Damage Deposit Laws Give Landlords Unfair Advantage

Tuesday, January 14, 2014
Paul Chiswell
Calgary Herald

If you rent a home in Alberta, you’ve likely faced the daunting task of getting your security deposit back when you move out. It doesn’t matter if you didn’t break anything and kept the place clean, your landlord has your money, and getting it back is rarely as easy as it should be.

As a lawyer who used to rent, and who has helped other renters, I’ve found it surprisingly difficult to get security deposits back. I can only imagine how difficult this must seem to someone who is transient, not as knowledgeable about the process, and not as willing to stand up to their landlord.

Studies elsewhere also show that many renters felt their deposits were unjustifiably withheld. If that’s you, you’re left with one option: hassle the landlord for your money back. If they refuse, you have to sue in court or apply to the residential tenancy dispute resolution service. Either way, you’re facing a filing fee, fees for serving the documents on the landlord, and lots of time and effort.

If you sue, chances are that the landlord will retroactively argue that something was left dirty or damaged, leaving you with the practical burden of proving a negative. Even if you’re successful, you still need to enforce the ruling against the landlord, which itself is complicated, time consuming, expensive and often fruitless.

Faced with this situation, it’s understandable why many tenants just give up. Disreputable landlords count on it.

But it doesn’t need to be this way. Ontario doesn’t permit landlords to collect a security deposit; they can only collect the last month’s rent in advance. In British Columbia, Manitoba and Nova Scotia, the security deposit is limited to half the first month’s rent. In Alberta, the security deposit can be up to a full month’s rent. Alberta has the most landlord friendly laws in Canada.

Landlords say they need this power to protect themselves against unscrupulous tenants who damage their home, or abandon the lease without having paid rent. While unsavoury tenants exist, that doesn’t explain why landlords should hold all the cards.

Current Alberta law attempts to protect a tenant’s deposit by requiring the landlord to hold the deposit in trust in a separate bank account for the duration of the lease. But nobody believes that the average non-professional landlord actually does this. And even if the deposit is kept in trust, it doesn’t help tenants get their money back — it only ensures that the money is there to get back if the tenant can somehow get at it.

The best solution is to make an independent third party hold all security deposits in trust. In New Brunswick, deposits are held by the Office of the Rentalsman, a government body. In the United Kingdom, approved private third parties hold deposits and even provide free dispute resolution services.

Under a third-party trustee system, if the landlord has a claim to the deposit, then he can apply for the money. If the tenant disputes the landlord’s claim, then a hearing is held.

This solves many problems. First, it ensures that the deposit is actually held in trust and will be there when the lease ends, even if the landlord isn’t. Second, it places the procedural and substantive burden on the landlord to prove a valid claim to the deposit. Third, no fees are required to serve notice on the landlord, and if the tenant wins, no judicial enforcement procedure is required (no judgment needs to be filed in court, and no civil enforcement agency needs to be hired).

Meanwhile, the landlord is also protected, because a deposit is still being held, and let’s not forget that a landlord can always sue the tenant for damage to the unit or for unpaid rent.

When people first hear of this idea, they wonder about the added cost of the third-party trustee and of creating an unnecessary bureaucracy. But the system pays for itself: the third party trustee has a large pool of funds that generate interest. This interest should easily pay for the system.

Currently, landlords in Alberta get to keep up to three per cent interest on deposits, presumably as a reward for their “efforts” as trustees. If a third party is acting as the trustee instead of landlords, landlords should have no problem giving up the interest as well.

This proposal would not only protect vulnerable Albertans from being taken advantage of, it also has an economic side benefit: since the funds are pooled, millions of dollars can be safely and more efficiently invested back into the economy.

It’s both a fairer and more efficient way to handle tenants’ security deposits. Alberta should adopt it soon.

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: