Despite its name, the Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles, HACLA, is a pseudo-federal agency over which City Hall has no authority. But that didn't stop the Los Angeles City Council on Wednesday from trying to exert some oversight onto an agency that seems to have gone a bit haywire, hurting the people it's supposed to help.
Nine HACLA residents, including some from San Fernando Gardens in Pacoima, were ordered out of public housing because they had the temerity to protest at the home of HACLA's fat cat director, Rudy Montiel, who earns almost $450,000 a year to run the $1 billion agency.
Authority or not, the council this week called upon state and federal authorities to investigate the retaliatory evictions of nine low income public housing tenants. And they were correct to do so; things seem to have gone terribly wrong with HACLA and its top official.
The evictions are just the latest wrinkle in an ongoing dispute between residents and HACLA. Residents are upset both about pending changes to public housing units and how HACLA had handled public meetings about the changes. Residents claimed that some people were shut out, some denied the ability to testify and the meetings were not properly publicized - all violations of state open meeting laws.
If the mountain won't come to Muhammad, as the saying goes, Muhammad must go to the mountain. In that spirit, HACLA public housing residents, organized together into a group called People Organized for Westside Renewal or POWER, chartered buses and went for a Sunday drive to Montiel's well-appointed home in San Bernardino County. The public housing mass congregated at his front door and in his driveway; they trampled his grass and walked on his patio. They peered in windows, pounded on the door and generally made a nuisance of themselves.
Montiel was "trapped" inside with his wife and teenage son until sheriff's deputies arrived more than an hour later. Montiel and his family reportedly feared they would be attacked any moment by this angry mob. Clearly Montiel doesn't have much affinity for the people his agency was set up to serve. HACLA gets most of its money from Housing and Urban Development funds.
Taking the protest to Montiel's front door and scaring his family probably wasn't the best way to handle this dispute, but disenfranchised constituents sometimes have no other way to break through the deliberate indifference of bureaucrats. More and more, public agencies from City Hall to Capitol Hill are finding new and more efficient ways to distance themselves from their constituencies. Sometimes, going to their homes is the only way to get their attention.
There might be an inclination to dismiss these public housing residents as people who've gotten too comfortable on the public dole and that they're willing to trample grass and make agency heads fear for their lives to protect what they've got. But who's getting the better deal - the poor folks having to live in crime-ridden public housing complexes, or Montiel, whose executive salary allows him to live in luxury far, far away from Pacoima and South L.A.?
Montiel's main motivation for the evictions seems to be that he was afraid of the crowd. He took pictures of demonstrators and then used the photos to get identifications of nine residents to target for removal.
But he's still afraid to look the public in the eye, it seems. The City Council had asked Montiel come to the council meeting Wednesday to explain what happened. While he was not obligated to do so, it would have been a respectful gesture. But he ignored the request and sent his attorney. "If he's not coming to our meeting, you think he's responding to the people?" Councilman Richard Alarcón asked Wednesday.
Montiel is a public official and needs to make public explanations. Until then, he should put the evictions aside. It might feel good to punish those unruly demonstrators for coming to his front door, but it will only serve to polarize the tenants and HACLA. It's also unseemly that a highly paid bureaucrat would choose to make poor people homeless simply because their behavior peeved him.
If he doesn't reverse course, Montiel ought to be removed from the job. The leadership of a public agency cannot be run by someone who refuses to deal with the public, in public.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.