CITY HALL — The owners of an apartment and hotel
property in the Wilmont district could be allowed to evict 19 tenants
under the Ellis Act and turn the units into hotel rooms despite having
previously waived their right to do so, a state appellate court ruled
this week.
Issued on Monday, the decision was a loss for City
Hall, which argued that the owners of the Embassy Hotel Apartments,
located at 1001 Third St., were legally bound to continue operating the
units as rent-controlled dwellings.
The decision by the Second
District Court of Appeals stems from a settlement agreement reached to
resolve a prior dispute between City Hall and the Embassy's owners.
That dispute, over Embassy's alleged failure to pay the tax on hotel
stays and a disagreement about how Santa Monica's rent control law
should apply to the property, was resolved in October of 2000 with a
settlement that allowed half of the Embassy's 38 units to be operated
as hotel rooms but required half the rooms to be maintained as
apartment units subject to rent control.
With their unanimous
decision, the three-judge panel reversed a trial court's earlier ruling
and determined the 2000 settlement's requirement that half the units
remain rent-controlled apartments was "unenforceable" because of the
state law known as the Ellis Act, which bars cities from compelling
landlords to remain in the rental housing business.
"Clearly
we're disappointed with [the decision] and we don't agree with the
court's opinion," said Stephen Lewis, public information manager for
Santa Monica's Rent Control Agency.
He said it would be up to the agency's five-member board to determine whether to appeal.
The
decision ends a case that began in 2008 after Embassy's owners applied
for an Ellis permit to remove the 19 units from the rental market. City
Hall rejected the application, citing the 2000 court settlement
agreement.
Tony Oliva, an attorney with the firm Allen Matkins who represented Embassy's owners in the case, applauded Monday's decision.
"We're
certainly pleased. We think the decision was correct as a matter of
law," he said. "Our goal is to continue to work with the city, not to
work against the city."
It's unclear exactly what changes will
take place at the Embassy. Oliva declined to discuss his clients' plans
for the property, but indicated the decision will enable them to invest
in the building.
"It's a real jewel in Santa Monica and it's
magnificently preserved. That's why we have pursued this — because we
want the ability to continue to care for this building in the way we
have."
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.