The notices arrived on their doors in the dark of night, residents say: Effective Feb. 15, 2014, Del Monte Manor – a 192-unit apartment complex in Seaside – would consider all U.S. Dept. of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) subsidies terminated in the property’s 98 HUD-subsidized units. Tenants in those units, the notice said, would soon have to pay the entirety of their rent.
But those notices omitted a key detail: A change of rental terms was never agreed to by HUD, and the notice itself constitutes a violation of tenants’ rights and a breach of federal contract.
Del Monte Manor Property Manager Dorene Matthews issued the 90-day notices on Nov. 15, 2013, citing HUD’s nonpayment of rent for the past 13 months as the reason. The notice says management “is saddened by HUD’s failure to reimburse Del Monte Manor their obligated portion of rents for their tenants for over a year,” and adds that “HUD has not acted in the best interest of our low-income families.” It also listed four HUD officials that residents could contact for relocation issues.
In response, HUD sent a letter seven days later to Norah Saffold, president of Seaside Civic League, Inc., the organization that owns Del Monte Manor. Seaside Civic League was founded by six local organizations – including the Ocean View Baptist Church and Greater Victory Temple – in 1965. Saffold is a trustee and deacon at Greater Victory, according to the church’s website.
The letter stated the 90-day notice, which changes rental terms for HUD-subsidized tenants, “is in direct violation of the [HUD] contract, and puts the health, safety, well-being and rights of the residents in jeopardy.” The letter also ordered the notice be rescinded.
“The owners or management are fear-mongering the residents,” says Gene Gibson, HUD’s regional public affairs officer for the Hawaii-Pacific region. Gibson adds that not only was the 90-day notice not rescinded, but an additional notice management was issued Jan. 28 and also violates the law. That notice extended the effective date of the rental terms change to March 1 and further explained management’s impasse with HUD.
Gibson says HUD has not paid its portion of the rent over the last 15 months because of improper filing practices, which she says Del Monte Manor’s management has long been aware of. “Reports have to be timely and on the proper form and in the proper format,” Gibson says. “That’s how contracts are.”
Gibson says HUD has advised management to hire someone familiar with HUD contracts to handle the paperwork, but Del Monte’s owners have refused. “They’ve dug in their heels and resisted,” Gibson says. She adds HUD sent letters to all affected residents on Dec. 22 to inform them they aren’t bound by the new terms, and urged them to seek legal counsel.
Calls to Del Monte Manor were all answered by the property’s receptionist Latasha Neal, who says management will not comment and declined to give out out Matthews’ phone number. Calls to a number listed for Saffold rang endlessly; Greater Victory Temple on Tuesday morning agreed to pass on a message to Saffold, but as of Wednesday morning there was no response.
Stuck in the middle are the subsidized residents: A meeting organized by the Alliance on Aging was held Jan. 29 at Oldemeyer Center to inform them of their rights. Jean Goebel, executive director of Housing Authority of the County of Monterey, and California Rural Legal Assistance attorneys Gretchen Regenhardt and Elena Dineen offered direction to 50-plus residents in attendance.
The main message: Residents who pay their agreed-upon rent cannot be evicted, and their rental terms cannot be changed, due to non-payment of subsidies by HUD.
“In order for an eviction to happen, it has to go through the court process,” Dineen says. “They can’t unilaterally change your portion of your payment.”
Goebel says she’s been instructed by HUD to prepare tenant protection vouchers, which residents could apply to housing elsewhere if negotiations fail.
Several residents, including Jimmy Welch, a member of the property’s tenants association, spoke during the meeting. “They’re gonna take you to court,” Welch says. “But if we came together, you’d be surprised what we can do as a people.”
The current 20-year HUD contract with the property was signed in 2011. Gibson says Del Monte Manor owners and management will not be let off the hook without either agreement – or prosecution. “We would like to see all this get worked out to everybody’s benefit,” she says. “[Prosecution] is something we only do as a last measure when all else fails.”
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.