Developers' new plan: Rental homes

Wednesday, June 16, 2010
Courtenay Edelhart
The Bakersfield Californian

Some land speculators who got stuck with a bunch of property after
the real estate market crash have come up with a creative solution to
the soft market for new homes.

An entire community of brand new rental homes. That's the latest
project by Bakersfield-based 6152 Partners, a group of five investors
who bought land in the southwest five years ago only to watch
developers and other potential buyers scatter.

Silverado Ranch, just north of Taft Highway off Wible Road, is a
subdivision of new single-family homes. At build out, there will be 53
total, including one occupied by an on-site property manager.

Half of the homes are complete and occupied by renters. The rest
should be done by the end of September, and eager families are lining
up to move in.

"We've got people who've submitted applications for houses that
aren't even finished yet," said property manager Justin Eccleston of
Professional Realty Management.

Many of the renters are former homeowners who have lost their homes,
he said. That's not surprising considering that about half of
Bakersfield-area mortgage borrowers owe more than their homes are
worth. Last month alone, there were 660 foreclosures in Kern County.

Those people need a place to live, and because their credit histories are marred, they can't get a loan to purchase again.

Eccleston said Silverado Ranch overlooks foreclosure as long as a
prospective renter's credit is otherwise in good shape, and they can
afford the rent.

Granite countertops

That enabled Cynthia Martinez and her family to move into a
four-bedroom home there in March. They had fallen victim to an alleged
loan modification scam, which culminated in foreclosure.

"Our old house was right down the street, so we knew the
neighborhood," Martinez said. "It's actually pretty good. It's quiet,
and the houses are really, really nice. We have granite countertops and
landscaping and good blinds, not the cheap ones you usually see in
rentals."

Best of all, she added, she and her husband now pay $1,200 a month less for housing than they did before.

"We're saving a ton of money," Martinez said. "We're going to stay
here a few years until we can build our credit back up, and then go at
it again."

Tennile Moxley, 32, moved to the community in April from another rented home. She says tenants are screened well.

"You don't see drug dealing thugs or three and four families piled
up in the same house with six cars in the driveway, which was a big
problem where we were before," Moxley said. "I love it here. I get a
brand new house, but I don't have to come up with $15,000 down."

Two exits

The developers aren't sure what their long-term plan is.

"There are two exit strategies," said partner Steve Lantz. "We could
sell the houses after the housing market comes back, but we've been so
satisfied with the way it's turned out and the quality of the renters,
we may just keep it the way it is."

Another partner, Brian Alexander, said he expects it will be a while
before new home purchases really pick up steam again, anyway.

"I think we've seen some signs of life, but with the expiration of
the federal tax credit, I don't know," he said. "There are just so many
tentative maps out there. There are still quite a few large,
semi-developed pieces."

6152 Partners bought the land five years ago and was in escrow with
a builder at one point, but the builder walked away when the market
tanked.

The land was grandfathered in under the city's old traffic impact development fee, which roughly doubled last year.

That was just a temporary reprieve, however. If the developers had
waited too long to build, they'd have been subject to the new fee.

Rather than risk that, the partners began new home construction on
the land in August, and the first tenants moved in in January.

The homes are 1,200- to 1,600-square-feet and each has a two-car
attached garage and either three or four bedrooms. Rent is $1,195 to
$1,349 depending on the number of bedrooms and the floor plan.

An uncommon arrangement

City Councilman Zack Scrivner, whose seventh ward includes the
project, said he knows of neighborhoods with high numbers of rentals,
but this is the first development he's heard of that consists
exclusively of rental homes.

There's no way for the city to regulate or even track such
developments, he said. When someone pulls a building permit, they don't
have to specify whether they're going to sell the house or rent it.

Scrivner said he isn't wild about the idea of such a dense
concentration of rentals, but, "If they've got an on-site property
manager, then I guess there's a better chance they'll be maintained.

"I'd also be worried about a lot of homes sitting vacant, but it sounds like they're filling them pretty fast."

Still, Scrivner said he'd keep an eye on the project to watch for public nuisances.

There aren't likely to be many more like it, said Paul Habibi,
professor of real estate at UCLA. In a normal market, the economics of
building for rent don't work nearly as well as building for sale.

But this isn't a normal market.

"What you've got is a perfect storm," he said.

An extraordinary number of families have been forced out of their
homes but can't buy another one either because they have bad credit, or
because banks won't lend even to buyers with good credit.

Habibi predicted that most home developers with inventory they can't
move will clear out tenants and sell as soon as the market comes back.

Until then, he said he didn't think the rentals would hurt the home values of surrounding homeowners.

"As long as it's not affordable housing, and they're renting at market rate, new houses can only help the area," he said.


FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

 

Help build power for renters' rights: