East Linda landlord must pay $11,000

Tuesday, March 15, 2011
Rob Young
Appeal-Democrat

A Yuba County judge has ordered a landlord to pay more than $11,000 in damages to tenants who filed claims about living conditions at College Park Manor apartments on Country Club Court in east Linda.

Judge Stephen Berrier also ordered landlord Ayad Hussain, of Clovis, to make corrections within 60 days, or pay for the tenants' relocation costs.

Thirteen claims for $7,500 each were filed Dec. 14. Berrier ruled Friday in favor of five and dismissed others, either because the plaintiffs did not pursue them or were found to be unauthorized residents of the complex.

New managers seem to be making progress, Berrier wrote, but substantial evidence was presented showing the "implied covenant of habitability" has been breached "for a substantial period of time."

Hussain, described by associates as semi-retired or retired, has owned the complex for about five years.

Pest control records presented March 7 in Small Claims Court indicated "roaches and rodents are endemic to the apartment complex," Berrier wrote.

Photos showed overflowing garbage containers, while a January report by Yuba County building inspectors mentioned fire and safety code violations, including missing or nonfunctioning smoke alarms throughout the complex and exposed wiring "in almost every apartment."

Rats, mice and roaches were found throughout the complex, along with broken handrails and guardrails, the judge wrote.

Greg Miller, maintenance supervisor for Hussain Properties, said Tuesday most of the problems have been corrected. Smoke alarms were replaced immediately after the building inspection report, he said.

"A lot of progress" has been made against roaches and rodents, Miller said.

One tenant, Deborah Lynn Thompson, paid $52 per month out of her own pocket for pest control, saying treatments provided by the landlord were ineffective, Berrier wrote.

Miller responded that the $52 payments were not documented in court.

Thompson, who organized the claims with the help of California Rural Legal Assistance, was awarded $3,125.

Tenant Phyllis Edwards, who complained for two years about roaches, faulty electrical outlets and stove problems, was awarded $1,200.

Berrier denied claims for electronics, appliances and furniture tenants said had been damaged by water leakage or electrical problems, writing that insufficient evidence was presented.

Yuba County Supervisor Andy Vasquez represents the area and appeared at the hearing on Hussain's behalf.

"The apartments are in much better shape than in January," he said.

Vasquez was critical of an article published Jan. 1 in the Appeal-Democrat after the claims were filed, saying tenants who are happy at College Park Manor were not interviewed.

Thompson said other tenants feared retribution if they filed claims. Others could not withhold rent because they receive Section 8 rent assistance from the county, she said.

Vasquez acknowledged Tuesday the article "may have" called attention to long-standing problems at the complex.

"I think (managers) finally got rattled enough" to make changes, Vasquez said.

When Hussain tried to evict tenants who withheld rent because of problems with their apartments, Yuba County Judge Kathleen O'Connor in January ordered rent reductions and imposed a deadline for repairs.

Hussain is trying a second time to evict tenants Jacqueline Roling and Timothy Penn Jr., who contested the first eviction attempt, Berrier wrote. He awarded the couple $1,050 each.

Vasquez said in January that a new management team was making needed changes at College Park Manor.

"Finally a ray of sunshine for some forgotten people," he wrote in a letter to County Administrator Robert Bendorf.

By the time of the March 7 hearing , a new manager, Margaret Miller, had been hired.

Greg Miller, no relation to Margaret Miller, said Tuesday that she left and has been replaced.

"We've made a big improvement with the person I have there now," he said.

Finding a good manager for an apartment in that area is not easy, Greg Miller said.

"We're trying to make this a decent place for people to live," said Greg Miller, who was hired about eight months ago.

Greg Miller credited Vasquez for getting involved and even hosting Sunday barbecues for tenants.

"He's concerned with the area. Linda needs good places to live," Greg Miller said.

Greg Miller said he hasn't confirmed a rumor that Hussain is trying to sell the complex.

"In that area, there are not a lot of takers," he said.

FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together.  This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: