A challenge by mobile park residents to the
city's amended rent control ordinance has been rejected by a county
court judge, who ruled in favor of the city.
Nineteen residents of Surf and Sand, a 74-unit mobile home park on
47th Avenue, filed a suit against the city, arguing that the city's
ordinance conflicted with state law.
Santa Cruz Superior Court Judge Timothy Volkmann rejected that
assertion, writing in his decision that the ordinance "does not
duplicate, or conflict with state law," and "local rent ordinances are,
indeed, allowable.
Challenges to the city's 32-year-old rent control ordinance have long
plagued Capitola, costing thousands of dollars in legal fees. Roughly a
third of the money for that defense has come from a mobile home
administrative service fee paid by Capitola's mobile home park
residents.
The ordinance was amended in March after the city reached a
settlement with Ron Reed, owner of Surf and Sand. The amended ordinance
would eliminate all rent controls once a current resident of the mobile
home park leaves. It contains protections for low-income residents,
including requirements for the landlord to offer long-term leases and
controls for how much and how rapidly rents can rise. The city is also
establishing a low-income housing assistance program to help residents
for the next 10 years.
Despite the provisions, many of the park's residents worried they
would not be able to afford their rents once the increases went into
effect.
"It's a drastic rental increase," said Maurice Priest, a Sacramento-based attorney who represents the residents.
The majority of the residents have been paying $260 to $400 a month.
Under the terms of the settlement reached with Reed, lower income
residents were offered 34-year leases with a monthly rent of $475 after
an income verification process. Many residents said they could not meet
the stringent qualifications leaving some paying five times what they
had been paying. Rents for higher-income, full-time residents will
gradually increase to market rate after eight years, while rents for
part-time residents and those with other residential property, could
immediately rise to market rate.
"We're very disappointed in the decision," Priest said Wednesday.
"We're currently discussing with out clients what the various options
are."
Calls to Mayor Dennis Norton and Reed, who were among the defendants
in the case, were not immediately returned Wednesday. Co-defendant and
councilman Mike Termini said he was pleased with Volkmann's decision.
Councilman Sam Storey called it "kind of a bittersweet victory,"
saying that he felt for the residents but still believed the right
decision was made.
"It's an important ruling because I believe local governments need to
be able to direct how our public resources are being used," Storey said
Wednesday evening.