East Palo Alto council approves revised rent law

Wednesday, March 10, 2010
Jessica Bernstein-Wax
San Jose Mercury News

East Palo Alto voters will decide whether to approve a new rent stabilization ordinance this June after the city council finalized changes to its existing 22-year-old law late Tuesday night.

After more than four hours of discussion during which some audience members appeared to be on the verge of slumber and one council member left in exasperation, the three remaining council members voted unanimously just before 11 p.m. to submit the revised rent control law to the San Mateo County elections office ahead of a Friday deadline to be placed on the June 8 ballot.

"No one ever said legislation was easy," Vice Mayor Carlos Romero said with a laugh when a community member yawned loudly shortly before the vote.

Council Member Laura Martinez was absent, and Council Member Peter Evans left the meeting at about 9 p.m. after declaring, " I can't stay all night and listen to this — let's move the ordinance."

East Palo Alto originally intended the revised law to go before voters last November, but San Mateo County Superior Court Judge Beth Labson Freeman in September ordered county officials to yank it from ballots saying the city failed to look into potential environmental impacts. Freeman's ruling came in response to a legal challenge by Palo Alto-based Page Mill Properties, then the city's biggest landlord owning an estimated 50 percent of the rental stock.

Early in Tuesday night's meeting, the council voted 3-1 with Evans dissenting to approve the environmental report city staff prepared.

Page Mill and East Palo Alto have been embroiled in a bitter legal dispute since 2008, and the city updated its ordinance in part to close existing loopholes that played a role in numerous lawsuits between the two parties.

In September, a judge appointed Pacific Palisades-based Wald Realty Advisors Inc. as receiver of Page Mill's approximately 1,800 rental units in East Palo Alto after the company missed a $50 million balloon payment to Wells Fargo Bank and later defaulted on the loan.

All 101 buildings reverted to the bank last week, and the city is still negotiating a settlement proposal with receiver Dave Wald for eight remaining lawsuits. City Attorney Vince Ewing said Tuesday that the cases essentially no longer stand since Page Mill has no remaining properties in the city of 32,000.

Robert Maddox, a Wells Fargo representative, attended the meeting, as did Lydia Tan of San Francisco-based nonprofit BRIDGE Housing, which is reportedly in talks with the bank about creating "long-term options" for the properties.

At Tuesday night's meeting, some residents raised concerns about subsidized housing providers getting exemptions from rent control under the new ordinance. In a letter to the council, Rent Stabilization Board Member Robert Allen said he was worried that if BRIDGE or another nonprofit took over Page Mill's units, the entire portfolio would be exempted from paying yearly fees that keep the rent stabilization program running.

"Basically, that's the end of the program," Allen said Tuesday.

However, the council opted to leave that exemption in place.

"Legitimate affordable housing" nonprofits give tenants even greater rent protections than the city's ordinance, Romero said at the meeting.

Wells Fargo's Maddox asked the council to let landlords increase yearly rents based on 100 percent of the Consumer Price Index instead of the 65 percent a majority of council members previously favored to keep up with rising owner expenses. After much debate, the council opted to set the increases at 80 percent of the index each year.

Maddox also said the bank wants to work with city leaders and residents "to provide safe well-managed housing" and doesn't intend to "flip" the apartment complexes.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the
use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright
owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website
in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in
California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such
copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S.
Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for
purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain
permission from the copyright owner.
m.

Help build power for renters' rights: