East Harlem residents claim 'predator investor' is trying to drive up rent and expel them

Friday, May 21, 2010
Juan Gonzalez
NY Daily News

Like many New Yorkers, retired railroad engineer Hilary Saunders lived for decades in a rent-stabilized Mitchell-Lama apartment - a place a working-class guy like him could afford.

It was in Schomburg Plaza, two East Harlem high-rises that overlook Central Park.

But these days, Saunders and 4,000 other tenants at Schomburg and several other former Manhattan
Mitchell-Lama developments are battling to keep their homes affordable.
They are victims, they claim, of a "predatory investor," one of many
that swept through the city during the housing bubble.

Such investors gobbled up hundreds of rent-stabilized buildings with big money from Wall Street,
then tried to force out old tenants and drive up rents. Then the
housing market crashed many owners can't meet their heavy debt load.

Tenants say their landlord, New Jersey-based Urban American Management, is so deep in debt it's trying to suck them dry.

The firm, backed by a Morgan Stanley-created
investment fund, paid $918 million for the properties in 2007 at the
height of the housing bubble. That was three times what the buildings
had sold for only two years earlier.

"We're tired of being treated like second-class citizens in our own
building," Saunders said Thursday. He and other tenants met with city Controller John Liu and other elected officials Thursday to plead for help.

"The new tenants get new kitchen cabinets, granite countertops, wood
floors," Saunders said. "We get nothing new, and maintenance keeps
getting worse."

Then there are the huge electric bills. Most of the developments use
electricity for heating and power. Under prior owners, heating and
electric were included in the total rent bill.

More than a year ago, Urban American installed separate meters for every apartment and started charging for electricity.

"Tenants were suddenly hit with electric bills of from $400 to as much as $1,000 a month," said Dina Levy, head of organizing at the Urban Homesteading Assistance Board.

Doug Eisenberg,
the company's chief operating officer, admits there was a "timing"
problem. The new metering began in the middle of winter and "tenants
were rightfully scared" about the huge new charges, he said.

So scared that they filed complaints with the Public Service Commission, and the commission rolled back the increases.

Eisenberg says his company still wants to find a way to bill for power separate from heating.

"We firmly believe that we as a business need to be responsible citizens to reduce our carbon footprint," he said.

Eisenberg also rejects the label of "predatory investor."

"We go to great lengths to make sure our residents are treated with
decency and respect," he said. "These buildings were falling apart, and
we've improved them. We haven't tried to force old tenants to leave.

"And we've been able to pay our debt service every month we've owned the buildings," he added.

"That's utter nonsense," said Levy. "Urban American is the poster
child for predatory investing. This was one of the most insane deals of
the real estate boom, and there's no way they can pay their debt with
the rent rolls from these buildings."

Along with state Sen. Bill Perkins
from Harlem and state Assemblyman Micah Kellner, the tenants are
demanding that Eisenberg produce audited statements that would show the
health of the financial status of the buildings and would justify the
huge electricity charges.

Tenant advocates say these Mitchell-Lama buildings are only a tiny
portion of the 100,000 apartments that predatory investors purchased
during the housing crash that are now drowning in debt.

All Saunders and his neighbors want to do is pay a rent they can afford and be left alone.

jgonzalez@nydailynews.com

Help build power for renters' rights: