A fight has erupted over an infill development project near
the northern boundary of the city's Castro District that is pitting affordable
housing for LGBT seniors against units for low-income renters.
Community groups, city officials, and the project's
developers have been meeting for months to try to forge a deal that would fund
Openhouse's LGBT senior housing project, and still result in having 49
below-market-rate units among the 330 market-rate housing units built on site.
The project in question, located at 55 Laguna, was home to
the former UC Berkeley Extension campus and lies a block away from the LGBT
Community Center. It is one of the last available large parcels near the heart
of the city's gayborhood.
Housing activists, while supportive of the units for
seniors, are loath to lose the affordable apartments that could be rented by
people living with HIV, LGBT youth, or low-income queers.
Yet Wood Partners, which has taken over as the lead
developer of the project, and the Mayor's Office of Housing have proposed that
the company, rather than build the affordable housing on-site, pay a $17
million in lieu of fee that would be used to help pay for Openhouse's 110-units
of affordable senior housing, estimated to cost upwards of $60 million.
The proposal reneges on the deal hammered out in 2008 that
led to city approval of the project and would need to be approved by the
Planning Commission. A hearing is tentatively scheduled for August 4.
"We want Openhouse to happen. But the idea of pitting
one group of people against another is problematic," said Tommi Avicolli
Mecca, a queer activist and the Housing Rights Committee of San Francisco's
counseling program director. "Those 49 units could go to HIV-positive
people. It is the last block of affordable housing we will get in the Castro in
a long time."
Openhouse officials are just as concerned that their project
could be fatally jeopardized if a deal isn't struck before September, when they
hope to finalize their lease with UC and move ahead with the design phase for
their building.
"The Planning Commission really needs to happen on
August 4 in order to keep the timeline moving along. If that doesn't happen
that can certainly possibly delay our negotiations with UC," said Seth
Kilbourn, Openhouse's executive director. "It causes a lot of problems for
Wood Partners keeping their process moving along. Delay on this is not good for
the long-term prospects of the project."
When the jettisoning of the on-site affordable rental units
was first proposed, Openhouse, which has teamed with Mercy Housing California
to build its project, did not object. Instead, the agency sided with the
proposed fee change and sent out an action alert in May asking supporters to
contact planning commissioners and urge them to back the fee proposal.
"The $17 million fee takes the place of building
multifamily units on the site that would be affordable to low-income renters.
But the fee does make the Openhouse
project possible," wrote Kilbourn.
He later added, in bold italic type for emphasis, that,
"Without the fee, Openhouse can't build the housing that LGBT seniors and
their friends so urgently need. As a result, the project could die or be
delayed indefinitely."
The alert was the first time many community leaders learned
that changes to the original deal were being proposed.
"Starting in December certain parties to that deal
started going behind everybody's back, including Openhouse, trying to change the
terms of the deal. They were trying to screw the community out of $88 million
in rent savings," said AIDS Housing Alliance director Brian Basinger,
referring to the reduced price of the 49 rental units.
While Kilbourn stopped short of issuing a formal apology for
not notifying the community sooner about the proposed changes to the
development deal, he did tell the Bay Area Reporter
that Openhouse now regrets that decision.
"Yes, we absolutely should have brought this idea to
the community sooner than we did. Regretfully, we didn't bring the idea to the
community and we should have once the Mayor's Office of Housing sent the letter
to planning," said Kilbourn. "I do regret that it unfolded the way it
did."
Dariush Khan, deputy director of the mayor's housing office,
could not be reached for comment by press time Wednesday. Frank Middleton, Wood
Partners' San Francisco office director, did not respond to an interview
request.
In late April Middleton told the San Francisco Business
Times that "the project's overall
vision remains intact and reflects years of community interest."
Housing market collapsed
Openhouse has spent decades pushing to see an assisted
living center for LGBT seniors built in the city. At first a market-rate
project, it switched to being affordable housing at the insistence of housing
activists like Basinger and Avicolli Mecca.
In exchange for Openhouse changing focus, the Mayor's Office
of Housing promised it would secure funding to help pay for the project. While
no dollar amounts or funding streams were specified, it was believed the money
would come from in-lieu payments the housing office collected from developers
of other projects eschewing on-site below-market-rate units.
Then the housing market collapsed, and the funding dried up.
A change instituted under former Mayor Gavin Newsom, that pushed back requiring
developers to pay the fees upfront to when their projects were finished,
further exacerbated the housing office's budget issues.
Kilbourn said the reason Openhouse didn't raise objections
about the in-lieu fee proposal was because it believed the mayor's housing
office when it said there was no other money to pay for the project.
"We were taking what the Mayor's Office of Housing said
at face value," said Kilbourn. "If they have no money and this is the
only option we have, we decided we will move forward because Openhouse is
important."
The agency also believed that using the $17 million as
leverage to secure the rest of the financing it needs for its project is an
"incredibly efficient use of scarce local dollars," said Kilbourn.
"This is a massive investment that will ultimately
benefit the LGBT community," he said. "This Openhouse project is
incredibly urgent and critical for the LGBT senior community, which is a voice
that really has not been heard enough of in this whole discussion. It is really
important for us, between now and August 4, to make sure the voices of the LGBT
senior community, who have waited for years for this housing to be built, be
heard."
It remains unclear if a deal will be reached in time that is
acceptable to all parties involved. Some options being discussed include
raising how much renters would be charged for the 49 affordable units or
securing a bridge loan to pay for the city's contribution to Openhouse that the
mayor's housing office would pay back later.
Another meeting with interested parties to hammer out a
compromise is scheduled to take place this afternoon (Thursday, July 7).
"I think that everybody is on the same page to figure
out how to put the BMRs back on-site," said Kilbourn. "We are all
working toward the same goal here."
Basinger said he remains hopeful a solution can be found
that all sides will accept.
"I think everyone is committed to this and coming up
with a solution. It is going to happen," he said.
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.