SANTA CRUZ - Scores of
property owners urged the City Council on Tuesday to reconsider a new
fee-based ordinance that would require owners of all rental units
within city limits to register their properties and eventually submit
to city inspections, a proposal critics called misguided and
unconstitutional.
Controversy over the ordinance has been brewing for months as city
officials have negotiated with real estate groups, property managers
and landowners in advance of a September deadline to adopt a rental
inspection and maintenance ordinance as required in the city's 2008
agreement with UC Santa Cruz to house more students on campus.
Rather than passing an ordinance that scrutinizes all rental
properties, opponents of the proposal encouraged the council to go
after illegal units that are already subject to local and state laws
governing housing and safety codes. Others applauded the city for
taking action to reduce overcrowding, unauthorized construction and
other code violations, of which there are about 500 reported cases.
"You know where the problem places are - deal with those
immediately," said Rose Marie McNair, a real estate broker, adding that
inspections without cause are unconstitutional. "Take 90 days and
enforce the laws that are already on the books."
Mayor Mike Rotkin responded that, "There is no question in
California law that privacy rights that people have not to interfere
with the enjoyment of their home is in fact balanced in law with the
government's obligation to demonstrate that there is a valid purpose to
inspect a property."
Rotkin assured the public early in the hearing that the council
would not vote on the ordinance Tuesday. Rather, the proposal will be
brought for first reading at the 3 p.m. meeting Aug. 3 and a final
adoption in September.
In introductory remarks, the mayor made the case for the urgency of
the new rules, saying there are thousands of suspected illegal units
that, either by their sheer occupancy or poor construction, pose fire
and health hazards. About half of the city's residents are renters,
according to census reports, and the new measure is meant to complement
other ordinances targeting party houses and public nuisance properties.
Rotkin, a 40-year UCSC employee, also tried to put to rest
widespread suspicion that the UCSC agreement is driving the push for an
ordinance. He said he began considering an ordinance years before the
agreement with UCSC, which will pay for half the program's estimated
$322,0000 annual cost of two inspectors and a clerk.
The ordinance, in its current form, would include the following provisions:
n Registration of all properties for $45 annual fee each, with the
exception of in-law units and single rooms for rent in single-family
homes.
n Eventual inspections of all rental units at $20 per unit, which
covers a reinspection if problems are found. Subsequent inspections
would cost $120 per hour, and uncorrected violations would be subject
to civil penalties.
n There would be no inspections for the first three years except for
properties that already have reported or documented code violations.
The regular inspection cycle would begin in 2013.
n A self-certification application for property owners whose units
have not received code violations in the last three years.
Self-certified landlords would still pay $20 per unit for 20 percent of
all units annually every five years.
n The inspection would examine storage areas, roofs, lighting, bug
and rodent infestation, electricity, water heater, running hot and cold
water, sewage system, weather-protected and locking windows, and safe
flooring and walls.
"These conditions don't exist in a whole lot of rental units in
Santa Cruz," said Councilwoman Cynthia Mathews. "I don't fear this as a
property owner, I welcome it."
Property owners were mostly concerned about the cost.
Rick Thomas, owner of multifamily housing units, said, "You're
putting a tax on things, you're collecting money, that's all you're
doing."
City officials said all the fees raised will go toward paying for the program, which means it is not the same as a tax.
Opponents also raised concerns that the ordinance will cause rental
prices to go up and put some residents of illegal units out on the
street. Several argued that the ordinance misses the mark because it
doesn't require inspections of owner-occupied homes, which can also
house too many residents and have unsafe conditions.
Rotkin acknowledged some residents would undoubtedly be displaced by
violations, but said the city can no longer look the other way.
Landlords also are required under other city rules to reimburse
displaced tenants.
The city is bound by the settlement with UC Santa Cruz over campus
growth to adopt a rental inspection ordinance within two years of the
agreement, which would be Sept. 12. If the city fails to do so, the
university can reduce its obligation to house more students on campus -
the foundation of the agreement - by 450 beds.
Although city officials dread the impact on water use and traffic if
the private rental market has to absorb 450 more students in coming
years, Planning Director Juliana Rebagliati said the ordinance was not
being fast-tracked to meet the deadline.
"We are going to adopt the right ordinance," she said, even it takes more work in the next few weeks.
The ordinance is quite different from drafts issued months ago.
Staff made numerous revisions in response to concerns raised previously
by Santa Cruz Neighbors, the Board of Realtors and others.
Among major changes, the ordinance now applies to all owners of
rental property. Previous versions only applied to owners of three or
more rental units, but Rebagliati said critics felt that wasn't
equitable.
With the increase in volume of properties covered under the
ordinance, the city also lowered the fee for registration from $100 and
increased the inspection pre-notification period from 12 days to 21
days.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.