East Palo Alto mayor, pastor oppose sale of low-income housing

Wednesday, October 12, 2011
Valerie Schmalz
Catholic San Francisco

Wells Fargo Bank plans to sell half of East Palo Alto’s low-income housing to a real estate company whose founder is a billionaire opponent of rent control – and whose representatives reportedly told the city’s mayor it plans to gentrify in one to five years.

The city of East Palo Alto’s mayor and City Council, tenants and affordable housing groups and the pastor of the city’s Catholic church all oppose the sale to Equity Residential. In addition San Francisco Auxiliary Bishop William J. Justice and Rep. Anna Eshoo, D-Palo Alto, have written letters to Wells Fargo urging the bank to take steps to ensure the town does not lose affordable housing.

“We’re trying to stop the sale, which is like standing in front of a train,” said Father Lawrence Goode, pastor of St. Francis of Assisi Parish in East Palo Alto. “They intend to come in and gentrify.”

A petition is circulating against the sale, saying that “Equity Residential has a history of alleged violations of housing laws and disregarding the interests of tenants” and that Equity founder and chairman of the board Sam Zell is a “well-known opponent of rent control and tenant protection laws.”

The deal transferring the 1,800 units in 101 buildings is tentatively scheduled to be concluded in mid-to late October, said Wells Fargo spokesman Alan Elias.

“We are confident that Equity Residential is committed to being a good landlord for the residents of Woodland Park and will abide by all applicable laws and ordinances. Both Wells Fargo and Equity Residential are committed to complying with the existing rent stabilization ordinance,” Elias said.

The buildings were bought up from 2005 to 2008 by Page Mill Properties and aggregated into Woodland Park Apartments. Page Mill raised rents and evicted 400 families before going bankrupt. Wells Fargo acquired the repossessed property when it took over Wachovia Bank and invested $4 million in new roofs and other maintenance before looking for a new buyer.

The city favors a sale to multiple buyers rather than one owner, said East Palo Alto Mayor Carlos Romero.

“My main concern with any purchaser is I don’t want to give anyone that much control in my city so that when I sit down at the table it is an unbalanced equation,” said Romero, who said he is not concerned about Equity founder Zell in particular. “Wells has every right to sell this property to whoever they want.”

Chicago-based Equity Residential did not return a request for comment. The real estate investment company was founded in 1969, and owns more than 160,000 units nationwide. It advertises its units as luxury accommodations, for instance, asking from $2,000 to $2,500 for two-bedroom apartments in Daly City, Foster City and San Mateo.

Zell was a key supporter of Proposition 98, a ballot initiative rejected by voters in 2008, which would have repealed rent control in California. He is the chairman of the Tribune Co., corporate parent of the Los Angeles Times. Capitol Weekly reported in 2008 that Zell’s company, Equity Lifestyle Properties, had filed lawsuits to repeal rent control ordinances in several California cities, including Santa Cruz and San Rafael.

Bishop Justice wrote a letter Sept. 21 saying if the Woodland Park sale reduces the stock of affordable housing “it would be a disaster for many and cause a great deal of community suffering.”

Rep. Eshoo asked the bank in a Sept. 21 letter “to secure a written assurance prior to the sale from any new owner that they will be abide by and conform to the requirements specified in” the city’s rent control and eviction ordinance.

All the rent-controlled Woodland Park units are located on the west side of U.S. 101 at the gateway to Palo Alto’s downtown in an area that is prime for gentrification, with high-density zoning already in place, said Mark Moulton, executive director of the Housing Leadership Council of San Mateo.

“Those 1,800 units represent about 15 percent of all affordable housing in the county,” said Moulton, in an area that lacks enough housing for its working class residents. The Housing Leadership Council is a coalition of 60 community organizations whose mission is to see that more affordable housing is built in San Mateo County and to preserve existing affordable housing.

Rent control makes the small town affordable in an area bounded by the Silicon Valley communities of Palo Alto and Menlo Park, Father Goode said. The town has affirmed rent control six times against challenges and via referendums, most recently in 2010 by 79.6 percent, said Romero. “This is a working class people of color community,” he said.

Romero said he won as mayor by spending $2,200 of his own money and going door to door. Romero sent out no mailings to the 7,700 voters in East Palo Alto. Approximately 3,400 turned out for the 2008 election. Someone willing to spend more money might sway enough voters to change the makeup of the city council and perhaps allow demolition, he said.

“The political winds in any city change quite abruptly,” Romero said. “In four or five years you might get folks on the council who will say, `yeah, it makes sense to gut the west side.’”

Romero said Equity officials told him in discussions prior to the deal that they planned to hold the property from one to five years and then gentrify.

Moulton said even without any specific action, attrition over the years will yield vacancies of about 200 units a year, effectively allowing the company to go forward with creating higher density housing and renting to more affluent residents.

FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together.  This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: