A couple of weeks ago, the satirical newspaper The Onion reported that the City of San Francisco was looking to relocate because its current location had become too expensive. Funny though this was, I expected the follow-up story to focus on the economic development incentive package being put together to keep San Francisco where it is.
A week or so later, Gabriel Metcalfe – head of the respected San Francisco urban planning organization SPUR – published a provocative piece in CityLab blaming the city’s affordability crisis on progressive politics – especially progressive politics of the no-growth kind. Progressive San Francisco, he argued, “had a fatal, Shakespearean flaw that would prove to be its undoing: It decided early on to be against new buildings. It decided that new development, with the exception of publicly subsidized affordable housing, was not welcome.”
All up and down California – especially in the expensive coastal enclaves around San Francisco and Los Angeles – community activists have been lately decrying how the rising cost of housing is making it impossible for normal people with normal incomes to live in these towns. Yet, as Metcalf points out, most of the time these same community activists are arguing that the trend toward high housing cost must be countered with... less housing construction. Or at least less market-rate housing construction.
Perhaps the best example in Southern California is the recent “growth politics” melt-down in Santa Monica, which led the city council to rescind approval of a major development project near the Bergamot Station Expo Line station even though it contained a major housing component.
It’s no surprise when NIMBYs fight against new development projects because they want to preserve their community’s “character” – which usually means low-rise development and, they hope, a tolerable amount of traffic. But now a new generation of people – not quite NIMBYs, but not quite not NIMBYs – are arguing that you shouldn’t build more housing because housing is already really expensive. What gives?
What gives is this is what happens when supply and demand get intertwined in peculiar ways, as is happening up and down California today – and, indeed, as is occurring in desirable locations across the country and throughout the world.
The traditional economist’s assessment of the current situation would be pretty straightforward: Housing prices are going up because demand is outstripping supply. So if you create more supply, prices will come down (or at least stabilize) and the market will approach equilibrium. This is Gabriel Metcalfe’s argument: Like the rest of California, San Francisco’s been under-building for decades. Now that the city’s population is going up, this undersupply is beginning to show up in the market.
This, in turns, leads to the typical argument of the building industry or Joel Kotkin, which is that overregulation in California – especially the California Environmental Quality Act – has suppressed supply and screwed up the market.
All of this is true as far as it goes, but it doesn’t explain why people who are concerned about the high price of housing are against the construction of more housing. That’s happening because the interplay between supply and demand is more nuanced than traditional economics would suggest, and because the interplay between the market and politics isn’t always rational.
The problem is that under some market conditions, more supply doesn’t lead to market equilibrium because it actually creates its own demand. You can see this wherever the world’s uber-rich decide to buy houses – New York, London, or, most relevant to this discussion, Santa Barbara.
Santa Barbara has housing prices that are not supported by the underlying dynamics of the local economy, for one very simple reason: The uber-rich from around the world drive up home prices by paying premium prices, often for houses they don’t actually occupy very often. This throws the supply-demand equation out of whack; if you build more houses, the result might just be more uber-rich folks from out of town showing up to buy them, and that doesn’t help ordinary folks. In fact, for a while the debate in Santa Barbara centered on encouraging construction of certain types of housing that uber-rich wouldn’t want to buy, such as small rental apartments on busy streets. But given the revival of urban living, I wouldn’t even bet on that strategy working. Look at what’s happened to Charleston, which has rapidly become a second-home haven for people from New York.
And once the uber-rich throw the supply-demand equation out of whack, there’s a ripple effect. When I was in elected office in Ventura, we faced this very problem: A two-earner couple making $200,000 a year, having been driven out of Santa Barbara by the uber-rich, would show up in Ventura, and their jaws would drop at the prices. A hillside home with an ocean view for only $900,000? A three-bedroom track home for only $500,000? These folks would drive our prices up, thus driving our local folks out of town. An increased supply of housing in Ventura just meant an increased demand from Santa Barbara commuters, which didn’t really solve the problem.
Something similar is going on today in San Francisco and Santa Monica. These places are hotbeds for cool jobs. The folks taking the cool jobs may not be uber-rich, but they have tons more money than everybody else, and so they drive prices out of sight. Build more market-rate housing, and you’ll just accelerate the cycle – more smart kids will show up wanting to work for tech start-ups, and that means you’ll have more tech start-ups, and pretty soon demand will rise faster than supply – in large part because you increased the supply. To a local community activist, it feels like a no-win.
The solution isn’t easy – or, at least, it isn’t simple. Yes, you need to build way more new housing than we’ve done in California. But that housing needs to come in more types, forms, and even tenures than we have seen in a long time. Yes, some needs to be market-rate – but we need to recognize that this will be snapped up by highly successful folks and won’t necessarily bring about market equilibrium. Yes, some needs to be subsidized – but we need to recognize that we will never built enough affordable housing and so therefore to some extent we are creating housing for lucky lottery winners.
Maybe most important, we need to build – and, more important, be politically accepting of – a wide variety of housing types. Apartments of all sizes. Duplexes and triplexes. Micro-units. Even boarding houses, which will allow urban singles to live more cheaply and comfortably than they do now.
The growth control policies in coastal California began when everybody lived in a single-family house and most NIMBYs (and even environmentalists) believed that less was better. The solution today is not simply to restrict supply to preserve a neighborhood’s character because these will strangle our cities – and our emerging middle-class. Nor is it to let the private market loose, because this will turn the cities over to the uber-rich. The solution is both-and. We have to do everything we can.
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.