Desperate tenants in poor conditions fear reprisals

Monday, January 10, 2011
Ashley Gebb
Appeal-Democrat

Black, brown, yellow and bluish mold creeps up from the floor in a bedroom corner and reaches chest-high in the adjacent closet. Rotten Sheetrock crumbles and bulges near the floor.

The carpet in the children's bedroom is soggy and the walls slimy to the touch. The Yuba City apartment has no heat, but the rooms are warm and steamy with humidity.

"I'm afraid to even let them sleep in here," said resident Kathryn Olschowka. "They all have a runny nose, they are all stuffed up. I'm concerned they are getting it because of the mold."

Black mold is just one of the problems tenants at Twin Pool Garden Apartments are living with these days. No heat, no smoke detectors, and water dripping around electrical fixtures adds to the headaches of cockroach infestations, broken appliances and leaking faucets.

"I love it, it's still our house, it's still our home," Olschowka said. "I just want things to be fixed."

Deplorable living conditions in the Yuba-Sutter area may have been worsened by the economy, but housing for low-income renters has always been a battle, says Dylan Saake, directing attorney for California Rural Legal Assistance. The fear of a forced move and potential homelessness pushes residents who may not know their rights to continue living in subpar — and sometimes illegal —conditions.

"It's not that low-income individuals don't have the capacity or the intelligence to assert their rights — it's the lack of resources," he said. "That's what gives leverage to bad landlords — they know that fear will keep people from causing too many problems."

Residents at the Gray Avenue complex have chosen to speak up.

Problem after problem

Angel Callier, 31, and Josh Larrabee, 20, have lived in their unit since February, but the ceiling around the bedroom light fixture turned spongey about a month ago and water now drips into a coffee can on the floor.

"It sizzles when I turn the light on," said Callier, who is five months pregnant. "The smell is making me sick, and I can't do this anymore."

A portable heater is what they use for warmth, since the apartment's heater is broken and exposed wires are all that's left of a thermostat. They cover the hole in the wall with a picture.

They've thought about withholding rent but are afraid of eviction, the last thing they need with a baby on the way. In the meantime, their phone calls to the landlord are getting them nowhere.

"He ain't getting nothing done. All he wants is rent money," Larrabee said. "He's a slumlord."

Landlord Michael Hart, who lives in Chico, did not return the Appeal-Democrat's phone calls.

Residents say that no response from their landlord is the norm. Most pay $645 for monthly rent in the 64-unit complex.

Olschowka moved in July 16, but had looked at the apartment weeks earlier, when it was obvious the previous tenant was evicted. No walk-through to identify damage or problems was ever offered.

"They don't do anything," she said. "No credit check, no application. 'Show me the money' That's what he says."

Olschowka, 30, had been homeless for more than a year, after losing her house and evictions for nonpayment in other places. Hands of Hope helped her with a deposit at Twin Pool Garden Apartments and to cover her debt with Pacific Gas & Electric so she could get power.

She lives on welfare, food stamps and $50 a month in child support, and with a bad rental history and poor credit, the stay-at-home mom doesn't know any other housing complexes that might take her.

Seven people live in her two-bedroom, one-bath unit, including her six children, ages 7 months to 9 years. The apartment, however bad, is a roof over their heads, she said.

Mold can be found once more under her kitchen sink, which was leaking above and below the cabinets. After months of requests, the landlord finally provided a new faucet head to replace broken parts two weeks ago.

A while back, one burner on her avocado-green stove caught fire. Another is missing a coil and sparks when turned on; one does not work at all.

"I need them to get it fixed, but at the same time, am I going to be able to find a place to live if we get evicted because I spoke out?" Olschowka asks, tears running down her face. "I know that by law he can't do that, but it still scares me."

The landlord's response to her problems is "OK, we'll take care of it," and then he never does, she said.

"It's like, 'If you don't like it, move. We'll find somebody else to rent it,'" she said. "These apartments move quick — and I see why."

But little is fixed between tenants.

When Amanda Crooks, 30, was living in Callier and Larrabee's apartment last year, her 3-year-old daughter fell sick with pneumonia. The unit didn't have heat then either.

She decided to move, but the landlord convinced her to stay, offering a free move and no new deposit for another unit.

"It's hard to find a two-bedroom around here for $650," Crooks said. "And I've got three kids and $800 a month on welfare."

The wood on her porch ceiling has rotted away and water leaks around the light. The cockroaches that crawl on the walls and hover in cabinets make for a never-ending battle.

"You can bomb one house but they are just gonna move back after you're done," she said. "It's always one thing or another,"

Non-English-speaking tenants and illegal immigrants are taken advantage of even worse, Crooks said.

Living off Social Security while he waits for admittance into the Army, Nathan Brown can't afford to repair his unit himself. If things don't get fixed soon, he said he'll quit paying rent and move in with his foster family.

The lack of smoke detectors is his greatest concern, because he often baby-sits for his cousins but knows children should be in a place with basic safety infrastructure.

"What happens if I'm asleep and there's a fire?" he asks.

That danger did happen for Alissa Corbin, 18, who also lives in the complex, only she woke up in time to catch it. When asked if she has smoke detectors, she laughs.

"We had our heater on just like any other family in wintertime," she said.

Only the unit's heater was in the closet. The Fire Department told her it had to be repaired but the appliance was put back days later with just new wiring, then later moved to an outer wall.

Corbin is still too afraid to use it.

"We use the oven any time it's really cold," she said.

A steady stream of water flows from her tap, unable to turn off, and she has roaches like many of her neighbors.

Until her situation improves, she's not paying rent. The scorched, melted pink Christmas dress belonging to her 18-month-old daughter, Baeley Atkins, still hangs in the closet as evidence of the fire.

She pays $525 for the office-turned-studio.

"I've lived here four months and I hope this one is going to be my last," she said. "In my opinion, people come before money, bottom line."

Within their rights, or not

The city is the first step toward identifying and resolving problems beyond initial tenant-landlord disputes, said Community Development Director Aaron Busch. But like many code enforcement issues, the city tends to be reactive and is largely dependent on tenants to notify it of problems.

"As soon as we do receive notification, we go through proper procedures," he said.

Tenants must notify their landlord of problems in writing, and the landlord has 30 days to respond. If the problems are not fixed, the tenant can come to the city, file a complaint with a copy of what the landlord received and a city inspector will pay a visit.

If there is any deviation from housing or building codes, the landlord typically has 30 days to file for permits and complete the improvements, Busch said. Any immediate threat or dangers to health and safety, such as lack of heat or hazardous wiring, are inspected immediately.

"We are here to ensure homes are not substandard," he said. "If there are cosmetic issues that are the center of the dispute, we really cannot get involved in that."

Mold is a problem that goes unregulated by federal, state or local governments, said Robert Boyer, building official for Sutter County. It is only addressed when it causes structural damage.

The Yuba City Fire Department does its best to monitor apartments for fire-related safety issues, following an 18-month inspection cycle, said Fire Marshal Jim Mathews. Twin Pool Garden Apartments was last inspected in July 2009, so it is due again.

Like houses, apartments are required to have smoke detectors in sleeping units and hallways leading to sleeping units. Landlords must ensure smoke detectors are installed and functioning prior to leasing.

Yuba City also mandates that landlords or property managers fill out a form saying they checked every smoke detector in every unit and report how many were defective and fixed.

Tenants assume some of the burden after moving in, Mathews said, and would need to notify the landlord if the battery is dead or the detector stops functioning.

As with smoke detectors, every living space is required to have heat by means of a heater than can produce 70 degrees 3 feet off the floor.

"Ovens don't qualify, little plug-in space heaters don't qualify," Mathews said. "It becomes an uninhabitable space if they don't have heat."

Property owners who do not comply with smoke detector or heat requirements face penalties, Mathews said.

"I'll give education the opportunity to work, and generally it works," he said. "Then there are some people who are just slumlords and won't do anything until they are called."

Finding a solution

At California Rural Legal Assistance, Saake was not familiar with Twin Pool Garden Apartments or its tenants' living conditions but said that it's not uncommon in this area — or any area — for renters living in subpar conditions to not assert their housing rights, especially because of moving costs.

"Knowing that fear of being unable to move also creates a fear of 'Am I going to be retaliated against if I voice my complaints?'" Saake said. "Retaliation is prohibited by law, but of course sometimes it happens."

And when landlords are uncooperative landlord, sometimes it takes a focused action by a group of residents to see positive results.

"The key is when a group of tenants do get together and say 'Enough!," Saake said.

Both he and Mathews say education is a major component.

"We spend a lot of our energy trying to make sure people know what their rights are and how you go about asserting them," Saake said.

Sometimes landlords don't have the resources to make the necessary repairs, which is understandable, but some improvements can always be made, he said. The economy has only worsened the problem.

"There is zero doubt in my mind that there is far more of this going on than anybody realizes," Mathews said upon learning the conditions at the complex. "And that scares me."

Renters are entitled to at least the basic amenities, which include smoke detectors, heat and safe wiring, he said. Improving other subpar conditions is just the right thing to do.

"People in this country, in this state, should not be subjected to living like that," Mathews said.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: