Issue tabled until budget workshops are completed
The Ukiah City Council voted unanimously Wednesday night to postpone
discussions and further action on a proposed rent-stabilization
ordinance for mobilehome parks.
"We need a clear understanding of the potential outcomes before we pick
a path," said Council member Doug Crane. "This step should follow (the
budget strategic planning) discussion later this month. I hope that we
simply continue this until we've had a chance to digest the budget and
do some prioritization."
Prior to the vote, City Attorney David Rapport presented the council
with three examples of similar ordinances in California: one in Santa
Rosa, one in Lake County and one in Merced.
According to Rapport's report, the Santa Rosa ordinance establishes a
base rent for mobilehome parks and limits any increases to 100 percent
of the consumer price index (CPI), as long as it is 6 percent or less.
The ordinance also allows park owners to pass on expenses such as
capital improvements and government-mandated fees and taxes to tenants,
but sets procedures for how the fees can be imposed and how tenants are
notified.
If owners feel the CPI does not provide a "fair return" on their
investment, they can seek an increase through a formal arbitration
procedure.
The city's costs to administer the ordinance include paying a clerk to
assess and collect fees, process protest petitions from tenants,
process fair return applications by owners, and oversee arbitrations.
Crane said his understanding was if Ukiah adopted such an ordinance,
"we need to find $35,000 somewhere in the budget to implement this. So
what do we displace?"
Rapport said the Lake County ordinance is similar to the one in Santa
Rosa, with the primary difference being that instead of using a
professional arbitrator, it uses a Hearing Board.
Another difference is that it offers park owners the ability to "exempt
the entire park from the rent control ordinance" by offering its
tenants a five-year lease.
The Merced ordinance, however, does not establish a base rent nor
regulate increases. Called the Mobile Home Rent Review Ordinance, it
establishes a Rent Review Commission made up of park owners, tenants
and other citizens that conducts investigations and hearings when park
tenants submit petitions protesting rent increases. Qualifying
petitions must come from 51 percent or more of the tenants in parks
with at least 25 spaces.
Council member Mary Ann Landis made a motion to "ask staff to create an
ordinance based on the Merced ordinance for us to discuss and implement
over the coming year," which Council member Mari Rodin supported.
"That would take us to the next step, but I don't feel it would bind us
to anything - we could still discuss the items in the ordinance," Rodin
said. "Finding the money (for an ordinance) is a real concern, but
there's enough people here (in the audience) to convince me that we
have a real problem and we need to find the money."
Council member Phil Baldwin expressed strong opposition to modeling an ordinance after the one in effect in Merced.
"People want protection from unfair profit takers, and I'm not sure we
get that if we just go with the Merced ordinance," Baldwin said. "This
is the weakest conceivable option, and one that I understand was
suggested by a park owner."
After Crane suggested the discussion be tabled until budget talks are
completed, Landis withdrew her motion, and the council voted
unanimously to table the discussion.
"I agree with (Crane)," Baldwin said. "I want to comb through the
budget and find the money for a more stringent ordinance - something
that is not just a mirage."
Baldwin's statement was met by applause from the audience, which
included several senior citizens, many of whom addressed the council to
support rent stabilization.
The council will likely restart the discussions in July.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.