in August.
The staff reports states that the proposal would assist Mr. Nash immediately, and two other properties down the road, in the following ways:
1. Permit fee waivers;
2. Transfer of development rights;
3. Change of use or adaptive reuse;
4. Mills Act Agreements;
5. Reduction in the development standards of this Zoning Ordinance;
6. The permitting of uses not allowed in the zone, but which are permitted in other zones;
7. Affordable housing requirement (Chapter 19.22) waiver for the conversion of rental units into common interest developments for buildings with 21 or more units and eligible for the National Register as identified in the Historic Resources Inventory or listed on the National Register; and
8. Development fee (Chapter 19.64, Table 4-3) waiver for the conversion of rental units into common interest developments for buildings with 21 or more units and eligible for the National Register as identified in the Historic Resources Inventory or listed on the National Register.
Two comments from commissioners summed up the generally adverse reaction to the proposal aimed at allowing the Jerome Nash (see Ellis Act)-owned El Mirador and two other historic buildings to convert to condos.
Former-chair Mark Yeber expressed “disappointment” in the document’s contents after noting that the issue had been percolating in the Chamber of Commerce, the Historic Preservation Commission and with landlords and advocates for years.
He also deep anger about creating a zone text amendment to incentivize one property owner, saying he was, almost incensed that this was brought forward simply because of one property owner who decided to be a bit aggressive with the community and a bit aggressive with the city and then bullied us.”
Commissioner Donald Deluccio called the idea of evicting renters to save buildings and incentivizing condo conversions by leaving out an affordable housing component was “almost insulting” in a city built on rent control and affordable housing.
To Mr. Yeber’s point, Michael Jenkins said the individual instance can catalyze lawmaking.
“Oftentimes we make changes in laws because we encounter a situation that discloses a problem that we’ve yet had to deal with or address,” he said.
Mr. Jenkins admitted that the ordinance came as a result of the city’s fear of having a “white elephant on our hands… a building that is vacant which creates problems of its own… or ultimately the demolition of a building that is historically significant.”
One argument set forward by staff, that the larger buildings cost more to renovate than small buildings, got a stinging rebuke from Ed Levin, whose architectural firm has done historic renovations.
“The idea that large buildings are more of a [renovation or maintenance] burden s nonsense… On a per square foot, or per unit basis, the smaller the building the higher the cost.”
He summed up, “This makes no real sense, on a public policy issue or on a rational basis issue.”
As for the apparently threatened demolition of El Mirador, realtor Dan Siegel said, “It’s prohibitively expense,” to demolish something on the National Register.
Mr. Siegel said that the two debunked arguments showed that the city is, “starting with… premises that are not correct.”
Lauren Meister said that the proposal “wasn’t thought out very well,” as she felt the ordinance could be left as it stands and the landlords need to find maintenance and renovation funds satisfied through recalibrating “the NOI (Net Operating Income)calculation… using affordable housing in lieu fees for grants for historic preservation grants or low interest loans as an incentive to owners of historic properties to maintain their properties and keep their renters.”
Protecting renters seemed on the mind of many people who filled the room to comment on the proposal.
Grafton Tanquary, a tenant living in Fontainebleau on Fountain Avenue and Crescent Heights Boulevard hoped that the city could find a way to voluntarize the condo conversion process.
“Provision must be made to protect existing renters from immediate eviction upon conversion,” he said. “Renters should be allowed to buy their units, or, if they wish to continue renting, to remain as renters with the same protections now in the Rent Stabilization Ordinance.”
In the end, the commission voted to deny the resolution as prepared and recommended that council explore other ways to incentivize capital improvement for an expanded pool of historic buildings that would make condo conversion voluntary on a unit-by-unit basis, including the use of reductions in fees, streamlining/adjusting the NOI process and expansion of grants to historic buildings.
The City Council will take up the proposed zone text amendment and the Planning Commission’s recommendations at an upcoming meeting.
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.