Council moves rent-stabilization law forward

Thursday, October 7, 2010
Justine Frederiksen
The Ukiah Daily Journal

Still at least one more vote before ordinance is adopted, however

After nearly two more hours of discussion, the Ukiah City Council voted
Wednesday night to introduce an ordinance that would stabilize rents
for mobile-home park residents.

"People who own mobile-homes are in a unique situation in that they
can't easily move -- that puts them at the mercy of park owners," said
Council member Mari Rodin. "I want to give them protection."

However, Rodin and the rest of the council -- with the exception of
Council member Phil Baldwin -- also expressed reservations about the
ordinance, which limits annual rent increases to 100 percent of the
Consumer Price Index, as long as it is 5 percent or less, and
stipulates how costs for park improvements and replacements can be
passed on to residents.

Council member Doug Crane, who voted against drafting an ordinance and
cast the sole "no" vote Wednesday night, said there were still many
questions regarding the consequences of passing one, for everyone
involved.

"This ordinance will mean that every mobile-home tenant in this city will pay more money," Crane said.

The vote came despite several last-minute snags: two motions from
Baldwin that died without a second, and a letter sent to City Manager
Jane Chambers from a representative of the owners of Rancho del Ray,
who pointed out that one part of the ordinance may invite litigation.

"The Santa Rosa ordinance allows a rent increase of $50 due to turnover, but the

Ukiah ordinance limits the increase to 10
percent or the average of the three highest rents, whichever is lower,"
wrote Joseph Carroll, representing the mobile home park's owners. "The
issue is before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, and the city may be
named in litigation."

Carroll said his clients were willing to sit down and draft a long-term
lease as an alternative to the ordinance, but had not been given an
opportunity prior to it being drafted.

However, mobile-home park resident David Villmar pointed out that in
discussions two-and-a-half years ago, the owners of the park were
approached about drafting a long-term lease for residents and nothing
materialized.

"They dismissed the long-term lease previously -- did the fairy of
human kindness make them come forward with this now?" asked Thomas,
addressing Doug Johnson, who warned the city against adopting the
ordinance.

"Yes, I think the owners have had that Come to Jesus moment,'" said
Johnson, representing the Western Manufactured Housing Communities
Association. "We support a long-term lease because it's more fair.
Councilman Baldwin is selling you a bill of goods. Rent control is not
going to be good for the owners, or the tenants."

Council member Mary Anne Landis said given the litigation concerns,
keeping a long-term lease in "the back of our minds would not be a bad
idea. I still think this is a good idea, but I have concerns about it."

Baldwin said the ordinance does not preclude long-term leases.

"Any park owner can go door-to-door and offer every tenant a lease and
say, I've got a better deal for you.'" he said. "The difference here
is, the resident has a choice."

The vote did not adopt the ordinance, however; it only introduced it.
City Attorney David Rapport said the council has to wait five days
after introducing the ordinance before adopting it, and it would come
back before the council at its next meeting in two weeks. The earliest
it could take effect would be Nov. 15.


FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: