It seems the Tenants Together activists are empowered once again to establish the ”Just Cause for Eviction Law” in Merced.
Members have already marched to the City Clerk’s office and delivered nearly 4,000 signatures from residents in a referendum effort that they say explains, “The importance of protecting renters’ rights and standing up to real estate special interests that control the current City Council.”
After a detailed review, City Manager and Clerk John Bramble and Assistant City Clerk Dana Davidson accepted the petition. The city has until Aug. 16 to verify that the signatures come directly from actual, registered voters.
If successful, the Merced City Council will be tasked with either voting to preserve the Just Cause for Eviction Law, or place the decision before voters.
The Just Cause ordinance, originally approved last year, applies to foreclosed properties and prohibits evictions of renters unless there is specific cause (like nonpayment of rent, nuisance, owner move-in, etc.) for the eviction. Foreclosure alone is not grounds for evicting a tenant under the ordinance. Those opposed to the law say there are plenty of protections for renters already in place. They say it amounts to a double assault on property rights of owners and redevelopment of the local real estate market.
In May, the council voted 4-3 to repeal the law, and last month it backed that decision up during a second reading.
Dean Preston, the San Francisco-based executive director of Tenants Together, highlights the fact that last year the previous council voted to pass the law by a 6-1 vote. Says Preston, “Some of them then got cold feet when the people who were writing campaign checks started saying, ‘We don’t want you to vote for this law.’ But by and large, we had overwhelming support for the law a year ago.”
Former City Council member John Carlisle had been present when the law originally came up for a vote to the council, and had voted to pass the law. Now, according to Carlisle, “It’s interesting that in the beginning there was little to no opposition, and it wasn’t until the law had passed, and went to the first and second readings, that a number of real estate professionals showed up to flex their political muscles and tried to keep it from passing. … I was really quite surprised at one council meeting when a bunch of [Realtors] had come and made public comments because it became really clear to me that the majority of them had not read the ordinance, and if they had, they clearly didn’t understand it. They talked about how foreclosures were a good thing for the community, because when people are evicted they bring in gardeners, and they remodel and spend local money to do this. The real reason in my mind is because it’s easier to sell a house with a lock box on the front of the house as opposed to one with renters already in it.”
In an interview with the Times, Carlisle said the “real reason” for the opposition is “money” and “a power play by [Realtors] to show that they’re back in charge.”
Said Carlisle, “It didn’t work out too well when [Realtors] were in charge last time. I don’t know why it would work out too well this time.”
Preston put it a little harsher on certain city leaders: “Even before it went into effect, current Mayor Stan Thurston and some of the new council members, decided that the most important issue facing the City of Merced, and what they would spend their time and energy on, was not to solve the problems with education, housing, the pools, or the budget issue. The most important thing was to repeal this tenant protection act.”
Mayor Thurston has vehemently denied accusations that he doing anything but keeping the interests of the entire city in mind when voting on the issue.
His colleague Mike Murphy has also criticized Tenants Together activists for not trying to work with the city on a compromise proposal. Councilman Tony Dossetti has said the rights of property owners need to be protected in a state where renters enjoy a variety of existing protections.
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.