Everybody hates public housing, except the low-income people who live there and the people on the long waiting lists to get in.
Now, after years of neglect, the Obama Administration wants to save
public housing for future generations. It has a plan to inject billions
of dollars into the developments to make long-deferred repairs.
But a few liberal Congressmembers,advocacy groups, and left-wing
academics view the proposal with skepticism, worried that it is really
a scheme to "privatize" the government-run housing projects and lead to
rising rents, evictions, and perhaps the elimination of scarce
affordable housing.
A recent memo written by some radical urban studies professors makes
it seem like Obama wants to hand public housing over to Goldman Sachs
or turn the low-income projects into luxury housing. And separately, in
an article for Huffington Post,
George Lakoff, the well-known UC-Berkeley linguistics professor, warns
that the Obama administration is trying to "privatize all public
housing in America" and "give conservatives a victory they could not
have anticipated." It is, Lakoff wrote, evidence of Obama's "move to
the right."
The critics raise some important concerns, but their attacks on the
Obama administration's motives and objectives are misguided. By doing
so, they are playing into the hands of most Republicans, who would like
nothing more than to destroy public housing, which to them is a symbol
of "big government" and an excessive "welfare state" for the poor. The
liberal critics - including some tenants groups, anti-poverty lawyers,
and academics -- need to stop the scare tactics and figure out how to
seize this rare opportunity to take advantage of having a president who
actually wants to preserve public housing for the long term.
As the National Low-Income Housing Coalition stated in its
Congressional testimony: "Private resources could be public housing's
savior or its greatest enemy." What's important is how the White House
and Congress shape the legislation. Recent experience with big banks,
the oil industry, the coal mines, the insurance companies, and other
sectors suggests that government has to be more than a just a neutral
watchdog when it comes to business. The progressive agenda is for
government to establish tough rules and regulations, and enforce them
with adequate inspectors and penalties, to make corporations behave
responsibly.
Ever since it began in the Depression as part of the New Deal,
public housing has been a political orphan. The nation's economic
collapse provided reformers with a political opening to push their
then-radical idea that the federal government should subsidize "social
housing" and help create a noncommercial sector free from profit and
speculation. They envisioned that public housing would be for the
middle-class as well as the poor. They pushed for well-designed,
mixed-income, government-subsidized housing projects, sponsored by
unions, church groups, other non-profit organizations, and government
agencies.
During its first few years, the New Deal built a few model
developments that reflected this vision, described by historian Gail
Radford in her book, Modern Housing for America. They included day care
centers and playgrounds, involved residents in cultural and educational
activities, and were physically attractive enough so that middle-class
families wanted to live there.
But the reformers were soon outmaneuvered by the real estate
industry. The industry -- worried that well-designed and affordable
government-sponsored housing would compete with the private sector for
middle-class consumers -- warned about the specter of "socialism."
After World War Two, recognizing the pent-up demand for housing and
fearing competition from public housing, the industry mobilized a major
campaign against the program. Especially with the federal housing act
of 1949, the industry sabotaged the program by pressuring Congress to
restrict its funding, give local governments discretion over whether
and where to locate developments, and limit it to the very poor.
Senators from the South made sure that local governments had the
authority to keep public housing racially segregated.
With limited budgets, many projects were poorly constructed and/or
badly designed - ugly warehouses for the poor - stigmatizing
"government housing" as housing of last resort. The local housing
authorities - at the time owned by local governments but whose boards
were dominated by business and real estate representatives -- often
sited public housing developments in areas without adequate stores,
transportation, or schools, and isolated from middle-class
neighborhoods, contributing to the concentration of poor people in
cities.
In other words, the problems we now associate with public housing
were not inevitable. They were due to political choices made in
Congress and at the local level.
Even so, the best-kept secret about public housing is that it
actually provides decent, affordable housing for many people. Properly
run, it remains one of the best options for housing the poor. Vincent
Lane, former chairman of the Chicago Housing Authority (CHA), remembers
when public housing was new. In the 1950s, Lane's family moved from the
South to a cold-water flat opposite the CHA's Wentworth Gardens public
housing development. The CHA project boasted broad playgrounds, heat,
hot water, and basketball courts. "I envied the kids in public
housing," Lane recalls. "The best housing in the community was
Wentworth Gardens."
In many places, this is still true. There are also probably more
than 500,000 families on the waiting lists of the nation's 3,060 local
housing authorities. In many cities, it takes between two and five
years -- and sometimes longer -- to get off the waiting list and into
public housing. Public housing developments are often better - and
certainly more affordable -- than apartments available to the poor in
the private housing market, which is why the waiting lists continue to
swell.
Despite the popular stereotypes, a decade ago high-rises accounted
for only one-quarter of public housing buildings. Many of those
high-rise projects have been demolished in the past two decades. As a
result, most public housing developments today are garden apartments,
low-rise walk-ups, and single-family homes or townhouses. But the
high-rise projects, most of them in the largest cities, accounted for
many of the most problematic developments and cast a giant shadow on
the whole program.
Right-wing politicians have long used misleading stereotypes about
public housing to attack the very idea of government activism. In the
1980s, the Reagan administration wanted to sell off public housing and
eliminate the federal government's commitment to house the poor. During
his 1996 campaign, for example, Republican presidential nominee Bob
Dole said that public housing was "one of the last bastions of
socialism in the world", calling local housing authorizes "landlords of
misery." More recently, after the Katrina hurricane, Congressman
Richard Baker (R-LA) was overheard telling lobbyists, "We finally
cleaned up public housing in New Orleans. We couldn't do it, but God
did."
Years of opposition to public housing - from the real estate
industry and conservatives -- meant that very little of it actually was
built. Public housing represents less than one percent of the nation's
overall housing stock and only about one-third of government-subsidized
housing for the poor. (The Section 8 housing voucher program -- a kind
of food stamp program for housing -- is larger in terms of the number
of families served, but most low-income families get no federal housing
subsidy of any kind).
Most of today's public housing developments were constructed in the
1950s, 1960s, and early 1970s, before the Nixon administration and
Congress ended construction of new projects in 1973.
Since then, Congress has failed to provide adequate funding to
maintain and repair these developments. Today there are roughly 1.2
million public housing apartments that house about 2.3 million
low-income people. Although many of its residents work, they are among
the nation's poorest citizens. The average annual income for a public
housing household in the United States is $13,414. Without public
housing - for which they pay 30% of their incomes, with the federal
government paying the rest - they would inevitably be living in awful
substandard slums, or paying half or more of their income just to keep
a roof over their heads, or find themselves homeless.
Previous administrations have had little use for public housing and
the poor people who live there. In the past 15 years alone, about
200,000 units have been torn down, forcing the tenants to find housing
in the private market, where affordable apartments are extremely hard
to find. Only about 50,000 of those units have been - or are planned to
be - replaced. After years of neglect, the nation's remaining public
housing projects now need $20 billion to $30 billion of critical
repairs, such as new roofs, heating systems, window, and
energy-efficient appliances. The federal government subsidizes tenants'
rents, but that isn't enough to pay for decades of deferred maintenance.
The best solution would be for Congress to simply allocate the
funding for a one-time infusion to make long-neglected repairs. But
because there are so few people who live in public housing, and because
they are not well organized, Congress has little incentive to do so.
(Last year's stimulus bill include $4 billion for public housing
capital improvements, but that was a one-time emergency measure).
So HUD Secretary Shaun Donovan, who has spent his career improving
housing for the poor, has proposed that local housing authorities be
permitted to borrow money from private lenders to help fill the funding
gap. Officially, his proposal is called the Preservation, Enhancement,
and Transforming Rental Assistance Act, or PETRA. Under the plan, HUD
would allow local housing authorities to raise rents to market levels,
in order to attract private investors. HUD would then fill in the gap
between what low-income tenants can afford and the rents. Tenants will
continue to pay only 30% of their income for rent.
The Obama administration has asked for $290M for the first year of
the PETRA program, which would attract enough private mortgage loans to
repair about 200,000 to 300,000 units. This, however, is simply a
downpayment. To leverage the $25 billion in private funds to upgrade
the entire public housing stock, Congress needs to allocate a total of
$800 million to $1.6 billion a year.
Some tenant groups and their allies worry that, if PETRA passes,
private lenders will care more about the bottom line than about
tenants' needs, and put their lives, and their housing, at risk. It is,
wrote the group of urban studies academics, "the latest attempt to
remove safety nets" from the poor. They worry, too, that private
investors might be careless stewards of this valuable housing resource.
As one public housing tenant activist testified to Congress in May:
"Make no mistake, the private market's only motivation here is profit
and let us not forget that this is the same private market that just
crashed our economy, took billions in taxpayer funded bailouts, and
aren't fixing the messing they created."
Given public housing's history, these concerns are understandable.
But given the political and fiscal realities, what's needed is a way to
allow local housing authorities to borrow private funding while
maintaining ownership and control of the developments, and protecting
the rights of current and future tenants to decent, affordable,
well-maintained housing.
Secretary Donovan needs to do a better job than he did in recent
testimony before Congress to address the concerns raised by tenants and
their supporters, including Congressmembers Barney Frank and Maxine
Waters. For example:
- Donovan's proposal has no cap on the interest rate that
lenders can charge housing authorities. This is a serious problem.
We've had enough recent experience with predatory and irresponsible
lenders to know that the federal government needs to toughen
regulations to protect consumers from greedy lenders. We also need to
protect public housing agencies, and their tenants, from rapacious
lenders. The best solution would be to require all project to have
Federal Housing Administration (FHA) insurance, so they fall under the
relatively strict FHA standards for loans. - Under Donovan's
plan, local housing authorizes could, with HUD's permission, charge
rents that are 10% over market rates if this is needed to attract
private loans. He hasn't yet spelled out what criteria HUD would use
before granting these increases. Some critics worry that, under this
scenario, tax dollars could be used to give banks and investors a huge,
and unnecessary, windfall, especially in high-rent areas like Los
Angeles. - How can Donovan guarantee that Congress will
allocate sufficient subsidies to fill the gap between what tenants pay
and the higher market rates? This is particularly worrisome if
Americans elect a subsequent president or Congress that has less
concern for the poor. - If Congress doesn't provide the needed
funds, how will HUD guarantee that local public housing authorities
will be able to repay the loans to private banks? And if they don't,
what's to stop private lenders from foreclosing on the developments?
Some critics warn that once banks take possession of these projects,
they could allow the housing to further deteriorate, or sell them off
to private developers for market rate housing, especially in cities
where they are located in gentrifying neighborhoods? The bill specifies
that even in the event of a foreclosure, the units have to remain
affordable to low-income renters for at least 30 years. - Indeed,
the current proposal requires that all the public housing repaired
under PETRA be affordable to the poor for another 30 years. But the
genius of public housing was to provide a permanently affordable stock
of noncommercial housing. The nation has already lost hundreds of
thousands of privately-owned, government-subsidized housing because the
low-income "use restrictions" expired after 20 years. Let's not make
that mistake again. When taxpayers' dollars build or repair public
housing, those units should be available "in perpetuity" for the
nation's poor. - Although Donovan insists that the local
housing agencies will retain both ownership and control of the public
housing projects, his proposal allows HUD to wave this obligation.
Although the Obama administration may never exercise this option, the
legislation needs to lock in public ownership so that subsequent
administrations don't put public housing on the auction block. - Moreover,
HUD should not paint all public housing with the same brush. Only
developments that really need repairs should be allowed to participate
in the PETRA program. HUD needs an updated assessment of the physical
condition, and cost of repairs, of every public housing development in
the country. - According to Donovan, PETRA preserves and even
strengthens tenants' rights against rent increases and unfair evictions
- and gives tenants groups an unprecedented right to organize and have
a much stronger voice in the day-to-day operations of their
developments. Even so, HUD needs to make sure that the next generation
of public housing managers - whether they are on the government payroll
or hired by local housing authorities to manage the projects - are
experienced, qualified, and respect tenant organizing. Perhaps what's
needed is a landlord-tenant counterpart to the National Labor Relations
Act , giving tenants the right to organize and negotiate collectively
with management over issues like maintenance, eviction rules, job
training programs, and the provision of social service programs. - Donovan's
plan requires local housing authorities to give tenants the right to
return if they have to temporarily vacate their apartments so they can
undergone extensive repairs. The plan requires housing agencies to pay
tenants for temporary housing and relocation back to public housing.
This is an important protection. To make this work, HUD needs to
require that local housing agencies keep track of those tenants, inform
them of their right to return, and pay for both their temporary housing
and their relocation back to public housing. - Donovan wants
to allow local housing authorities to rent public housing apartments to
working class, even middle class, families to restore the original
Depression-era vision of mixed-income housing. He wants to remove
public housing's stigma as government-subsidized ghettoes that
concentrate and isolate the poor from the rest of society. This is
absolutely the correct idea, but to make it work, Donovan needs to make
sure that it is not achieved at the expense of low-income tenants. That
means providing poor tenants who voluntarily choose to leave with
housing vouchers so they can find and afford private housing,
preferably in middle-class neighborhoods. But for that scenario to
work, HUD needs to guarantee that there is sufficient low-income rental
housing in the area, or market-rate apartments whose landlords who will
accept families with HUD vouchers. But tenant-based vouchers are not an
adequate replacement for when real units are lost. HUD needs to toughen
that part of PETRA that requires local housing authorities to replace
any low-income units lost, and the money must be allocated to make this
happen. - The federal funds used to carry out this PETRA
program should not come at the expense of other HUD programs,
especially the expansion of the housing voucher program for families
now living in private apartments that are too expensive or so run down
that they put the tenants, especially children, at risk for their
health and safety.
Let's put this debate over public housing in perspective. Last year,
the federal government provided American homeowners with $110 billion
in tax deductions for mortgage interest and property taxes. In
principle, using tax breaks to help working and middle class families
buy and keep their homes is a good idea. But about one-third of this
tax subsidy - over $33 billion - goes to the wealthiest 2.6% of
taxpayers with incomes over $200,000. That annual government subsidy
for the richest homeowners could, on its own, pay for the one-time
repair of every deteriorating public housing development in the
country. Congress has the money to fix public housing, but it lacks the
political will.
Unfortunately, the Obama White House and progressive Democrats in
Congress cannot simply snap their fingers and usher in a new wave of
progressive legislation. We saw this during the health care debate,
where reform advocates met enormous resistance from the drug companies,
insurance industry, and their allies in Congress - both Republicans and
moderate Democrats. As a result, progressives who wanted a single-payer
system, and liberals who wanted a robust "public option," all had to
compromise in order to win the landmark legislation that Obama signed
in March, expanding coverage for over 30 million Americans and
improving existing coverage for many more. Progressives know that this
bill is not the end of health care reform, but a foundation on which to
build in the future.
In one way or another, health care reform affected a majority of all
Americans. In contrast, public housing has very little direct impact on
most Americans. It is not very high on the nation's political radar,
certainly far below other housing issues, like the epidemic of
foreclosures facing families and communities across the county.
So having a President, a HUD Secretary, and Congress that wants to
invest their political capital - as well as real money - in public
housing is a rare moment. This may be the last chance for public
housing advocates to make a difference, because many of the projects
have already reached, or will soon reach, the tipping point when they
are beyond repair.
Challenging the Obama administration to clarify and improve its
PETRA plan is a good strategy. But they should be pushing for what the
radical Michael Harrington called the "left wing of the possible." This
is no time for progressive housing activists and advocates to waste
time on finger-pointing, name-calling, and fear-mongering, or confusing
most Republicans' disdain for the poor and public housing with Obama's
willingness to find solutions that will preserve public housing for
America's neediest families.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.