Laws controlling how much mobile home park owners can charge for
monthly site rentals don't infringe on constitutionally protected
property rights, a federal appeals court ruled Wednesday.
The U.S.
9th Circuit Court of Appeals rejected the argument of Daniel and Susan
Guggenheim of Goleta, Calif., that the city was engaged in an
unconstitutional "taking" of their property by limiting how much space
rentals can grow.
The Guggenheims bought the land in 1997, five
years before Goleta was incorporated as a city but well after Santa
Barbara County adopted the original rent-control measure in 1979. The
couple had no "investment-backed expectations" taken away from them, the
appeals court said, because rent control already was the law when they
bought Rancho Mobile Home Estates.
The decision, though split 8 to
3, could foretell the outcome of renter-owner disputes elsewhere in the
nine-state region covered by the court, as other mobile home parks have
become arenas of contention between landowners wanting to charge what
the market will bear and homeowners of the often not-so-mobile dwellings
having to pay more or disassemble and relocate their homes.
Goleta's
ordinance imposes strict limits on rental increases for existing
tenants and caps rent increases at 10% for new buyers of mobile homes
already situated in residential clusters within the city.
The
Guggenheims argued that the rent-control limits unjustly transferred the
value of their property to the tenants because mobile home owners could
sell their homes for almost nine times as much when the buyers could
count on paying fixed monthly rent for the space rather than market
value.
An expert's report said homes at the park would sell for an
average of $14,000 without rent control and $120,000 with it, enriching
the homeowner at the landowner's expense. Space rentals could earn
$13,000 a year on the open market, the expert said, while under the city
controls the same space costs less than $3,300 annually.
Those
disparities didn't amount to an unconstitutional "taking" in violation
of due process and equal protection, the court said, because the
Guggenheims knew of the controls when they bought the property.
Judge
Carlos T. Bea, joined by Chief Judge Alex Kozinski and Judge Sandra S.
Ikuta, dissented. The trio, all appointees of Republican presidents,
said the majority ignored other U.S. Supreme Court findings and disputed
that Goleta's ordinance was a legitimate rent-control policy.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.