Confusion on the SF Housing Front

Tuesday, April 14, 2015
Randy Shaw
Beyond Chron

A housing development proposed for San Francisco’s Tenderloin neighborhood has exposed an ongoing confusion between a “loophole” and an “incentive.” In this case, a planned new group housing development for 145 Leavenworth and 361 Turk is described as benefitting from a “loophole” because inclusionary units are not required. In truth, the city openly sought to promote group housing construction (which differs from apartments by lacking private kitchens) by excluding inclusionary units as a cost incentive to build such developments.

The reasoning was that group housing targets a lower income population than new studios. And that remains correct. But two changes have occurred.

First, new group housing now attracts much higher rents—and tenants with far greater incomes—than we normally associate with units lacking private kitchens.

Second, group housing units now include “mini kitchens.” They do not meet the  requirements for full kitchens in studio apartments, but some argue that by providing cooking in the unit that this raises the price of the housing in a way not contemplated by the group housing law.

So now some want to change the rules of the game. They want to retroactively apply inclusionary requirements to developers who moved forward due to a financial incentive the city openly and consciously enacted.

That’s not fair.

The proposed developments at 145 Leavenworth and 361 Turk have other problems that put their approval in doubt (unlike other Tenderloin projects, they face strong neighborhood opposition. I will explain why in an article prior to the April 30 Planning Commission hearing). But not providing inclusionary housing that the law does not require should not be why this project does not get built.

Should the city add an inclusionary requirement to group housing? Supervisor Avalos introduced legislation to do so last week. Given the market changes that have occurred since the original legislation, such an incentive may no longer be necessary.

Live-Work Lofts

The group housing dispute is not the first time that law passed to incentive a specific type of housing construction is wrongly criticized as a “loophole.” We saw this with the live-work loft battles of the 1990’s.

In the early 1990’s new housing development in San Francisco was dead in the water. City officials asked builders what it would take to get construction going, and were told that there might be buyer interest in live-work lofts. After a long public debate, the city enacted a law that incentivized the construction of live-work lofts by excluding projects from inclusionary requirements.

Live-work lofts proved surprisingly popular. They proved even more attractive after the dot com boom of the late 1990’s, which led to their increased construction as other forms of new housing were still not being built.

Suddenly, the exemption from inclusionary requirements that was openly enacted to incentive live-work construction became attacked as a “loophole.” The Bay Guardian routinely denounced the live-work “loophole” as an example of backroom “pay to play” politics at City Hall; in truth, the exemption was openly discussed at many hearings and was granted because nobody was building housing. This incentive was seen as needed to get builders back in the game.

Not even “Monster Homes” have been demonized more in San Francisco than live-work lofts. Their supposed inclusionary housing “loophole” led the Board of Supervisors to take the unusual step of killing future construction of this housing type.

Those wondering why more housing is not built in the city should note that the Board preferred to stop future live-work projects instead of continuing their construction with the standard inclusionary requirements.

New Inclusionary Rules Needed

It’s clear that today’s skyrocketing housing prices require long overdue changes in San Francisco’s inclusionary housing laws. Many were included in the recommendations of Mayor Lee’s 2014 Housing Work Group, but have still not come before the Board for enactment.

For example, in the November 2011 election, Prop C reduced the inclusionary requirements from 15% to 12%. Does that lower number still make sense?

And what about the extreme delays caused by the Mayor’s Office of Housing procedures in selling the affordable BMR made available under the inclusionary laws. Why should it take several months for a buyer to acquire an affordable unit when standard deals are closed within 30-60 days? These delays in getting buyers into affordable homes also hurts developers; it is a lose-lose that the Board of Supervisors should correct.

Housing advocates should prioritize moving these broader inclusionary changes through the political process. This is a far fairer process for developers than having them move forward on projects only to see the rules changed midstream.

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: