East Palo Alto Residents Explore Westside Development

Wednesday, June 11, 2014
Sue Dremann
Palo Alto Online

During a town hall meeting Monday night, more than 100 East Palo Alto residents said they are willing to support higher density housing -- including a scenario that could add up to 8-story buildings to its west side -- to preserve and expand low-income and affordable housing.

The meeting was held for the purpose of defining a vision for the city's Westside Area Plan and gauging residents' opinions on future development in the area. Westside lies west of U.S. Highway 101 and includes the Woodland, Willows and University Circle neighborhoods, stretching from Menalto Avenue to the Palo Alto border at San Francisquito Creek and Highway 101 to Woodland Avenue.

The area is part of the city's "Vista 2035" vision plan, which serves as a blueprint for what residents want the city to look like for future generations in terms of housing, parking, safety and quality of life. The plan will replace the city's state-mandated 1999 general plan, which was adopted as an update to East Palo Alto's first general plan in 1986.

The Westside area has been deemed one of the most critically sensitive because it contains the city's largest chunk of rent-controlled housing stock, including 1,800 units owned by one corporate landlord. The 160-acre area comprises roughly half of the city's rental housing with a total of 2,700 units, of which 2,185 are rent-stabilized, city planner Anne Cook said.

But high turnover places rent-stabilized units at risk. The city's rent-stabilization ordinance only protects a unit for the time a particular renter is living there. When a renter moves out, the landlord can raise the rent to the current market rate. That jump can place housing out of reach for many of the city's poorest residents, staff said Monday. A full 75 percent of renters have lived there for less than four years; only five percent have lived in their units for 10 or more years, Cook said.

"Rent stabilization is great as long as you stay in your unit," she said.

A mismatch between East Palo Alto income levels and the formula used to define affordable housing adds to the problem, she added. Affordable housing is defined as a percentage of the area median income, which in San Mateo County is $101,200.

Based on that formula, extremely low income -- 30 percent of the area median -- comes out at $30,360. Very low income is $30,361 to $50,600; low income is $50,601 to $80,960; and moderate income is $80,961 to $121,440, according to the area median income calculations.

Nearly all East Palo Alto households earn less than $75,000 a year, putting them in the low-income or less category. And 35 percent of East Palo Alto households make less than $35,000 a year, according to city statistics.

At Monday's meeting, residents overwhelmingly voiced their support for permanent affordable housing, for preventing displacement of existing residents, for preserving the "right of return" for existing residents if they are moved during construction to units of similar size and rent and for maintaining the city's rent-stabilization program.

They also supported to varying degrees health and safety improvements such as new sidewalks, parks, community centers, lighting and safer access and connectivity across Highway 101, as well as other development concepts that could improve the city's fiscal strength.

If the general plan and zoning are not changed, individual property owners would rehabilitate or redevelop their properties on a parcel-by-parcel basis. Current zoning would limit development to up to 400 units, which would limit incentive to build new housing, staff said. Rent control would remain in place, but rents would continue to rise as tenants move out.

Three development scenarios -- based on research and discussions by the Westside Area Plan Advisory Committee and city planning staff -- presented to the community Monday would increase the affordable and low-income housing stock in buildings ranging from four to eight stories high. Under one scenario, housing could more than double to 3,500 to 4,500 units. Some would be permanent affordable housing and some would be rent-stabilized. The increase would yield 1,000 to 2,000 net new units with some improved infrastructure, some improved streets, enhanced retail and gathering spaces and pedestrian-overpass improvements across Highway 101.

A second and more popular alternative among residents is a mixed-use, hotel, office and high-density-housing development that would build the same number of housing units as the first scenario, but subsidies from the hotel and offices would allow for the highest number of permanent affordable housing units. The plan proposes building a 300,000- to 600,000-square-foot office complex with Main Street-style retail serving neighborhood uses. Commercially generated revenue would help the city to greatly improve the area's lagging infrastructure and add new streets, parks and open space, including a one- to-two-acre public park, mini parks and a green-belt space along San Francisquito Creek. This plan also promises increased parking for residents.

A third scenario would build mixed-use, high-density housing for a total of 4,000 to 5,500 units (1,500 to 3,000 net new units). The option offers a high number of permanent affordable housing units with retail, new parks, increased parking and new streets and infrastructure.

Residents favored the second and third alternatives, but they wanted assurances that commercial-development funds would largely stay within the Westside and not be disbursed for other city projects. Some residents also questioned if all commercial development would be squeezed onto the Westside rather than in the east side of the city where there is more land.

Staff also hoped Monday to gauge residents' preferences for scale of future developments, asking them to state their preference for three options: 100 apartments in an eight-story building with 20 permanent affordable units; 50 apartments in a five-story building with 10 permanent affordable units or 20 townhomes in a two- to-three-story building with four permanent affordable units. Residents said they would opt for greater density and building height if it meant more affordable units.

Residents also weighed in on levels of affordability they would like to see in new housing projects. For the same amount of subsidy, an affordable-housing developer can build more units for moderate-income households or fewer units for lower-income households, staff said. A developer could build 100 moderate units, each two-bedroom unit for a family of three, that would rent for $1,970 per month; 50 low-income units for $1,530 per month; 35 very-low-income units renting for $1,100 or 25 extremely low income units renting for $660.

The majority of residents wanted the housing mix to largely include units for low-income and very-low-income residents. But Millicent Grant, East Palo Alto Senior Center president, cautioned that many seniors fall into the extremely low income category, and they would be forced out of housing if there is an inadequate supply of extremely low rental units.

"What about having senior housing? Don't forget your seniors. They are the ones who created this city," she said.

Rent Stabilization Board Member Midge Dorn also asked staff to look into the consequences of demolishing buildings. She questioned if the rent ordinance's protections would be transferable to demolished units.

But everyone agreed they don't want a repeat of the University Circle development, which demolished the run-down Whiskey Gulch area -- the closest thing the city had to a downtown -- and turned it into offices for law firms. The site has no real access or amenities for the community, residents said.

"Nobody wants another University Circle. It's a barricade to the community; it's a project that turned its back on the community," Cook said.

Residents also said they want more over-the-freeway connections that will restore unity and access between the west and east sides of the city.

The Westside Area Plan Advisory Committee will meet to discuss Monday's results on June 16 at 6:30 p.m. at East Palo Alto City Hall. The City Council will receive an update on July 2. Another town hall meeting will take place in September, with a draft-plan meeting in October.

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: