Dust-up with picketing tenants puts L.A. housing authority chief in spotlight

×

Error message

  • Deprecated function: Creation of dynamic property MergeQuery::$condition is deprecated in MergeQuery->__construct() (line 1357 of /home/tenants/PROD_tenantstogether/public_html/includes/database/query.inc).
  • Deprecated function: Creation of dynamic property DatabaseCondition::$stringVersion is deprecated in DatabaseCondition->compile() (line 1887 of /home/tenants/PROD_tenantstogether/public_html/includes/database/query.inc).
  • Deprecated function: Creation of dynamic property DatabaseCondition::$stringVersion is deprecated in DatabaseCondition->compile() (line 1887 of /home/tenants/PROD_tenantstogether/public_html/includes/database/query.inc).
  • Deprecated function: Creation of dynamic property DatabaseCondition::$stringVersion is deprecated in DatabaseCondition->compile() (line 1887 of /home/tenants/PROD_tenantstogether/public_html/includes/database/query.inc).
  • Deprecated function: Creation of dynamic property DatabaseCondition::$stringVersion is deprecated in DatabaseCondition->compile() (line 1887 of /home/tenants/PROD_tenantstogether/public_html/includes/database/query.inc).
Sunday, November 28, 2010
Jessica Garrison and David Zahniser
Los Angeles Times

Rudolf Montiel holds one of the biggest government jobs in Los
Angeles, running a $1-billion-a-year agency responsible for sheltering
more than 60,000 of the city's neediest families.

He is also one
of the city's best-paid officials, with a compensation package of about
$450,000 a year, including 10 weeks of vacation.

But despite his
power and perks, in his six-year tenure Montiel has mostly flown beneath
the radar — until a dust-up this month over a move to evict nine public
housing tenants who picketed with others outside his Rancho Cucamonga
home.

The eviction effort infuriated City Council members, who
took to their microphones and rained down nasty sound bites on Montiel —
calling him "Big Brother," "childlike" and manipulative — while angry
tenants upset over city policies roared their approval.

"Where is
Rudy?" Councilman Bill Rosendahl demanded. "Where is he?… I would like
Rudy to come before us and answer every question about this."

Montiel,
49, did not appear, later saying he did not feel the council chamber
was safe, even though it is guarded by metal detectors and armed police
officers. He said he had felt threatened by some of the tenants.

But
some council members wondered who was threatening whom when Montiel's
agency sent a video cameraman to a news conference called that same day
by housing advocates to denounce the eviction efforts. Some, including
Councilman Richard Alarcon, accused Montiel of trying to intimidate
tenants.

In the two weeks since, sharply divergent pictures of
Montiel have emerged at City Hall. Some praise him as a brilliant
reformer who saved a struggling institution that had been plagued by
scandal for decades. Others call him paranoid and vindictive, and
question the terms of his lucrative employment, which also includes a
$3,600-per-month housing allowance and, this year, a $25,000 bonus.

"Given
that he is receiving such a nice package … you would think that [he]
would be up there on a daily basis working with the people he serves,"
Alarcon said. "I get the picture that this is a person who really wants
to stay away from [tenants] and wants to manage them like he would
manage cattle."

The flare-up represents one of the biggest public
debates in years over the person who leads the largest public housing
authority west of the Mississippi. And it comes as the agency is moving
aggressively to redevelop an aging housing stock, including Jordan Downs
in Watts, where there are ambitious plans to rebuild the barracks-like
complex into an "urban village" with shops and market-rate housing mixed
in among units for the poor.

Those efforts, as well as a related
move to modify how some public housing subsidies are calculated — which
some fear could raise rents — have provoked concern among activists who
are part of a nationwide network fighting what they call "the
privatization of public housing."

"This is a huge philosophical,
political shift where the government is saying they will no longer
ensure that the poorest people have housing that is publicly owned,"
said Barbara Schultz, a lawyer who has sued Montiel on behalf of the
nine tenants who were given notices of eviction, saying he violated
their 1st Amendment rights.

Fifty tenants arrived at Montiel's
home on a Sunday afternoon. What happened next is in dispute. Tenants
say they were peaceful. Lawyers for the housing authority say Montiel's
family was "held captive in their own home" when a "mob" stormed the
house. About 20 San Bernardino County sheriff's deputies responded but
made no arrests.

In person, Montiel, the son of Mexican
immigrants, does not come across as a divisive character. He possesses
courtly manners, a quick, mordant sense of humor and a deep grasp of the
complex rules of affordable housing. At public events he often stands
back while politicians grab the spotlight. Outside of work, he appears
devoted to his family, describing his wife as "the most wonderful woman
in the world."

In an interview, Montiel talked about his job in
religious terms. "What guides my commitment to the poor is my Catholic
faith," he said. "It is about serving the less fortunate. … 'There but
for the grace of God go I.' "

Nevertheless, he remains something
of a cipher to many in the "city family." He doesn't move in the same
social circles and he makes his home in San Bernardino County, 40 miles
away.

Montiel has defended his stewardship, noting that his agency
has received high ratings from the federal Department of Housing and
Urban Development.

"This place was a cesspool, and he turned it
around," said Cheryl Parisi, executive director of the American
Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees District Council 36,
which represents more than 400 workers at Montiel's Housing Authority
of the City of Los Angeles.

But the commotion over the evictions
has prompted some council members to question his leadership.
Technically, the council has no power over the authority. It is a state
agency that administers federal housing money and is overseen by a
commission appointed by Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa.

In the shadows
of city government, the agency has lived a colorful and troubled
existence. Three of the last four executive directors left after
inquiries involving alleged misappropriation of public funds. The
agency's 7,000 public housing units were widely viewed as dangerous and
even out of control, with gang members seizing some apartments for drug
dealing and prostitution.

Montiel arrived in 2004 from El Paso's
housing authority and said he found numerous other examples of
corruption, including employees allegedly cutting themselves checks and
then purging the records from computers. He spent millions on private
investigators and lawyers to root out problems. The effort left Montiel
feeling besieged. He said he received threats against his life.

This
is not the first time Montiel has faced off against a city council.
During his time in El Paso, he also came under fire for what council
members saw as disrespect.

"He refused to appear … numerous
times," said former Mayor Joe Wardy. "He sent a spokesperson. He sent
attorneys. Then he said he didn't feel safe, so he had security
installed in his office with a buzzer because he felt threatened by some
of his tenants."

Montiel described a different kind of conflict
with that council, saying his agency filed a lawsuit against the council
over a development project.

Still, some Los Angeles activists say they are disturbed that Montiel has expressed fear of his tenants.

"You
cannot work with people if you are afraid of them," said Becky
Dennison, co-director of the Los Angeles Community Action Network.

In
the wake of the latest controversy, Montiel said he was working to find
a "political solution" to let the nine tenants keep their housing. He
also said he has no desire to battle the City Council.

"What I want is for us to get back to the business of transforming public housing in Los Angeles," he said.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: