At 22
years old, East Palo Alto's rent control law is no spring chicken — and
city leaders, community groups and others are hoping voters will opt to
strengthen and modernize it at the ballot box Tuesday.
Many blame
the existing rent stabilization ordinance's vagueness and inconsistency
with state law for a string of legal disputes over the past couple of
years between the city and Page Mill Properties, which was the city's
largest landlord until it defaulted on a loan to Wells Fargo Bank and
lost its 101 East Palo Alto buildings to foreclosure earlier this year.
East
Palo Alto and Wells Fargo are on the verge of signing a settlement
agreement that would put to rest nine existing lawsuits over rent hikes
and other issues, City Attorney Vince Ewing said Wednesday.
"The
point of drafting (the ordinance) again was based in large part on the
challenges we had encountered to the ordinance by Page Mill," Ewing
said. "Prior to them, it had been around for years and nobody had
really challenged it."
Ewing described the new ordinance, Measure H, as "less vulnerable to attack."
"Although
an aggressive litigant can always challenge an ordinance at any time,"
Ewing noted. Page Mill blocked the city's previous attempt to put a new
rent control law before voters last year by arguing in court that East
Palo Alto failed to look into potential environmental impacts.
The company declined to comment through a spokesman Wednesday.
If approved by a majority of
voters Tuesday, the new ordinance would limit annual rent increases to
80 percent of the Consumer Price Index, exempt only owner-occupied
duplexes and triplexes from rent control rather than all buildings with
four or fewer units, and strengthen a just cause for eviction section.
It would also incorporate state law allowing landlords to set rent for
protected units at market rates when an existing tenant moves out.
However, rent control would kick in again for new tenants once a base
rent was established.
East Palo Alto Vice Mayor Carlos Romero
has been volunteering with the People for Fair Rent and Affordable
Homes Steering Committee to campaign for the ordinance and said a group
of 40 to 50 volunteers went door to door, sent out a mailer to absentee
voters and distributed 8,000 fliers.
"This campaign is ours to
lose just based on the publicity that Page Mill has brought to the
whole issue of rent control, based on one year of outreach and
intervention and the whole process," Romero said. "It's a question of
just making sure people get to the polls."
Romero said Measure H
would make it easier for the city council to select quality candidates
for the rent board by eliminating the landlord, tenant and other
categories, and simplify the process by which landlords can petition
for individual rent adjustments, among other advances.
"Bringing the law into sync with the state law was paramount, and we've done that," he added.
Should
voters approve the ordinance Tuesday, it will take about a month for
the new law to go into effect, Romero said. The rent board, city staff
and a consultant will then need to spend a couple of months developing
regulations for its implementation, he said.
The ordinance has no organized opposition, and Romero said city officials haven't seen any informal protests either.
"The opposition that we had last time was from Page Mill Properties," Romero said. "They're pretty much out of the picture."
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.