David Chiu Strikes Deal with Developer To Demolish Over 1,500 Rent Controlled Units at Parkmerced

Wednesday, May 25, 2011
Dean Preston
BeyondChron

Yesterday, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, led by Board
President David Chiu, voted 6-5 to approve the controversial demolition
of over 1500 rent-controlled homes in San Francisco’s Parkmerced. Chiu
reached a backroom deal with the developer and provided the crucial
sixth vote to approve the largest demolition of rent-controlled housing
in San Francisco since the redevelopment of the Fillmore. Despite a good
record on tenant rights issues before his work on Parkmerced, Chiu has
now earned the distrust of tenants across the city.

The Parkmerced development proposal is flawed at many
levels. Fundamentally, the demolition of over 1,500 homes violates
city policy and common sense. The discussion at the board level has
largely focused on the enforceability of the developer’s promise to
apply rent control to replacement units.

Chiu introduced 14 pages of amendments to the Development Agreement for
the first time at yesterday’s hearing and would not agree to continue
the matter so that his colleagues and stakeholders could analyze the
proposed amendments. Chiu’s amendments did not resolve substantial
concerns about the enforceability of the rent control promises in the
Development Agreement.

On tough questioning from Supervisor David Campos, Deputy City Attorney
Charles Sullivan admitted that the rent control promises to the existing
tenants are not guaranteed to be enforceable. Instead, the best
Sullivan could offer was his belief that the city has “strong arguments”
if the developer, or a subsequent owner, tries to get out of the
obligations to provide replacement rent-controlled units. This provides
little comfort to residents fearful of losing their homes and rent
control protections.

Frustrated residents reacted at the hearing. As Chiu was explaining to
the full Board how beneficial his new amendments were for tenants, one
longtime Parkmerced resident, whose home of 50 years would be demolished
under the plan, shouted “bullshit.” She and another tenant insisted on
being heard even though there was no public comment period. They were
removed from the Board Chamber by Sheriff’s Deputies in a scene that
underscored the human impact of this project.

Six supervisors supported the project: David Chiu, Malia Cohen, Carmen
Chu, Sean Elsbernd, Mark Farrell, and Scott Wiener. Strangely, Elsbernd
opened the session with remarks about how the demolition plan must be
approved in order to keep the Parkmerced community intact.

Supervisors John Avalos, David Campos, Jane Kim, Eric Mar and Ross
Mirkarimi voted against the project. Campos emphasized that he could not
accept the risks regarding enforceability of rent control on
replacement units. Mar condemned the clear-cutting of the existing
community at Parkmerced. Avalos expressed his opposition to the project
and offered an amendment to provide vacancy control on the newly
constructed units.

The Parkmerced fight will now shift to the ballot and the courtroom. In
its zeal to embrace this project, the City violated numerous
obligations under CEQA. Expect a legal challenge to the Environmental
Impact Report and check your next ballot handbook for your opportunity
to stop this unconscionable mass demolition project. San Francisco
voters are far less likely than Supervisors to be persuaded that this
project is too big to reject.

Amidst all of the troubling news on this project, there are many who
deserve credit for putting people over reckless real estate speculation.
Supervisors Avalos, Campos, Kim, Mar and Mirkarimi refused to be party
to this wholesale destruction of a community. No doubt they withstood
enormous pressure to support the project, yet they stood firm and did
the right thing.

Planning Commission President Christina Olague and Commissioners Kathrin
Moore and Hisashi Sugaya – the Board of Supervisors appointees to the
Commission – voted against this project after months of hearings.
Commissioners Moore and Sugaya were highly critical of the project and
prepared detailed comments that guided, and will continue to guide, much
of the discussion about the Parkmerced proposal.

Nonetheless, the Planning Commission approved the project 4-3 and the
Board of Supervisors, under the leadership of David Chiu, approved the
project 6-5.

Supervisor Chiu has put the well-being of thousands of San Francisco renters in jeopardy. It is a decision he will regret.

FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together.  This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: